Review Collingwood the Decade every best list team et al

[Saintly Viewed]

The decade of the tens has come and all but gone.

what is the best lists you can name in this decade.

eg best team of the decade

best ten players of the decade

best ten injuries of the decade

whatever you want.

humour, anything go for it.

 

[Tarkyn_24]

1. Tarkyn Lockyer
2. Scott Pendlebury
3. Dane Swan
4. Brodie Grundy
5. Travis Cloke

 

[Saintly Viewed]

Collingwood 2010 - 2019

B. H Shaw ~ C Tarrant ~ B Maynard
HB. J Howe ~ D Moore ~ J Crisp
C. S Sidebottom ~ T Adams ~ A Treloar
HF. J De Goey ~ B Reid ~ J Stephenson
F. J Elliott ~ T Cloke ~ A Didak
R. B Grundy ~ S Pendlebury (c) ~ D Swan
I. D Jolly ~ D Beams ~ L Ball ~ D Thomas

 

[Tarkyn_24]

Reid making centre half forward despite predominantly being a backline mainstay really underlines our poorly our tall forwards with the exception of Cloke performed this decade.

Whether that was structural, talent related or both is up for debate but really Cloke’s production for us cannot be sneezed at.

 

[Saintly Viewed]

Reid making centre half forward despite predominantly being a backline mainstay really underlines our poorly our tall forwards with the exception of Cloke performed this decade.

Whether that was structural, talent related or both is up for debate but really Cloke’s production for us cannot be sneezed at.

Nail.
hammer.
head.

i was so thinking that.
like we really really really struggle to have a second key forward after the obvious Cloke.
its a sad song.

says so much.

 

[Tarkyn_24]

Nail.
hammer.
head.

i was so thinking that.
like we really really really struggle to have a second key forward after the obvious Cloke.
its a sad song.

says so much.

I’d almost stick Mihocek in there.

I suppose your inclusion of Moore does somewhat balance it out given he spent all but the last two seasons forward, but a developing KPP selected on the premise of promise is probably even more damning to our other options.

 

[Saintly Viewed]

Best 10 players of the past decade:

• Pendlebury
• Swan
• Grundy
• Sidebottom
• Cloke T
• Treloar
• De Goey
• Shaw H
• Elliott
• Beams

 

[ZEV]

Best players we picked in National Draft last decade,
1. Grundy
2. DeGoey
3. Moore
4. Stephenson
5. Maynard
6. Phillips
7. Langdon
8. Sier
9. Fasolo
10. Scharenberg

 

[ZEV]

Top 10 Pies players that broke my heart to see in another clubs jumpers last decade;

10. Harry O

9. Toppy Dawes

8. Sharrod Wellingham

7. Paul Seedsman

6. Nathan Brown

5. Jarrod Witts

4. Dayne Beams

3. Travis Cloke

2. Daisy

1. Heath Shaw

 

[adammania9]

Top 10 Pies players that broke my heart to see in another clubs jumpers last decade;

10. Harry O

9. Toppy Dawes

8. Sharrod Wellingham

7. Paul Seedsman

6. Nathan Brown

5. Jarrod Witts

4. Dayne Beams

3. Travis Cloke

2. Daisy

1. Heath Shaw

I reckon Wellingham would have become a club champion if he stayed at Collingwood. His 2011-12 form is often forgotten about, but he wasn't just a good wingman to Swan, Pendlebury and Beams, he often stood up at times when they were down. Had a lot of weapons, and he just flourished in those two seasons.

No hard feelings since he turned into the pick we used on Grundy, but I often wonder about how his career would have gone if he didn't go back to WA to become a flaky back flanker at West Coast.

 

[ZEV]

I reckon Wellingham would have become a club champion if he stayed at Collingwood. His 2011-12 form is often forgotten about, but he wasn't just a good wingman to Swan, Pendlebury and Beams, he often stood up at times when they were down. Had a lot of weapons, and he just flourished in those two seasons.

No hard feelings since he turned into the pick we used on Grundy, but I often wonder about how his career would have gone if he didn't go back to WA to become a flaky back flanker at West Coast.

I find a telling stat that surmises SW's career pretty well, he only ever had one 30 plus possession game.

 

[adammania9]

I find a telling stat that surmises SW's career pretty well, he only ever had one 30 plus possession game.

Quality > quantity. Was a good user, reliable goal kicker and very good defensively.

Plus, there was only so much footy to be won by Wellers with Swan, Pendles, Beams, Ball and Thomas around him.

 

[ZEV]

Quality > quantity. Was a good user, reliable goal kicker and very good defensively.

Plus, there was only so much footy to be won by Wellers with Swan, Pendles, Beams, Ball and Thomas around him.

Just feels like he was never thrown the keys to the midfield car often enough.

 

[Heater39]

Top 10 moments of the decade

10. 2012 draft night. Brodie Grundy somehow slips through the cracks...
9. 2011 comeback win against Adelaide- Taz with the jumper tug/ Krakouer's mark
8. 2016 rd 2, beating Richmond by 1 point
7. Swanny winning the brownlow
6. 2010 rd 19 vs Geelong. This was the game when i knew we were good enough to win the flag
5. 2012 ANZAC day. Blairy's dribbler/ Swanny dominates
4. 2010 prelim against Geelong. Leigh Brown's torp bouncing through for a goal
3. 2018 prelim. Cox! Enough said
2. 2011 prelim win over Hawthorn. Cloke's mark/ Ball's snap
1. 2010 grand final replay. Winning the mother****ing grand final!

 

[adammania9]

Top 10 moments of the decade

10. 2012 draft night. Brodie Grundy somehow slips through the cracks...
9. 2011 comeback win against Adelaide- Taz with the jumper tug/ Krakouer's mark
8. 2016 rd 2, beating Richmond by 1 point
7. Swanny winning the brownlow
6. 2010 rd 19 vs Geelong. This was the game when i knew we were good enough to win the flag
5. 2012 ANZAC day. Blairy's dribbler/ Swanny dominates
4. 2010 prelim against Geelong. Leigh Brown's torp bouncing through for a goal
3. 2018 prelim. Cox! Enough said
2. 2011 prelim win over Hawthorn. Cloke's mark/ Ball's snap
1. 2010 grand final replay. Winning the mother******* grand final!

People love that comeback win against the Crows and rightly so, but I tell you what comeback win from 2011 I love even more, is when we trailed Essendon by 23 at quarter time and at half-time by 12, before going on to win by 74 points, with a 6-2 goal third team and 10-1 goal final term. Complete annihilation in that second half. One of Swanny's finest performances with 45 and a goal, Pendles had over 30 and kicked 3, Krakouer kicked 4 and Faz kicked his first bag with 5. So good.