Changes V Richmond

[jules101]

Out: Dyson, Cole
In: Lonergan, Lovett if he is fit

Other news: NLM may still be 4-6 away... Is going to Sydney to see a specialist and may need surgery

 

[adamcf]

Out: Dyson, Cole
In: Lonergan, Lovett if he is fit

Other news: NLM may still be 4-6 away... Is going to Sydney to see a specialist and may need surgery

Could there be an unchanged line up?

 

[boms]

No changes

Cole did well today doesnt get alot of possies but his class
Dyson showed alot today

 

[Jono B]

No changes

Cole did well today doesnt get alot of possies but his class
Dyson showed alot today

Agree, no changes.

 

[jules101]

No changes

Cole did well today doesnt get alot of possies but his class
Dyson showed alot today

We must be talking about different players...
If lovett is fit he will come in for Dyson, no doubt

 

[boms]

We must be talking about different players...
If lovett is fit he will come in for Dyson, no doubt

If you actually didnt know Lovett is out for 4-6 weeks

 

[jules101]

If you actually didnt know Lovett is out for 4-6 weeks

Really? just got home from the footy... All I know is he is a last minute replacement. Dyson can stay in then..

Still think Cole SHOULD be dropped, he wont be tho...

 

[Crave]

Campo should go....Davey looked to have copped a late knock on the side of his knee, Lloyd's hamstrings still worry me to a fair degree.

 

[jules101]

Campo should go....Davey looked to have copped a late knock on the side of his knee, Lloyd's hamstrings still worry me to a fair degree.

Campo played well I thought, added some class. Davey came back on...

 

[EssendonBombersFC]

Unchanged.

 

[adamcf]

I'd love to see Lonergan in for someone against the Tiges.

 

[kelvin_sheedy]

Out : Dyson
In : Whoever plays well at Bendigo or NLM or someone coming back from injury.

Dyson - same old performance and I'd rather see what Lonergan or Hislop has to offer.

Cole deserves to hold his spot. Some really clean pickups and dash off half back. Slowed down a little due to fitness but did enough for mine.

 

[kelvin_sheedy]

Campo should go....Davey looked to have copped a late knock on the side of his knee, Lloyd's hamstrings still worry me to a fair degree.

Are you crazy man.

He was so important today it is not funny. So many crucial possessions that set us up from congestions.

Added the class and quality around the ball that we have been missing.

 

[monty1104]

Just heard on the news that Richo has all but ruled himself out for this week!

 

[bomberstomake8]

the only possible omission is dyson.... i think he will be playing though.

sheedy acknowledged both cole and campo after the match and said they were pretty good. he wont kick either of them out for next week. i think neither deserve to be omitted too

 

[Dr Moose]

Unchanged line-up but I wouldn't leave McVeigh up forward. It was great to get those late goals but he really was doubting himself in front of goals today.

 

[GoDons]

I thought Dyson was great today, it'd be a bit rough to drop him in my opinion.

In: Lovett, Welsh (if fit)
Out: Cole, Slattery

I thought Slatts struggled a bit today and I'd like to see Welshy come back in and have a crack down back. Lovett replaces Cole on a wing. If Welsh isn't fit, Slatts should hold his place or Heffernan should be looked at depending on how he goes for Bendigo.

 

[jules101]

I thought Dyson was great today, it'd be a bit rough to drop him in my opinion.

In: Lovett, Welsh (if fit)
Out: Cole, Slattery

I thought Slatts struggled a bit today and I'd like to see Welshy come back in and have a crack down back. Lovett replaces Cole on a wing. If Welsh isn't fit, Slatts should hold his place or Heffernan should be looked at depending on how he goes for Bendigo.

SLatts played well defensively today, would not drop him

 

[GoDons]

SLatts played well defensively today, would not drop him

I've never really liked him and that probably influenced my opinion somewhat. I thought he stood off Lappin a bit and he didn't provide enough in doing so. He'll probably hold his sopt, as will Cole, but they're the changes I would like to see.

 

[retroparty]

How far away is Gumby?

 

[bomberstomake8]

How far away is Gumby?

3 weeks from memory...
he wont play afl level the year imo.. unless we have some big injuries.. we have enough height as it is....
itll be good to see him in 2008

 

[Wahooti Fandango]

I thought Dyson was great today, it'd be a bit rough to drop him in my opinion.

In: Lovett, Welsh (if fit)
Out: Cole, Slattery

I thought Slatts struggled a bit today and I'd like to see Welshy come back in and have a crack down back. Lovett replaces Cole on a wing. If Welsh isn't fit, Slatts should hold his place or Heffernan should be looked at depending on how he goes for Bendigo.

I thought Slattery was really good today. Although Cole was not great today his bursts out of the backline were a good sign. His big body is very useful in defence. I don't think Lovett will be fit to play next week.

 

[dave_27]

Look Im a Dyson fan so I may be a little bias but I thought he used the ball very well today. Some of his passes were beautiful.

He needs to get more of the ball but I wouldnt drop him after what was probably his best performance for this year.

He'd take alot of confidence from today.

 

[Crave]

Campo played well I thought, added some class. Davey came back on...

I wouldnt call it class that he adds. I think we have better available in the VFL. Lonergan, Heff...he's only in while we have injuries to running players...namely NLM, Lovett, Welsh & Jetta.

 

[Crave]

Look Im a Dyson fan so I may be a little bias but I thought he used the ball very well today. Some of his passes were beautiful.

He needs to get more of the ball but I wouldnt drop him after what was probably his best performance for this year.

He'd take alot of confidence from today.

Ill agree, he was good today. Hope he can maintain some momentum going into next weekend.