Changes Vs Pies next week

[RichosGuns]

OUT:
Raines: Injured
Hughes: Took some marks, but with Riewoldt and Morton having good games at Coburg he needed to do more
Polo: Did nothing, highly overrated on this board
Hyde: Shit

IN:
Johnson
Morton
White
Tivdendale

Others:
- Polak hasn't done anything in either match this year and wouldn't be far away from being replaced by Luke McGuane
- Jake King had a shocker giving up about 6-10 goals. But he still tried, needs a couple of solid weeks to consolidate
- Jordan McMohan was the biggest waste of pick 18 or 19 ever. I can tell he will be the typical "up when where up" and "down when where down player." Should be given no immunity and if he continues with performances like today he should be dropped

 

[Croat tiger]

OUT:
Raines: Injured
Hughes: Took some marks, but with Riewoldt and Morton having good games at Coburg he needed to do more
Polo: Did nothing, highly overrated on this board
Hyde: Shit

IN:
Johnson
Morton
White
Tivdendale

Others:
- Polak hasn't done anything in either match this year and wouldn't be far away from being replaced by Luke McGuane
- Jake King had a shocker giving up about 6-10 goals. But he still tried, needs a couple of solid weeks to consolidate
- Jordan McMohan was the biggest waste of pick 18 or 19 ever. I can tell he will be the typical "up when where up" and "down when where down player." Should be given no immunity and if he continues with performances like today he should be dropped

Not tivendale,connors yes.

 

[want2spoodge_pettifer]

yes - cleve is out. although i think he is now starting to understand what it's going to take. morton should come in. edwards should take someone's spot. i don't know who. but right now we'd get more value out of him than mcmahon, who has been horrid. i wanna give him a little more time though.

 

[lids2004roar]

OUT: ___ IN:

Raines ... Johnson
Hughes ... Riewoldt
Polo ... White
Hyde ... Morton


Polo will be a good player, just needs another pre season as he wasn't able to build up any strength after his shoulder reco last year.

 

[JSFish]

Hyde for Johnno
Cleve for Jack
Morton for Polo...Morton plays forward in Lids' pos, Lids into the midfield to replace Polo
Raines for White I guess.

 

[richcogs]

Before hyde is ousted TAMBLING should be! WAS DISGRACEFUL TODAY! DISGRACEFUL! Alot worse than last week!

Morton, Johnson and White in next week for Raines (injured), Tambling (omitted) and possibly Hyde.

Deledio into the midfield (come on 11 possies in the last quarter there), Morton can play his forward role just as well! White definitely deserves a spot after yesterday, looked a lot better, ALOT!

BTW those who are saying the likes of Connors and Edwards should come in obviously didn't watch the game yesterday. Both didn't do enough to warrant a spot. White was BRILLIANT!

 

[Tigerland]

Before hyde is ousted TAMBLING should be! WAS DISGRACEFUL TODAY! DISGRACEFUL! Alot worse than last week!

Morton, Johnson and White in next week for Raines (injured), Tambling (omitted) and possibly Hyde.

BTW those who are saying the likes of Connors and Edwards should come in obviously didn't watch the game yesterday. Both didn't do enough to warrant a spot. White was BRILLIANT!

______________________________________________

Tambling can improve. Hyde has show us his best - and it's shithouse.

Surely Tuck must be on shaky ground after that effort - will be gone when Cogs gets back.

 

[richcogs]

______________________________________________

Tambling can improve. Hyde has show us his best - and it's shithouse.

Surely Tuck must be on shaky ground after that effort - will be gone when Cogs gets back.

Yes he can and will, but after THAT performance others don't deserve to be dropped before him! Watch the game over if you don't see that. Just because he's a high draft pick and we have so much hope pinned on him doesn't mean he should be a walk in. He needs some pressure placed on him to improve!

 

[itsintheblood]

Out: Hyde (never to play again), Hughes (soft, lazy, terrible kick), Polo (I don't know why this guy gets a game). Shaky ground, Tuck, Mcmahon.

In: Riewoldt, morton, tivendale.

Geez it's frustrating. Our coach has no idea.

 

[richcogs]

Out: Hyde (never to play again), Hughes (soft, lazy, terrible kick), Polo (I don't know why this guy gets a game). Shaky ground, Tuck, Mcmahon.

In: Riewoldt, morton, tivendale.

Geez it's frustrating. Our coach has no idea.

Not White did you see him play yesterday?

P.S. Edwards and Connors didn't do enough yesterday to deserve a spot next week. Maybe in 2 weeks time!

