Brown or Robbo?

[pgm87]

i know this has already been done (my thread finding skills aren't great), but given that fev is all but gone, which wasnt the case when the initial threads started, does anyone think we should consider picking one of brown or robbo up in the PSD?

i know the chances are that neither will play in our next premiership, but i would really consider going for brown.

 

[GibbsOnTheRun]

Brown really struggled this season, and i think that footy has passed him by since his injury. I'd rather we get a young kid who WILL be part of our next premiership

 

[Smell The Glove]

Who would you prefer- Eddie Betts or Trent Knobel?

 

[Matt72]

i know this has already been done (my thread finding skills aren't great), but given that fev is all but gone, which wasnt the case when the initial threads started, does anyone think we should consider picking one of brown or robbo up in the PSD?

i know the chances are that neither will play in our next premiership, but i would really consider going for brown.

Why?

 

[Bentick's My Man.]

I'd be seriously interested in Nathan Brown on 1 year incentive-based, minimum-wage contract

 

[gbatman]

Robbo, we might need a marking forward than a washed up ex-star. Robbo still had form, Brown was finished years ago.

 

[dark blue days]

Who would you prefer- Eddie Betts or Trent Knobel?

The best part about this is we wanted Knobel

 

[Jeremias]

For a second I thought you were asking about Steven Browne vs Mitch Robinson

I've been on the Russell Robertson bandwagon for a while now and my feelings on that issue are becoming stronger now that it's almost a certainty we'll be getting rid of Fev.

Nathan Brown is a money hungry tool. Don't want him anywhere near the CFC.

 

[bluekidjoe]

I'd take Robbo for sure

 

[The Old Dark Navy's]

Dad's army forward line but we need the backup. Whether he plays or not is another thing but we need him if Bradshaw does get injured.

 

[The Toad]

Robbo- Only If he takes a basic wage contract, perhaps we could sit him in the fwd pocket and see what happens. You never know he might just find that old spark and become a handy goal sneak.

 

[Aphrodite]

For a second I thought you were asking about Steven Browne vs Mitch Robinson

I've been on the Russell Robertson bandwagon for a while now and my feelings on that issue are becoming stronger now that it's almost a certainty we'll be getting rid of Fev.

Nathan Brown is a money hungry tool. Don't want him anywhere near the CFC.

My thoughts exactly J but I won't be posting what I really think about Nafan Brown as I cannot stand this self centered, egotistical, attention seeking tosser

 

[Jatz]

robbo yes, brown no.
robbo can still play a bit and would pick him up cheap

 

[albyg]

Definitely Robbo, still has a spring in his step, can take a mark and has a great attitude. I am pretty sure he followed Carlton as a kid as well, giving him a touch more incentive to do well.

 

[Gabagool]

Definitely Robbo. If Fev goes, he would be a huge help. Brown has never been the same since his injury. And as Sam pointed out on the footy show a while back, Nafe is too busy with other shi*e and his heart isn't in it.

 

[Heres Waite]

Definitely Robbo. If Fev goes, he would be a huge help. Brown has never been the same since his injury. And as Sam pointed out on the footy show a while back, Nafe is too busy with other shi*e and his heart isn't in it.

Get Robbo!!! I definatly feel he has something to offer (kicked 5 goals against us anyway). I wants to come to Carlton said so on before the game. Wouldnt cost us to much.

 

[BLUES82]

was hoping to see Robbo play alongside Fev next year - not to be...surely if we wanted Robbo, we would have asked that he be thrown in as part of the McLean deal?