Comments on Voting

[legitimatic]

5. Browne
4. Head
3. Thornton
2. Dodd
1. Duffield

I think the match committee will agree with me. Contract extensions for all.

I just can't believe all those guys "played" today, not even Geelong could win carrying those players IMO, what chance do we have?

And true to form they were all shit again.

 

[Athomas]

Re: Votes Rd 2 v Essendon @ Docklands

How can some of you bag Mundy!? He was great today. Just my two cents.

 

[Phat Toni]

Re: Votes Rd 2 v Essendon @ Docklands

Anybody who watched the game yesterday and doesn't have Sandi as their best needs to get their eyes tested. BOG without doubt, I also see on here no love for Mundy, his first half was fantastic.



And Tarrent, I see some people have him in their best.. WOW!! I think he typifies all that is wrong with Freo. I've watched him for a long time and seen him play live maybe 25 to 30 times and I've been calling him 'The Nothing Man' for a while now. On the surface he looks like a guy that should be able to dominate games, and he does at times but that's the problem it's only at times, his 2nd and 3rd efforts have always been terrible and his consistency of effort fluctuates to when it suits him. In an old sporting analogy what does he bring to the table and what does he take away from the table? My view is his good and bad equal about the same, hence 'The Nothing Man'. Here is a question for you, if Tarrent didnt play yesterday would the result have been any different? He has a career winning % of 44%, he is not a winner, cut your losses and get rid of him. If I were on the Freo selection committee I would just stick a folk in him and give one of the kids greater responsibility.

One funny ting that happened yesterday there was a Freo supporter sitting in front of me(don’t know how he got into our section as it's a pretty blocked in Essendon Reserved Seat section) he yelled out at a Tarrent error "Tarrent you suck at life" harsh but very funny!

 

[Lach72]

Re: Votes Rd 2 v Essendon @ Docklands

Anybody who watched the game yesterday and doesn't have Sandi as their best needs to get their eyes tested. BOG without doubt, I also see on here no love for Mundy, his first half was fantastic.



And Tarrent, I see some people have him in their best.. WOW!! I think he typifies all that is wrong with Freo. I've watched him for a long time and seen him play live maybe 25 to 30 times and I've been calling him 'The Nothing Man' for a while now. On the surface he looks like a guy that should be able to dominate games, and he does at times but that's the problem it's only at times, his 2nd and 3rd efforts have always been terrible and his consistency of effort fluctuates to when it suits him. In an old sporting analogy what does he bring to the table and what does he take away from the table? My view is his good and bad equal about the same, hence 'The Nothing Man'. Here is a question for you, if Tarrent didnt play yesterday would the result have been any different? He has a career winning % of 44%, he is not a winner, cut your losses and get rid of him. If I were on the Freo selection committee I would just stick a folk in him and give one of the kids greater responsibility.

One funny ting that happened yesterday there was a Freo supporter sitting in front of me(don’t know how he got into our section as it's a pretty blocked in Essendon Reserved Seat section) he yelled out at a Tarrent error "Tarrent you suck at life" harsh but very funny!

Suggest you have another look at the game...he's the least of our worries

 

[Phat Toni]

Re: Votes Rd 2 v Essendon @ Docklands

Suggest you have another look at the game...he's the least of our worries

I'm not saying he is your only problem,just like Essendon the problems run quite deep. I'm just saying that he has always been a part time player on a full time salary, if you want to play finals consistently year after year you need players that show up quarter after quarter game after game. Think of Sydney, they have played finals for about 7 years now, they have a team of guys that don't take a possesion off let along go missing for a half of footy. Freo should cut their losses with Tarrent and not punish the future of the club just because they paid a high price for him a few years ago and think they need to get their value out of him by playing him each week.

 

[Lach72]

Re: Votes Rd 2 v Essendon @ Docklands

I'm not saying he is your only problem,just like Essendon the problems run quite deep. I'm just saying that he has always been a part time player on a full time salary, if you want to play finals consistently year after year you need players that show up quarter after quarter game after game. Think of Sydney, they have played finals for about 7 years now, they have a team of guys that don't take a possesion off let along go missing for a half of footy. Freo should cut their losses with Tarrent and not punish the future of the club just because they paid a high price for him a few years ago and think they need to get their value out of him by playing him each week.

No really, suggest you have another look at the game, as opposed to spouting cliches

 

[legitimatic]

I do not remember creating this thread, it's just depressing really.