Crichton Medal 2008

[AndyLesPaul]

Seeing as the seasons almost over how about we guess whos going to win our Best And Fairest this year.

1. Hille
2. Lloyd
3. McVeigh (regardless of injuries.)

 

[bomberstomake8]

1. LLoyd
2. Hille
3. Watson

 

[Colin D'Cops]

1. David Hille
2. Brent Stanton
3. Mark McVeigh (Because of injuries)

 

[Lotch]

Yeah Hille and Lloyd

McVeigh would of been in contention for more than B&F if he wasnt injured...
Great player

 

[loopy_cam]

Hille
Lloyd
Welsh

 

[Panna Witchy Salitou]

1. Hille
2. Watson
3. Lloyd
4. McVeigh
5. McPhee

 

[Burzum]

1. David Hille
2. Jobe Watson
3. Matthew Lloyd
4. Andrew Welsh
5. Adam McPhee

 

[warney7]

1.Hille
2.Lloyd
3.Watson
4.Stanton
=5.McVeigh
=5.Welsh

 

[tristo]

Top 5

D.Hille - Probably leader atm, but will miss final 2 games. Opens the door for M.Lloyd and J.Watson if they can finish strongly.

J.Watson - Been good for a couple of months now and I reckon will get votes throughout. If Jobe can finish the season strongly in the last 2 games could sneak past Hille.

M.Lloyd - Been great since West Coast game in round 12. Like Watson, with Hille out for the season could get across the line in the last 2 games with some big performances.

M.McVeigh - Awesome early in the season however injuries have wiped away any chance, should still finish top 5 with the amount of votes he will poll when he actually got on the park.

B.Stanton - Tough choice for 5th as I reckon it could be close, but Stanton over the season I reckon will score enough votes to slot into 5th.

Other top 5 possibilites
A.Welsh
P.Ryder
D.Fletcher

 

[bomber39]

1. Watson (just)
2. Lloyd
3. Hille
4. Fletch
5. Mcveigh

 

[FullFathom5]

Top 5

D.Hille - Probably leader atm, but will miss final 2 games. Opens the door for M.Lloyd and J.Watson if they can finish strongly.

J.Watson - Been good for a couple of months now and I reckon will get votes throughout. If Jobe can finish the season strongly in the last 2 games could sneak past Hille.

M.Lloyd - Been great since West Coast game in round 12. Like Watson, with Hille out for the season could get across the line in the last 2 games with some big performances.

M.McVeigh - Awesome early in the season however injuries have wiped away any chance, should still finish top 5 with the amount of votes he will poll when he actually got on the park.

B.Stanton - Tough choice for 5th as I reckon it could be close, but Stanton over the season I reckon will score enough votes to slot into 5th.

Other top 5 possibilites
A.Welsh
P.Ryder
D.Fletcher

Agree here. Had McVeigh stayed fit, the medal would have been around his neck before the season was out. Watson has just been consistent. I think he'll sneak through.

 

[windyhill]

Hille. Stanton is coming home like a train though.

 

[The_Young_Gun]

watson, Hille, lloyd.

The second half of Lloyds season will notch him up a huge margin, but will most likely get in the top 5 region.

As for Hille, he deservidly should get the Critchton Medal but missing the last 3 games of the year might just get Watson over the line.

So, Yeah, Watson gets my vote.

 

[Bomber32]

1. Watson
2. Hille
3. Lloyd

 

[Big Blow Hard]

1. Watson
2. Hille
3. Lloyd

Seems about right.

My smokey for a top 5. anyone who played more than 15 games. lol

 

[The_Young_Gun]

Seems about right.

My smokey for a top 5. anyone who played more than 15 games. lol

I wouldn't be surprised if thats the case.

 

[bomber69]

I reckon Ryder may poll well as he has been our most consistent all year and has played every game.

 

[retroparty]

Hille
Stanton
Lloyd
Watson

These 4 will get heaps of votes. Will be very close.

After that:

McVeigh
Fletcher

 

[essendon2008]

I'm gonna take somewhat of a risk here and say Watson.

 

[Rabbit of Caerbannog]

I hope Lloyd wins. The champion deserves a B & F.

 

[Bomber57]

1. Mcveigh (easy)
2. Hille
3. McPhee
4. Watson
5. Stanton

 

[Darealrath]

1. Lloyd
2. Hille
3. Stanton
4. Welsh
5. Watson
6. McPhee
7. McVeigh

 

[scottie pippen]

1.Hille
2.Mcveigh
3.Lloyd
4.Stanton
5.Watson

 

[hinrich-gun]

hille for sure

then lloyd and watson

if mcveigh didnt get injured he would be up there in brownlow as well

 

[Merv]

1: Hille
2: Lloyd
3: Watson
4: McPhee
5: McVeigh