Chris Judd?

[SimJamie]

I've heard that Judd may be coming back to Victoria. I do not think he will but if he does what could Collingwood offer West Coast? I'd love to see Judd running around in the black and white, even though it probely won't happen.

We could trade Thomas for him (but we won't), could trade few rookies... I don't know what do you think?

(Serious answers please - don't want things like "Pick 180 for Judd").

So what do you think he is worth?

 

[WakeUpPies]

didak and first round, but if he desperately wants to come to collingwood we can offer WCE richards

 

[SimJamie]

didak and first round, but if he desperately wants to come to collingwood we can offer WCE richards

Hmmm preety good trade (Didak and first round) I don't think West Coast would want Richards though...

 

[Barwick17]

I've heard that Judd may be coming back to Victoria. I do not think he will but if he does what could Collingwood offer West Coast? I'd love to see Judd running around in the black and white, even though it probely won't happen.

We could trade Thomas for him (but we won't), could trade few rookies... I don't know what do you think?

(Serious answers please - don't want things like "Pick 180 for Judd").

So what do you think he is worth?

You started it by trading Thomas! He is going to be the face of marketing at Collingwood for 10 years. No chance.

Didak and 2 first rounders would be required IMO

 

[SimJamie]

You started it by trading Thomas! He is going to be the face of marketing at Collingwood for 10 years. No chance.

Didak and 2 first rounders would be required IMO

I also said that we WON'T TRADE HIM. But a player with the skill level of Thomas or Didak would be what we need for Judd, and probely a high draft pick. Thomas is the next Nathan Buckley

 

[Tarkyn_24]

Didak + Medhurst.

Back to WA you go, Medders.

Seriously: Pendles and a first rounder is the least they'd accept. But we can't afford to do it.

 

[Barwick17]

I also said that we WON'T TRADE HIM. But a player with the skill level of Thomas or Didak would be what we need for Judd, and probely a high draft pick. Thomas is the next Nathan Buckley

Spot on!

 

[SimJamie]

Didak + Medhurst.

Back to WA you go, Medders.

Seriously: Pendles and a first rounder is the least they'd accept. But we can't afford to do it.

I like the sound of Didak and Medhurst... I hope they do as well haha

 

[daddy_4_eyes]

I've heard that Judd may be coming back to Victoria.

You sure you didn't just imagine it?

You started it by trading Thomas! He is going to be the face of marketing at Collingwood for 10 years. No chance.

Didak and 2 first rounders would be required IMO

If the pies got Judd, Thomas wouldn't even rate a mention in the marketing department.
Judd's value isn't just his on field ability, its also his off field professionalism & marketability. Imagine what Collingwood could do in terms of marketing with arguably the best known and most popular footy player in Australia?

Your trade offer sounds reasonable though.

 

[didaka]

He can stay at West Coast for all I care. Don't want him. Quite happy with the path we're taking at the minute.

Build a side like the West Coast did!!!! But better!

I'd vommit if Didak was traded!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

[didaka]

Plus West Coast have already got too many loose cannons. You'd think they'd employ Didak?

Like I said we should build a team. I hate poaching players.

 

[Stakerz]

Didak, Thomas and Pendlebury are all loved by every Coll supporter, we don't want to trade them

 

[daics cousin]

Forget it !Wet Toast can keep Chris Judd.I wouldn't trade didak for him.We don't need him.
Someone said give them Thomas for judd.No way.why would you give a future champion for someone in his prime.We have seen the best of Chris Judd.Why sell off the farm no way.What if he got a serious injury dumbcoffs.
He'll re sign with wet toast,your logic on this thread is ridiculous.
Please no more hypothetical Chris Judd threads.
ok i'll let you in on something,if and only if he came back to melbourne,his family are mad collingwood supporters,so he may get steered to come to collingwood but personally he was a melbourne supporter as a kid and Melbourne can have him.

 

[mdc]

Forget it !Wet Toast can keep Chris Judd.I wouldn't trade didak for him.We don't need him.
Someone said give them Thomas for judd.No way.why would you give a future champion for someone in his prime.We have seen the best of Chris Judd.Why sell off the farm no way.What if he got a serious injury dumbcoffs.

Judd is 23 years old. By your logic we had seen the best of Nathan Buckley by 1995.

You started it by trading Thomas! He is going to be the face of marketing at Collingwood for 10 years. No chance.

Judd is far more marketable than Dale Thomas. And football decisions shouldn't be based on marketability in the first place, that's just dumb.

Thomas + Any player not in the Pendles-Shaw-Cloke-Didak group + first round pick (around #15 this year probably).
We should jump be jumping all over such a deal, as it immediately takes us from up-and-coming to a contender.

But I can't imagine WC are dumb enough to ever let him go

 

[Hells K1tch3n]

Judd will never play for collingwood, none of the umpires would want to be involved with the game. They'd see judd and think yep he gets a free, or nah he got that away properly, didnt just drop it cold, but then realise he was wearing a collingwood jersey and have to second guess it, it would take them 15 minutes to come up with a decision!

 

[didaka]

These days buying champions isn't a key to instant success.

Judd could seriously upset the balance at Collingwood.

You trade Thomas or any of the other young players then it might just kick up a stink. The boys at our club play for each other.

You look at the recent sides to win premierships and they have never gone out and recruited the big names barring Barry Hall who was never the player he is now at St. Kilda. They have build their sides. We should do the same thing.

You can stick Judd right up your @rse. I want Collingwood players at Collingwood, not West Coast players.

 

[Tarkyn_24]

These days buying champions isn't a key to instant success.

Judd could seriously upset the balance at Collingwood.

You trade Thomas or any of the other young players then it might just kick up a stink. The boys at our club play for each other.

You look at the recent sides to win premierships and they have never gone out and recruited the big names barring Barry Hall who was never the player he is now at St. Kilda. They have build their sides. We should do the same thing.

You can stick Judd right up your @rse. I want Collingwood players at Collingwood, not West Coast players.

Though they do come in helpful in semi finals vs Geelong.

 

[Tarkyn_24]

Plus West Coast have already got too many loose cannons. You'd think they'd employ Didak?

Like I said we should build a team. I hate poaching players.

... yes

 

[didaka]

Though they do come in helpful in semi finals vs Geelong.

Nick Davis a champion????

 

[Tarkyn_24]

Nick Davis a champion????

for KFC, yes.

 

[didaka]

In that case you're right

 

[bringbackschwarter5]

I highly doubt Judd would want to go to a club like Collingwood

 

[Tarkyn_24]

I highly doubt Judd would want to go to a club like Collingwood

Yes. We are a class above the criminal clowns he hangs around now.

He probably wants to go to St Kilda to see Gradiner again.

 

[WakeUpPies]

i love didak but i would do the didak + 1st round for judd, judd is the best midfielder in the game and he is 23, younger than didak, at least 7 more good years in him and his crap years would probably be the better than richmond's team effort

 

[Big Bryza]

These days buying champions isn't a key to instant success.

Judd could seriously upset the balance at Collingwood.

You trade Thomas or any of the other young players then it might just kick up a stink. The boys at our club play for each other.

You look at the recent sides to win premierships and they have never gone out and recruited the big names barring Barry Hall who was never the player he is now at St. Kilda. They have build their sides. We should do the same thing.

You can stick Judd right up your @rse. I want Collingwood players at Collingwood, not West Coast players.

Absolutely, if Dids, Pendles or Tommo got chucked away for Judd i'd be shattered. I dont give a sh!t how good he is... he aint Collingwood. Those 3 boys are and i want to see them play in the next flag.