MRP / Trib. Clokes elbow

[rose jam]

Re: cloke

I'm predicting 2 as it's more an elbow to the back of the neck/lower head.

Good record.

1 week with a guilty plea.

I think with Cloke it will be no applicable record because he had 2x 1 week suspensions in 2008 if I remember. I know one was definitely against Carlton, or he missed the Carlton game in 2008. That was the Ben Reid stutter game

 

[Grumpy Bum]

Cloke's didn't look good from the little video evidence there is. If he goes, does this present an opportunity to mix up the forward structure and put Maxwell at CHF? can take a grab, can kick straight, might play closer to home. Now that would be a change!!

Thomas: if force of impact is the determinant, then he should be right. If intent is the determinant, then 50/50. You don't have 'innocent' jumper punches. He might not have intended the chin copping it tho.

Anthony: mmmm ........ might doing us a favour if he gets weeks. He is offering nothing.

 

[Stazza71]

Re: cloke

Cloke and Anthony will get weeks - Pendles and Daisy will be fine. May mean Fraser gets a game however which is not so good

 

[TradeDraft]

Could use Judd as Evidence?