- Moderator
- #4,251
Is a top 5, top 10 and a 2nd rounder in the 20-27 range too much?
Yes and totally unrealistic.
Where are Geelong going to get a top 5 pick from ?
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

BigFooty AFLW Notice Img
AFLW 2025 - AFLW Trade and Draft - All the player moves
Due to a number of factors, support for the current BigFooty mobile app has been discontinued. Your BigFooty login will no longer work on the Tapatalk or the BigFooty App - which is based on Tapatalk.
Apologies for any inconvenience. We will try to find a replacement.
Is a top 5, top 10 and a 2nd rounder in the 20-27 range too much?
Where will this top 5 pick come from though?Is a top 5, top 10 and a 2nd rounder in the 20-27 range too much?
Finishing bottom in 2016Yes and totally unrealistic.
Where are Geelong going to get a top 5 pick from ?
Why are people still trying to to twist this situation.
Geelong offer 800K, we match, Geelong trade. If Mardi is pregnant theirs no way he's going to sign a 1 year contract with some other club just so he can go to Geelong next year.
Carlton are in the middle of a rebuild they aren't going to pay 1M just so they can have him for a year, he will end up at Brisbane.
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
Finishing bottom in 2016![]()
The denial is strong with this oneThose in the denial camp (must be just me left...) hope that this is out "Ryan okeefe" moment where danger dr-signs at the last minute for one year to avoid draft when negotiations with Geelong fail.
I reckon he secretly wouldn't be that upset.
Well that is the highest probability of the options available.Well that will be the gamble when we take their 2016 pick !!!
Is a top 5, top 10 and a 2nd rounder in the 20-27 range too much?
What number would he wear at the cats ? Anything but 32 please. I'm close enough to vomiting as it is.The denial is strong with this one![]()
He makes a compelling argument.The most poignant thing I've read in this thread for a long while![]()
Geelong already have a number 32 - Motlop.What number would he wear at the cats ? Anything but 32 please. I'm close enough to vomiting as it is.
Denial. Everything will be ok. !!!
Why are people still trying to to twist this situation.
Geelong offer 800K, we match, Geelong trade. If Mardi is pregnant theirs no way he's going to sign a 1 year contract with some other club just so he can go to Geelong next year.
Carlton are in the middle of a rebuild they aren't going to pay 1M just so they can have him for a year, he will end up at Brisbane.
not with that attitudeCarlton aren't trading Henderson for CEY.
Also, if you trade a future first round pick you can't trade any other future picks from the same year
Either way a club has to pay for a player like PD...whether it's via a trade or by offering a mammoth contract deal as part of FA.......The geelong supporters don't seem to get this, they think they are running a charity over at the cattery. One way or another you gotta pay up
Then please piss off back to your board because that's just trolling and your adding nothing to the discussionIf the shoe was on the other foot...
Then please piss off back to your board because that's just trolling and your adding nothing to the discussion
What number would he wear at the cats ? Anything but 32 please. I'm close enough to vomiting as it is.
Denial. Everything will be ok. !!!
Havent been there for ages. And dont want to either. The circle jerking would be monsterous.
Then please piss off back to your board because that's just trolling and your adding nothing to the discussion
It irks me that McLeod is not a Brownlow medallist while Goodes is a dual Brownlow medallist. I am a Goodes fan, I think he was a amazing player ..... but I think McLeod was better, or at least on par. Every year the Brownlow has some controversy. Something needs to change.
Not really on topic with the thread but I had to get that out.
Absolutely, but perhaps the discussion had started at that point that we will upgrade your pick 14 to a top 10 pick and next year we will take your first rounder + ...No because that was a fair trade for both parties.
Look for what it's worth, and that's not much, but no it wasn't close. Goodes wasn't near the player McLeod was
did rowey just say it will be 9 and murdoch?