Collingwood and Richmond - who has the greater supporter base

[A Cut Above]

When did you throw your Hawthorn merchandise away and replace it with Richmond merchandise?

All that's left to do is to change your supported club on here to Richmond.

Do I know you sir?

 

[Deadly Assassin]

Do I know you sir?

Are we supposed to know each other? On an anonymous internet forum? Oh dear!

 

[brett15]

Are we supposed to know each other? On an anonymous internet forum? Oh dear!

careful bro, he's the type that expects the other person to pay for coffee

 

[CraigB]

Collingwood certainly did have the better of the supporter bases, however in recent years, I believe that they traded it away ro Richmond, I believe it was for continuation of Nafan No Flags and Furore McGuire to remain at the helm of the steadily sinking and irrelevant ship that is the Collingwood Football Club. Next year in 2021 when the Tigers AGAIN prove to be the draw card and end up with the threepeat and 4 out of 5 in they will become the GREATEST team of the modern era.

 

[Saveloy Rockstar]

You didn't answer whether you have a Collingwood membership

I didn't answer because it's irrelevant, but yes I am a CFC member

 

[Saveloy Rockstar]

If you want to be part of the biggest club in the land, and your 1000 odd posts in this thread tell me the you desperately do

No wonder you think RFC have the biggest supporter base if that's an example of your arithmetic

 

[Tiger2709]

I didn't answer because it's irrelevant, but yes I am a CFC member

Must be a little lonely these days?

Even that gold jacketed flog, Joffa has left the country.

 

[Grin]

No wonder you think RFC have the biggest supporter base if that's an example of your arithmetic

My bad. You've only posted 500 times in this thread.

If you're that desperate to be a supporter of the biggest club in the land, and you obviously are, you'd only need to have posted once: "I barrack for the Tigers! "

Welcome aboard mate

 

[Saveloy Rockstar]

Must be a little lonely these days?

Well we didn't have to rattle any tins

 

[Grin]

Well we didn't have to rattle any tins

View attachment 1017874

We're actually proud that we rallied around our club in its darkest hour. Something the likes of you would never contemplate.
Undying loyalty is part of what makes Richmond the biggest club of the land.
And whist Richmond has grown mighty again since then, you're little club became a rabble, the but of jokes, despite many years of desperately trying to ape all things Richmond.

 

[Rasha]

No wonder you think RFC have the biggest supporter base if that's an example of your arithmetic

Why can't Collingwood get anywhere near 100,000 members?

 

[Tiger2709]

Well we didn't have to rattle any tins

View attachment 1017874

You need a lot of supporters to make that work, so it was probably better that you just took the AFL handout, when you were a day or so from bankruptcy.

 

[Tiger2709]

We're actually proud that we rallied around our club in its darkest hour. Something the likes of you would never contemplate.
Undying loyalty is part of what makes Richmond the biggest club of the land.
And whist Richmond has grown mighty again since then, you're little club became a rabble, the but of jokes, despite many years of desperately trying to ape all things Richmond.

What a shame how they deserted their home in Collingwood to become the Holden centre Magpies, small club mentality.

 

[Vikingnz]

What a shame how they deserted their home in Collingwood to become the Holden centre Magpies, small club mentality.

You want to talk about small club mentality - how about the fact they have supporters who consider winning the '18 PF, thus derailing an eventual four-peat, as a 'one-up' on Richmond - they didn't even finish the job the next week.

I think it's disgraceful to have a club of that size, with that sort of financial clout, and have supporters consider that a victory. How the mighty have fallen. Genuinely feel for the black and white army. You deserve better.

 

[Postpandemicpremiers]

Perhaps if they'd got that 4 in a row, but always destined to be the runt of the big 4

 

[Elmer_Judd]

Perhaps if they'd got that 4 in a row, but always destined to be the runt of the big 4


View attachment 1019133

If you were not alive to see the Pies 4 peat, you do not get to ride on those coat tails.

 

[Postpandemicpremiers]

If you were not alive to see the Pies 4 peat, you do not get to ride on those coat tails.

My club, my flags, I have more than you

 

[brett15]

I didn't answer because it's irrelevant, but yes I am a CFC member

It's directly relevant to the question you asked. How many away games does your membership get into?

 

[Tiger Mopsy]

It's directly relevant to the question you asked. How many away games does your membership get into?

I think 3 game memberships are only for home games.

 

[Vikingnz]

Perhaps if they'd got that 4 in a row, but always destined to be the runt of the big 4

How ironic that literally the post after mine is exactly what I was talking about.

 

[Elmer_Judd]

My club, my flags, I have more than you

I am willing to bet that many of your Facebook posts about Footy have ended up on 'Nuffies on AFL Pages'

 

[Postpandemicpremiers]

I am willing to bet that many of your Facebook posts about Footy have ended up on 'Nuffies on AFL Pages'

Well that sounds like a fascinating world you are a part of, Lilly is impressed

 

[Postpandemicpremiers]

How ironic that literally the post after mine is exactly what I was talking about.

You should look up irony again

 

[Vikingnz]

You should look up irony again

Actually, I think it's you that needs to.

 

[Postpandemicpremiers]

Actually, I think it's you that needs to.

Don't play the Trump game with me, get up to speed with a few more flags, don't spend 37 years at 9th again, don't lose 3 GF's in a row to us again and we'll think about letting you in the club