MVP BF MFC "426 Memorial Trophy" 2012

[Bartram_Class]

It's not objective, it's rarely right and no-one wants to vote when we get smashed, but it is back™.

Blotted our copybook somewhat last year, Trengove's 5th placing making him the first 426 winner not to finish in the Top 3 of the Bluey.

Rules in 2012 will stay the same:
- Each voter gets 12 votes each week, can hand them out as he/she so wishes.
- Top cumulative vote-getter gets 10, and so on, 9, 8, 7 and 6.
- In the event of a tie in a given round, countback method is adopted (if X gets votes from 10 people, while Y gets votes from 9 people, X will get the points).

----------------------------------------------

Honour Roll (Bluey Truscott placings in brackets)

2011 - Jack Trengove (5th)
2010 - Brad Green (1st)
2009 - Aaron Davey (1st)
2008 - Brad Green (3rd)
2007 - Nathan Jones (2nd)
2006 - Brock McLean (3rd)
2005 - Brent Moloney (3rd)
2004 - Jeff White (1st)

Record Season Total: Aaron Davey (2009, 111)
Record Game Total: Colin Sylvia (2009, Rd. 9, 244)

------------------------------------------------------

Round 1 v. Brisbane

10 - Magner (104) (23 touches at 70%, 4 marks, 4 clearances, 4 tackles, 2.0)
9 - Trengove (56) (17 touches at 47%, 6 marks, 8 tackles, 1 GA, 1.1)
8 - Watts (35) (18 touches at 83%, 5 marks, 3 R50, 3 tackles, 1.0)
7 - Jones (23) (20 touches at 60%, 4 marks, 4 clearances, 3 I50s, 4 tackles)
6 - Howe (23) (10 touches at 60%, 5 marks, 2 tackles, 2.1)

Round 2 v. West Coast

10 - Clark (98) (12 touches at 67%, 5.0, 4 1%ers)
9 - Jones (96) (27 touches at 81%, 5 clearances, 2.0, 3 tackles)
8 - Magner (93) (32 touches at 50%, 4 marks, 11 clearances,, 5 R50s, 3 tackles)
7 - Rivers (15) (13 touches at 62%, 5 marks, 9 1%ers, 2 R50s)
6 - McDonald (5) (17 touches at 76%, 4 marks, 5 R50s, 8 1%ers)

Round 3 v. Richmond

10 - Howe (142) (24 touches at 50%, 12 marks, 4 contested marks, 5 R50s, 2.1)
9 - Jones (52) ((17 touches at 71%, 3 marks, 7 I50s, 5 clearances, 1.0)
8 - Clark (34) (8 touches at 62%, 5 marks, 4 I50s, 1 GA, 2.3)
7 - Watts (31) (15 touches at 67%, 9 marks, 2 contested marks, 2 I50s, 1.0)
6 - Frawley (28) (13 touches at 69%, 2 marks, 8 R50s, 5 tackles, 6 1%ers)

Round 4 v. Western Bulldogs

10 - Rivers (94) (15 touches at 80%, 7 marks, 6 R50s, 9 1%ers)
9 - Bate (70) (20 touches at 75%, 6 marks, 3 clearances, 4 tackles, 2.1)
8 - Moloney (29) (17 touches at 53%, 9 clearances, 3 I50s, 4 tackles, 1.2)
7 - Jones (27) (22 touches at 55%, 5 clearances, 4 I50s, 5 tackles)
6 - Howe (18) (12 touches at 58%, 3 marks, 2 CMs, 3 I50s, 2 tackles)

Round 5 v. St Kilda

10 - Jones (84) (27 touches at 67%, 7 clearances, 5 I50s, 6 tackles, 2.1)
9 - McKenzie (70) (14 touches at 50%, 4 clearances, 8 tackles, 5 1%ers)
8 - McDonald (54) (19 touches at 89%, 3 marks, 6 R50s, 10 1%ers, 5 tackles)
7 - Grimes (30) (27 touches at 59%, 4 marks, 2 CMs, 5 R50s, 7 tackles)
6 - Magner (28) (20 touches at 45%, 15 CPs, 7 clearances, 8 tackles)

Round 6 v. Geelong

10 - Clark (116) (21 touches at 62%, 14 CPs, 8 marks, 6 CMs, 4.2)
9 - Frawley (51) (19 touches at 84%, 7 marks, 7 R50s, 4 tackles, 5 1%ers)
8 - Jones (50) (19 touches at 74%, 5 marks, 3 clearances, 2.1, 4 tackles)
7 - Grimes (15) (24 touches at 71%, 4 marks, 4 clearances, 2 1%ers)
6 - Jamar (13) (10 touches at 70%, 4 marks, 40 HOs, 2 clearances)

