Broughton keeper?

[wheels4]

Just wondering what you guys are going to do with Greg Broughton,
Keeper or not?

He's played 6 games and had scores of ; 70,76,90,92,119 and 85.

Im very close to keeping him for the rest of the year.

Cheers.

 

[CaptainChardonnay]

Him and Grimes... Both Keepers...

 

[Hondo]

He's on my list of luxury upgrades if trades allow but I have about 3 other keepers I'd ideally like to upgrade before Broughton.

The weekly scores show that the points are in the midfield you'd be better off getting 6 super-guns in there rather than scrambling in some $450Kish defender for Broughton.

In other words, he'll very likely be my 7th defender at the end.

 

[Jobe Watson]

If I can, I'm going to try and snatch up Drummond for him. But he is scoring quite well.

 

[RWnBluey]

Too early to call, it will be either he or Grimes that will be my 7th back.

Will use one of them in 2 weeks to trade to drummond and then my backline is complete.

 

[abs_of_STEELE]

Not sure for me, depends how/if Chad returns.

 

[remedi]

Either grimes or broughton will be my 7th defender. Both have served me well.

 

[geodke]

why trade a player who is pulling is perfectly good numbers???

 

[Fabregas]

my backline: goddard, fisher, gilbee, drummond, gilbert, newman, grimes (broughton, cheney)

would anyone consider starting broughton ahead of gilbbe or fisher (assuming drummonds back next week)? fisher seems to be struggling with a tag but he may move back to full back if hudghton is out and gilbbe is struggling too

 

[Judd_Magic]

my backline: goddard, fisher, gilbee, drummond, gilbert, newman, grimes (broughton, cheney)

would anyone consider starting broughton ahead of gilbbe or fisher (assuming drummonds back next week)? fisher seems to be struggling with a tag but he may move back to full back if hudghton is out and gilbbe is struggling too

Just trade Fisher for anyone, he's a total spud now.

I'm trading him for Dawson.

 

[smashh]

why trade a player who is pulling is perfectly good numbers???

thats my feeling. just coz they are a rookie?? I'm perfectly happy with Grimes/Broughton as 6th/7th defenders pulling 80/90

 

[BILC]

He might have to be with all my injuries

 

[buttox]

I see him as an ideal 8th defender. if whe your out of trades later and he has to come on he'll do you proud. but will prob not score at true prem rates. prob who knows

 

[Millington Magic]

I'm spewing I didn't pick him up. He has shown us that he can score well, and looks a keeper IMO. But would be a good player to upgrade to Drummond when he drops.

 

[Walesy]

Either grimes or broughton will be my 7th defender. Both have served me well.

exactly! and with the way injuries have been rolling, he'll make for an excellent coverage for whichever backman decides to go down *this* week!

 

[Dirtywhirl]

Will be a keeper for me, more out of necessity than design. Similar situation to Ibbotson last season.

 

[Bender571]

With Broughton doing so well I'm thinking about trading out Chornes for Silvester to free up some cash so I can fix my forward line.

 

[Judd_Magic]

With Broughton doing so well I'm thinking about trading out Chornes for Silvester to free up some cash so I can fix my forward line.

Who is this Silvester guy that everyone keeps talking about and who does he play for? Is he a defender?

I can't find him anywhere when I click on the trade button (not that I am going to trade, was trying to find him in the trade list)

Feels like I am looking for U.Jiboni and need the secret code off Jeffy or something to unlock Silvester. Rofl!

 

[Judd_Magic]

Never mind I found him...

Jarrod Silvester, Richmond, Defender - $83,000. For some reason I was looking for Freo rookies as I thought he was a Freo player. LOL!

Nice score of $83,000 too. Could be another Broughton.

 

[Glenno23]

I think he's a keeper....

I thought after the Melbourne game, my decision was going to be easy on who to play out of Grimes/ Broughton once Drummond returned. Grimes gunned it, he gets the gig, the along comes Broughton with a hail mary!!!

Now i want Drummond to take as long as he likes to get his calf right

 

[I love DELEDIO]

keeper for me his 159 got me over the line this week !!!!!!

 

[lemon chicken]

Was looking at turning Broughton or Grimes into Goddard dont think i'll bother now. My problem will be when Cornes returns who to put on the bench.

 

[Walesy]

My dilema.

I've got Grimes and Broughton filling in for 6 and 7 at the moment...

So who goes to 8 when Cornes comes back from injury?

 

[Walesy]

Was looking at turning Broughton or Grimes into Goddard dont think i'll bother now. My problem will be when Cornes returns who to put on the bench.

(ha! you beat me to it. )

 

[lemon chicken]

(ha! you beat me to it. )

Never thought id be happy to see one of my players get injured. At least that would make it a lot easier.