- Joined
- Apr 10, 2004
- Posts
- 12,680
- Reaction score
- 23
- Location
- Melbourne
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
- Other Teams
- Bushrangers
Been getting into more of this guy's stuff lately and he is interesting at the very least. I prefer music to lyrics so it makes it a bit harder to appreciate some of the droning folk stuff he made early on with precious little melody involved. His voice is a bit irritating on those early albums, and it makes marathon songs like "Visions of Johanna" hard to sit through.
The melodies on "Tangled Up In Blue" and "Knocking on Heavens Door" make me wish he spent more time writing songs in that vein. These songs also had better production which might have helped (as with the 80s track "Jokerman").
Late in his career he seemed to write some dark, menacing stuff that was made all the more interesting by the absolute disintegration of his voice (it was ordinary to start with, but by the 90s it had just turned into something that was painful to listen to). Classic songs like Love Sick, Mississippi and Things Have Changed are maybe strangely enhanced by his terrible voice though. McCartney though, at the same age, hasn't seen his voice disintegrate a hell of a lot in comparison. Dylan today is indistinguishable from Dylan's voice of the 60s.
Anyone heard Dylan's whole catalogue? If so what are the highlights, lowlights and general thoughts on the man?
The melodies on "Tangled Up In Blue" and "Knocking on Heavens Door" make me wish he spent more time writing songs in that vein. These songs also had better production which might have helped (as with the 80s track "Jokerman").
Late in his career he seemed to write some dark, menacing stuff that was made all the more interesting by the absolute disintegration of his voice (it was ordinary to start with, but by the 90s it had just turned into something that was painful to listen to). Classic songs like Love Sick, Mississippi and Things Have Changed are maybe strangely enhanced by his terrible voice though. McCartney though, at the same age, hasn't seen his voice disintegrate a hell of a lot in comparison. Dylan today is indistinguishable from Dylan's voice of the 60s.
Anyone heard Dylan's whole catalogue? If so what are the highlights, lowlights and general thoughts on the man?






And his vocals are pretty good too.