Round 7 v. Hawthorn

10 - Clark (153) (13 touches at 77%, 9 marks, 4 CMs, 3.2, 4 tackles)
9 - Bartram (41) (16 touches at 100%, 10 marks, 5 R50s, 4 tackles, 4 1%ers)
8 - Magner (32) (17 touches at 71%, 8 marks, 4 CMs, 3 I50s, 1.0)
7 - Frawley (31) (16 touches at 88%, 7 marks, 5 R50s, 11 1%ers)
6 - Jones (28) (21 touches at 76%, 10 CPs, 4 tackles, 3 R50s)

Round 8 v. Sydney

10 - Watts (119) (34 touches at 76%, 11 marks, 8 R50s, 3 1%ers)
9 - Blease (72) (29 touches at 55%, 3 marks, 10 clearances, 4 R50s, 3 1%ers)
8 - Jones (59) (22 touches at 64%, 3 marks, 8 clearances, 3 R50s, 4 tackles, 2.1)
7 - Grimes (14) (23 touches at 78%, 9 marks, 4 R50s, 3 bounces)
6 - Clark (6) (16 touches at 62%, 6 marks, 14 HOs, 7 I50s, 4 clearances)

Round 9 v. Carlton

10 - Blease (54) (17 touches at 59%, 5 marks, 4 I50s, 1.1)
9 - Clark (35) (12 touches at 58%, 2 CMs, 3.4, 1 GA)
8 - Jones (29) (27 touches at 74%, 5 marks, 5 tackles, 3 I50s, 1.0)
7 - Bail (24) (24 touches at 58%, 5 marks, 8 I50s, 5 1%ers, 3 tackles)
6 - Rivers (20) (22 touches at 86%, 6 marks, 2 CMs, 4 R50s, 4 1%ers)

Round 10 v. Essendon

10 - Rivers (59) (20 touches at 70%, 6 marks, 6 tackles, 5 R50s, 7 1%ers)
9 - Watts (53) (24 touches at 88%, 7 marks, 7 R50s, 10 1%ers, 4 tackles)
8 - Jones (49) (26 touches at 81%, 8 clearances, 5 I50s, 9 tackles, 1.0)
7 - Garland (49) (20 touches at 65%, 11 marks, 4 I50s, 1 GA, 2.2)
6 - Grimes (48) (26 touches at 85%, 5 marks, 4 I50s, 3 R50s, 2 tackles)

Round 11 v. Collingwood

10 - Jones (99) (31 touches at 81%, 14 CPs, 5 clearances, 5 I50s, 5 R50s)
9 - Clark (78) (16 touches at 62%, 9 marks, 4 CMs, 8 HOs, 4.1)
8 - Grimes (75) (25 touches at 64%, 7 marks, 8 I50s, 2 R50s, 5 tackles)
7 - Howe (35) (18 touches at 78%, 7 marks, 5 CMs, 3 tackles, 2.0)
6 - Frawley (16) (11 touches at 73%, 6 marks, 6 tackles, 3 1%ers)

Round 12 - BYE

Round 13 v. GWS

10 - Jones (69) (33 touches at 76%, 7 clearances, 6 I50s, 3 tackles, 0.2)
9 - Rivers (60) (15 touches at 73%, 7 marks, 4 CMs, 6 1%ers, 4.1)
8 - Watts (47) (27 touches at 70%, 7 marks, 4 I50s, 3 I50s, 2 bounces)
7 - Clark (37) (11 touches at 45%, 3 marks, 2 clearances, 4.1)
6 - McDonald (26) (26 touches at 73%, 4 marks, 4 R50s, 5 1%ers, 3 tackles)

Round 14 v. Brisbane

10 - Sylvia (28) (21 touches at 67%, 7 marks, 6 I50s, 5 tackles, 1.0)
9 - Martin (25) (21 touches at 71%, 7 marks, 20 HOs, 8 I50s, 4 clearances)
8 - Howe (21) (21 touches at 76%, 7 marks, 3 CMs, 4 tackles, 3 1%ers, 1.0)
7 - Blease (10) (10 touches at 80%, 3 marks, 2 tackles, 3 1%ers, 2.1)
6 - Sellar (8) (11 touches at 64%, 3 I50s, 4 R50s, 11 1%ers, 3 tackles)

Round 15 v. Richmond

10 - Jones (62) (25 touches at 80%, 9 clearances, 5 I50s, 6 tackles, 1.0)
9 - Sylvia (38) (25 touches at 52%, 4 clearances, 7 tackles, 3 I50s, 1.0)
8 - Martin (24) (18 touches at 56%, 6 marks, 20 HOs, 2 I50s, 2.0)
7 - Nicholson (19) (18 touches at 83%, 8 marks, 8 R50s, 6 tackles, 4 1%ers)
6 - Frawley (15) (20 touches at 75%, 10 marks, 6 R50s, 4 1%ers)

