Crow Is Emergency...

[jefffff34]

Originally posted by Murray
He will be in standing in line with Kinnear for his long service soon Mark.
How may years do we wait?
It is now year 4
What year do we say enough is enough?

* It's his 3rd year on the list.
* He's played about 15 or so games I'd imagine by now.
* The kid has ticker.
* Guy Richards took 4 years to get a game.

 

[eddiesmith]

It's bad enough we have to carry COle who cant kick or man up but the team cannot afford to carry Walker, best for everyone if we try to see if any other clubs want him

If they dont delist him i would be ****ed off but happy if they atleast tried to trade him and when no clubs want him it will just prove he is **** and will never make it

He is a huge liability and I can blame him for losses in most games he has played

There is a stat for someone to look for, Collingwoods record with Walker playing

 

[guess_who]

Originally posted by hotpie
I think you can name a rookie as emergency without promoting him. But to get a game he needs to be promoted.

I'm pretty sure that you can play a limited amount of games then you have to be dropped again unles promoted AKA the Damian Peverill scenario.

 

[eddiesmith]

I will repeat myself as last nights game warrants this being brought up again

Please drop Walker
Please drop Walker
Please drop Walker
Please drop Walker
Please drop Walker
Please drop Walker
Please drop Walker
Please drop Walker
Please drop Walker
Please drop Walker

 

[guess_who]

What ever, walker was great last night. Presented well, marked well just couldn't convert on the score board. Drop O'bree, Davis, McKee before Walker.

 

[Lonie_from_50]

Anyway,

McKee will be dropped - for Richards,

Crow has to be promoted, which I don't think he is, there is no news on his promotion!

Damien Peverill played how many games before they had to promote him, before they realised???

He is the only player ever to play when not promoted!!!

Collingwood has been fined ALOT this season and they are not going to play him before promoting him.

Can't wait till his forst game, better be at the MCG, next week, so he can get a tan

 

[eddiesmith]

How could you suggest dropping Davis before Walker

And atleast McKee could kick straight from the shots Walker had

 

[guess_who]

Richards is out for the rest of the season! Stunner stays.

Davis is crud and should have been dropped yonks ago. Collingwood have that many injures, so no worry about promoting JC. Some one said they heard Balme on radio saying he has been or will be promoted. If Collingwood get fined for playing JC then I will personaly put my hand up to pay the fine.

 

[hotpie]

Originally posted by eddiesmith

And atleast McKee could kick straight from the shots Walker had

Gary Ablett kicked 1:6 against us - is he a dud?

 

[guess_who]

Originally posted by hotpie
Gary Ablett kicked 1:6 against us - is he a dud?

No, but over rated.

 

[hotpie]

Originally posted by guess_who
No, but over rated.

fair enough. you've just explained to the world your lack of football knowledge - no more needs to be said.

 

[eddiesmith]

Ablett doesnt do it every week, Walker does

 

[Lonie_from_50]

Originally posted by hotpie
fair enough. you've just explained to the world your lack of football knowledge - no more needs to be said.

yes, more does need to be said - I totally agree with guess_who, that Gary Ablett is overrated, not saying that he is a bad player, he is a great player. Gary Ablett is one of the best defensive forwards in the league, but he is overrated. I have seen every match he has played this season, we all know he works hard, we all know that he can kick important goals, but the media don't stop bragging about the gun small forward, and that is the only reason why. Just like Rhyce Shaw, change the last names, and they won't be either underrated or overrated. They will both be good players.

 

[Lonie_from_50]

Originally posted by eddiesmith
Ablett doesnt do it every week, Walker does

I don't know what you are on. Are you saying that Gary Ablett doesn't be innacurate every week.

Well, Tristan Walker has only kicked a SCORE 3 Career Games -

let me go through it for you:

Rnd 21 v Sydney, 2003 - 1 goal 1 behind
QF v Brisbane, 2003 - 1 behind
Rnd 17 v Bulldogs, 2004 - 2 goals 4 behinds.

TOTAL - 3 GOALS 6 BEHINDS.

He does it week in week out does he?

He has played 2 games in his career in the forward line, for 3 goals 5 behinds.

That Explains that he does it everyweek!

 

[The Scarecrow]

Walker needs to do some more kicking for goal at training, as does Jason Cloke.

 

[eddiesmith]

What I meant was that Walker cant kick and will never kick straight, at goal or general play if he even gets the ball at all seeing he is usually 10-15m behind his opponent

Ablett has actually kicked bags of goals before and has an accurate kick but he was unlucky against us

 

[The Scarecrow]

If only Dunstall was too....

 

[Lonie_from_50]

Originally posted by The Scarecrow
If only Dunstall was too....

I think that might be why Piggy is a very angry man at times.