Brett Deledio

[no1bankteller]

Id be tempted to give our pick #4 if we had a PP for Tambling, something more aggreable for me would be our second round pick #18/19 and third round pick upgrade (so a swap of third rounders) and a player for Tambling.

Ooops sorry I should have qualified that pick 4 was only on offer if we have PP. I would not trade our only first round pick otherwise and I do not think I would offer the 4th pick for Tambling.

Richmond may want a 4th pick but I think that this is over the odds.

 

[Lyyynnnchy]

Ok! Once you have shot your load we can move right along!

That deal will not get done! However your point that we are undervaluing Deledio is well made and has been well made by a number of sensible WCE poters.

What do I think is a fair trade? (Note I do not think that this would be done by the way but I think its fair.)

How about?

Pick 4 & Lynch (and/or pick ~20), for
Deledio and Tambling (?)

I would love to keep Lynch, I rate him and the value that he brings to this team is far greater then his statistical performance, however I would be happy to trade him to get Deledio.

I see Tambing as an add on and someone that can play as a crumber and provide mecurial change of pace through centre.

Lynch alone wouldnt get a pick inside the top 40 IMO

 

[no1bankteller]

Lynch alone wouldnt get a pick inside the top 40 IMO

Fair enough.

I guess I rate Lynch higher. I attribute this value to him being a very flexible key position player and key position players typically have a far greater value in the market.

 

[Obeanie1]

Lynch alone wouldnt get a pick inside the top 40 IMO

Your kidding right!

Lynch would get a second rounder for him not a problem.

Western Bulldogs would pay that.

Sydney would pay that.

Richmond would pay that.

Big mobile key forwards don't grow on trees mate.

 

[Embers]

Get off the drugs, two average players will not give you a very very good player

We know, thats why were trading them for Brett Deledio

 

[bigburger]

To be honest (Embers your gonna hate me here) I would trade our second pick and Mitch Brown for him. For some reason I get the feeling that Brown will never be as good at West Coast as he would somewhere else. Unless he circums to the fact his spot in the team, now and in years to come is CHB.