Round 16 v. Fremantle

10 - Martin (37) (19 touches at 74%, 7 marks, 26 HOs, 5 clearances, 5 I50s, 2.0)
9 - McDonald (31) (17 touches at 71%, 5 marks, 3 CMs, 6 R50s, 7 1%ers)
8 - Sylvia (30) (23 touches at 65%, 8 clearances, 4 I50s, 7 tackles, 1.0)
7 - Grimes (15) (22 touches at 55%, 7 marks, 5 clearances, 4 R50s, 6 tackles)
6 - McKenzie (12) (20 touches at 65%, 10 tackles, 2 clearances, 2 I50s)

Round 17 v. Port Adelaide

10 - Grimes (58) (32 touches at 75%, 11 marks, 6 I50s, 4 tackles)
9 - Jones (30) (26 touches at 81%, 6 clearances, 5 tackles, 1.0)
8 - Jetta (10) (18 touches at 83%, 4 marks, 6 I50s, 3 tackles)
7 - Nicholson (6) (22 touches at 68%, 6 marks, 6 R50s, 3 tackles)
6 - Green (4) (16 touches at 56%, 7 marks, 4 I50s, 7 tackles, 2.3)

Round 18 v. North Melbourne

10 - Jones (76) (32 touches at 84%, 4 marks, 10 clearances, 4 tackles, 1.0)
9 - Moloney (23) (29 touches at 79%, 3 marks, 3 clearances, 5 I50s, 4 tackles)
8 - Grimes (18) (23 touches at 78%, 5 marks, 2 I50s, 3 R50s, 5 bounces, 1 GA)
7 - McDonald (9) (23 touches at 74%, 5 marks, 4 R50s, 3 tackles, 13 1%ers)
6 - Howe (8) (20 touches at 75%, 6 marks, 5 clearances, 4 I50s, 4 tackles, 1.0)

Round 19 v. Gold Coast

10 - Jones (42) (29 touches at 97%, 7 clearances, 4 I50s, 5 tackles, 3 1%ers)
9 - Green (32) (14 touches at 64%, 7 marks, 4 CMs, 5 M50s, 3 I50s, 5.2)
8 - Howe (23) (23 touches at 65%, 8 marks, 6 CMs, 7 I50s, 1.0)
7 - Sylvia (15) (24 touches at 67%, 6 marks, 3 clearances, 3 tackles, 2.0)
6 - Tapscott (8) (18 touches at 72%, 9 marks, 5 I50s, 3 tackles, 1.0)

Round 20 v. St Kilda

10 - Blease (43) (20 touches at 70%, 8 marks, 3 I50s, 3 tackles, 5.0)
9 - Grimes (28) (29 touches at 69%, 5 marks, 4 I50s, 3 R50s, 3 tackles, 1 GA)
8 - Jones (24) (26 touches at 85%, 4 clearances, 4 I50s, 5 tackles)
7 - Rivers (9) (21 touches at 86%, 8 marks, 2 CMs, 6 1%ers)
6 - Macdonald (9) (27 touches at 78%, 7 marks, 4 R50s, 4 tackles, 2 1%ers)

Round 21 v. GWS

10 - Howe (31) (17 touches at 59%, 6 marks, 4 I50s, 7 tackles, 3.3)
9 - Grimes (30) (24 touches at 79%, 7 marks, 3 I50s, 9 tackles, 1.0)
8 - Dunn (30) (28 touches at 86%, 10 marks, 6 I50s, 4 R50s, 5 1%ers)
7 - Jones (13) (24 touches at 83%, 4 clearances, 3 tackles, 2 I50s)
6 - Trengove (13) (23 touches at 57%, 4 marks, 4 I50s, 2.1)

Round 22 v. Adelaide

10 - Sylvia (39) (34 touches at 76%, 4 marks, 5 clearances, 5 I50s)
9 - Howe (36) (14 touches at 79%, 8 marks, 3 I50s, 3 tackles, 1.3)
8 - Jones (28) (25 touches at 68%, 8 clearances, 5 I50s, 4 tackles, 1.0)
7 - Bail (26) (22 touches at 64%, 6 marks, 6 I50s, 2 tackles, 1 GA)
6 - Grimes (15) (23 touches at 91%, 7 marks, 3 clearances, 3 I50s)

Round 23 v. Fremantle

10 - Grimes (17) (23 touches at 65%, 3 marks, 5 clearances, 6 tackles)
9 - Sylvia (11) (25 touches at 72%, 4 marks, 5 clearances, 6 I50s)
8 - McDonald (9) (18 touches at 72%, 7 marks, 5 R50s, 8 1%ers)
7 - Nicholson (8) (17 touches at 59%, 4 marks, 6 R50s, 5 1%ers)
6 - Frawley (8) (10 touches at 70%, 2 marks, 2 R50s, 4 1%ers)

------------------------------------------------------

Leaderboard

162 - Jones
94 - Grimes
70 - Howe
69 - Clark
53 - Sylvia
49 - Rivers
44 - McDonald
42 - Watts
40 - Frawley
36 - Blease
32 - Magner
27 - Martin
21 - Nicholson
17 - Moloney
15 - McKenzie, Green, Trengove
14 - Bail
9 - Bate, Bartram
8 - Jetta, Dunn
7 - Garland
6 - Jamar, Sellar, Tapscott, Macdonald

 

[LeverPuller]

Fingers crossed I can actually give a vote after the game in Mordor.

