Brownlow

[Frodo]

Who would you say your top three players will be in this years Brownlow count?

 

[dennisismyhero]

1. Blake Caracella
2. Joe Misiti
3. Jason Johnson / Matthew Lloyd

 

[topdon]

1. Jason Johnson
2. Matthew Lloyd
3. Joe Misiti

 

[TD]

1. James Hird - Always a chance if he can stay fit
2. Mark Mercuri - Point to prove and a good pre-season under his belt (backed him at 100-1)
3. Smokin Joe - could easily have won it last year if he hadn't done his knee

 

[windyhill]

For value....Adam Ramanaskaus,if sheedy let him play his flowing game he could go close.I`m gonna back the clasy left footer each way.

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

1. Lloyd
2. J Johnson
3. Hird

 

[Stegelator]

Rama
JJ
Lloyd

 

[mantis]

I refuse to name anyone after last year, 2 games in & I was sure Misiti was going to win it.

 

[BomberBoy]

Mercuri
Johnson
Lloyd

In no particular order

 

[Bomber Spirit]

1. Hird
2. Lloyd
3. Mercuri

 

[USAEagle]

Lloyd and Brownlow...

ought not to be mentioned in the same breath. A full forward is too one dimensional to win a Brownlow Medal. As sharp a shooter as he is, he can never be best on ground for a whole season, because he is only the recipient of every oen else's hard work through the middle and half forward lines. Coleman Medal? Yes. Brownlow? Well, if you look at the last...5 years, if not longer, it has been the exclusive club of mid-fielders or rover/on-ballers that have wone it.

 

[NYMets]

if they are on form:
1. Fletch
2. Mercs
3. JJ

but I have a feeling Chick is going to get it .

 

[windyhill]

Re: Lloyd and Brownlow...

Originally posted by USAEagle
ought not to be mentioned in the same breath. A full forward is too one dimensional to win a Brownlow Medal. As sharp a shooter as he is, he can never be best on ground for a whole season, because he is only the recipient of every oen else's hard work through the middle and half forward lines. Coleman Medal? Yes. Brownlow? Well, if you look at the last...5 years, if not longer, it has been the exclusive club of mid-fielders or rover/on-ballers that have wone it.

Tony Lockett