Analysis Current Bottom 6

[SFgiant]

I will not stand for anymore DMAC slander. The man has taken my heart

 

[plugger66]

Yes lots to chose from. My criteria was bottom six but I acknowledge that it can easily be debated that many more.

Used it as a comparison of a team that won 20 of 22 and just got pipped in the Grand Final. One of our all time best teams.

Shows how even we are without the top end superstars. We are getting some, maybe we are like the 04/05 side more than 09. We have some players becoming AA selections and some young players that would be top notch in 2 or three seasons.

So in fairness here are my bottom 6 of the GF team

Could fit King, Blake, Armitage and Gwilt into our current bottom six as well in my opinion.

View attachment 1412892

Reckon the 05 06 side kills the 09 side on paper.

 

[CursingFijian]

According to AFL Player Ratings Long is ranked 9th in the competition for general forwards based on a minimum 4 match snapshot.

 

[gringo2011]

According to AFL Player Ratings Long is ranked 9th in the competition for general forwards based on a minimum 4 match snapshot.

Interesting with Wilkie, he's going really well as a general defender. Tom Stewart, Doedee and him are more third tall type interceptors but Wilkie the most accountable of all of them. The rest are the high possession ball carrier players like Saad, Sinclair etc who gather lots of touches to get their rating.

 

[plugger66]

Interesting with Wilkie, he's going really well as a general defender. Tom Stewart, Doedee and him are more third tall type interceptors but Wilkie the most accountable of all of them. The rest are the high possession ball carrier players like Saad, Sinclair etc who gather lots of touches to get their rating.

I don’t get those ratings at all. If long is 9th are there only 9 forwards?

 

[gringo2011]

I don’t get those ratings at all. If long is 9th are there only 9 forwards?

It's a formula. They rate players on marks and tackles higher than lot of other things though so they are pretty biased towards certain types. He's being measured against all the non KP forwards so he's obviously tackling and doing 1%ers and stuff to get those ratings points.