 

[d33my]

Great stuff BC. Whenever I see this thread it really feels like the footy's finally back.

 

[Crimson Azure]

Best round if I remember correctly was Col vs the Hawks. How he got 30+ possessions & 4/5 goals in a team that got smashed I'll never know.

 

[Bartram_Class]

Best round if I remember correctly was Col vs the Hawks. How he got 30+ possessions & 4/5 goals in a team that got smashed I'll never know.

3 Brownlow votes to boot also IIRC.

Given he got 20 lots of 12 votes in that game, I can't really see it being beaten for a while.

 

[Captain Jack]

3 Brownlow votes to boot also IIRC.

Given he got 20 lots of 12 votes in that game, I can't really see it being beaten for a while.

Here's hoping we're never that bad again.

 

[CowboyFromHell]

Great stuff BC. Whenever I see this thread it really feels like the footy's finally back.

I'll second this! We can have all the threads here in the world, but THIS is the one that screams "FOOTY IS BACK!" Great work BC!

 

[Bartram_Class]

Round 1 updated.

 

[Crimson Azure]

Thanks BC.

Defiantly not the best pic Magner has ever taken thats for sure.

Is anyone seeing Magner as a cross of these two:

&

I'm scared too.

 

[d33my]

Thanks BC.

Defiantly not the best pic Magner has ever taken thats for sure.

Is anyone seeing Magner as a cross of these two:

&

I'm scared too.

And BC, how many times in 426 history has a debutant lead after round 1?

 

[demonfan9]

Having just watched the replay, I didn't think Jones was worthy of votes. He was one of the main culprits in the midfield who let us down at the stoppages. I can't count the amount of times his direct opponent won a clearance, while Jones gave away too much space.

Unfortunately I missed the cut off to post votes, not that mine would have made a difference, but that was definately one key observation I took from the game. I had Magner, Trengove, Watts and Howe in my best so good to see they got recognition.

 

[Bartram_Class]

And BC, how many times in 426 history has a debutant lead after round 1?

Can't be bothered to check, but Tapscott got a fair few in Round 1 last year.

May not have got 10 though.

 

[Bartram_Class]

Round 2 Updated.

Clark's 5 goals get him the 10.

 

[Crimson Azure]

Very close for the 10-9-8 this week. I can't see the real B&F at the end of the year being much different.

 

[Bartram_Class]

Round 3 updated.

New leader.

 

[Bartram_Class]

Round 4 updated.

More votes for Jones.

 

[demonfan9]

I love the kid Howe, but he had just 12 disposals, 3 marks, 2 behinds and 1 tackle, yet somehow snagged votes? I think there was a bit too much excitement about those speckies.

 

[Bartram_Class]

I love the kid Howe, but he had just 12 disposals, 3 marks, 2 behinds and 1 tackle, yet somehow snagged votes? I think there was a bit too much excitement about those speckies.

For what its worth, the next highest vote-getter was Clark, who only really played a half, so not sure votes for him would have been any more justified.

 

[demonfan9]

Fair call.

 

[Crimson Azure]

I love the kid Howe, but he had just 12 disposals, 3 marks, 2 behinds and 1 tackle, yet somehow snagged votes? I think there was a bit too much excitement about those speckies.

First sentence of the OP says it all.

 

[demonfan9]

Haha yes it does.

 

[Bartram_Class]

Updated for Round 5.

Jones yet to have a vote-less game.

 

[Rudeurrection]

BC, it would appear you have added both Tom McDonald and Joel MacDonald's points under the same name on the leaderboard. Should read 8 votes Tom McDonald 6 votes Joel MacDonald.

 

[Bartram_Class]

BC, it would appear you have added both Tom McDonald and Joel MacDonald's points under the same name on the leaderboard. Should read 8 votes Tom McDonald 6 votes Joel MacDonald.

Sure?

The 6 votes in Round 2 went to Tom. Here is the votes thread: http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/showthread.php?t=928859

Glad you are keeping me on my toes though.

 

[d33my]

It's a pity there's not a 'No. of Goddard hissy-fits induced' stat, because I'm sure McKenzie would have broken the ton last weekend.