 

[C-Dog]

Not tivendale,connors yes.

would love to see that

but wont happen

 

[_RT_]

Out: Raines (injured) Hyde(omitted forever) Pettifer(junk time stats 2 weeks straight don't hide shit efforts the first 3 quarters)
Ins: Johnson (people may hate him but we missed him in the middle today) White (younger than Hyde and still has improvement left) Morton(straight swap for Pettifer)

 

[sante]

Look at the ferals go...what a joke you are.

IN: Johnson, Morton & Tivendale
OUT: Hughes (not entirely his fault that our F50 entries are shit.) Hyde & Raines


Drop Polo after one game when he is still underdone?

 

[richcogs]

I can't see Terry passing on White this week, he was at the game yesterday. Can't say not to that sought of performance!

 

[Richo Man]

White better not come in! Sure he played well yesterday, in the reserves. He's not an AFL player, anyone can kill it in the reserves, exaggerating a bit but you put White in our side and he'd do nothing.
Id bring in Johnson, Morton, Edwards and maybe Reiwoldt.

 

[PHX]

OUT:
Raines
Hughes
Polo
Hyde

IN:
Johnson
Morton
McGuane (We need someone to go back now Raines and Polo probably wont play next week and Ir eckon he is the best bet.)
Riewoldt

 

[RichosGuns]

Against Collingwood we don't really need a tall team.

Thurstfield to take Travis Cloke and then Bowden/Schultz or Polak to take Rocca and Fraser. Unless Ried comes in we don't really need any extra talls backs.

Hence White, Morton, Johnson and Tivdendale should play

 

[Bazzar]

White better not come in! Sure he played well yesterday, in the reserves. He's not an AFL player, anyone can kill it in the reserves, exaggerating a bit but you put White in our side and he'd do nothing.
Id bring in Johnson, Morton, Edwards and maybe Reiwoldt.

Constantly kicked arse in the WAFL. A class above the rest.

Not so with the Eagles.

 

[Gman]

Outs Ins

Hughes Morton
Raines(inj) Johnson
? Smith or Tivendale



Hard to say who should be the outs. I think we were one man too tall

Polo was on the bench and when he came on had a tagging role. He tagged ok but didnt get much of the ball
Hyde did some good things, always has time on the ball
Pettifer/Brown struggled
Wallace out coached. Told me mate at the footy b4 the bounce that Jade was wrong match up, should have had Bowden or Moore on him

Got murdered by umpire 22 in the 1st quarter.
Got smashed at centre bounces.

 

[YellowandBlackBlood]

Constantly kicked arse in the WAFL. A class above the rest.

Not so with the Eagles.

Yeah we all know that but the guy is only 20-21 and so has the time to step up. He is a first class kick. Something we really missed today going forward.

My INS: Riewoldt for Hughes
Johnson for Hyde
Morton for Pettifer (has done nothing in BOTH games)
White for Raines

We must reward great performances in the 'burgs and punish continual poor performances in the seniors.

 

[Bengal Tiger]

Hey RICHO MAN, give us the run down on why WHITE is so ordinary.

He has put in a huge preseason after an ankle op and his fitness is way up, hence he was able to run all day against Geelong yesterday.

He plays for the team, and not himself and yesterday shows that he is able to play.

Let us know the reasons that you don't think he can cut the mustard.

 

[PooPooMcPhee]

Polo is a quality player. He looked underdone. Keep him in though

 

[Bazzar]

Polo is a quality player. He looked underdone. Keep him in though

Well spoken PooPoo. This time last week it was all about bringing him in, now its about dropping him

 

[Richo Man]

Hey RICHO MAN, give us the run down on why WHITE is so ordinary.

He has put in a huge preseason after an ankle op and his fitness is way up, hence he was able to run all day against Geelong yesterday.

He plays for the team, and not himself and yesterday shows that he is able to play.

Let us know the reasons that you don't think he can cut the mustard.

Didn't Hyde kill it in the reserves? How'd he do tonight?
We got to many that 'play for the team' how many tiger players at the moment take the game by the claws? Put him in the richmond side and if we're losing will he stand up?
He's done nothing when he's been given a shot, that's just my opinion though.

 

[_RT_]

Yeah we all know that but the guy is only 20-21 and so has the time to step up. He is a first class kick. Something we really missed today going forward.

My INS: Riewoldt for Hughes
Johnson for Hyde
Morton for Pettifer (has done nothing in BOTH games)
White for Raines

We must reward great performances in the 'burgs and punish continual poor performances in the seniors.

Thought I was on my own for a while with that opinion.