MRP / Trib. Davey

[d33my]

I missed the incident and the two subsequent replays at the ground.
Is Davey in trouble? If so, how many weeks?

 

[Capt_Concussion]

Yes he's in trouble. He'll get weeks. How many? I've got no idea.

 

[Crimson Azure]

I missed the incident and the two subsequent replays at the ground.
Is Davey in trouble? If so, how many weeks?

I missed it too but also look out for Joel Macdonald, I still can't believe he didn't even give away a free. For some reason I thought there was one more too.

 

[master bate]

Personally I'd rule that it was below the minimal force to constitute a reportable offense. But I doubt that will happen:

McGlynn (I think) bent over misses the ball out of a centre clearance. Davey glances his head with his hip. McGlynn stops like shot, but then gets up pretty quickly once he's got the free.

Let's see:
Head High, Low Impact, In the play

No bad record and early plea hopefully gets him just a reprimand. But who knows.

 

[stretcharmstrong]

Anyone see anything in Mumford's (I think) hit on Sylvia (I think)?

Looked late, high and intentional to me...

 

[Crusty Demon]

I missed the incident and the two subsequent replays at the ground.
Is Davey in trouble? If so, how many weeks?

Hip to head means trouble. Wouldn't be surprised if he gets 2 weeks to be honest. J Mac could get a weeks spell as well for his tripping effort. 2 players we will need to be competitive against the Hawks next week. So not a great day for the Dees today...

 

[d33my]

When and where did JMacs tripping offence occur? Missed that one too...

 

[The Dr]

reckon davey might cop one week, and Joel Mac may be in trouble too, possibly Mumford cos the contact was a fair bit late as well.

 

[Crimson Azure]

McGlynn (I think) bent over misses the ball out of a centre clearance. Davey glances his head with his hip. McGlynn stops like shot, but then gets up pretty quickly once he's got the free.

On MMM they seemed to think it was a dive & the contact was not with his head but his shoulder.

Anyone see anything in Mumford's (I think) hit on Sylvia (I think)?

Looked late, high and intentional to me...

It was both late & intentional but I think he will get off.

 

[Sylvia Saint]

Davey has nothing to worry about I would've thought.

McGlynn went for an epic dive and the ump got sucked in. Shouldn't have even been a free.

JoelMac might be in a bit of strife, haven't seen a replay of that one however.

 

[rhaz]

Watch the highlights of the game on the foxsports website, Davey hits him on the shoulder.

Macca on the other hand, im surprised he didn't tear a groin muscle with how far out he stretched his leg in the trip attempt...

 

[Capt_Concussion]

If Mumford gets weeks I'll be pretty pissed off. Yes it was late but that's all.

 

[Hannabal]

Yes he's in trouble. He'll get weeks. How many? I've got no idea.

You have no clue.

Wager ?

 

[Stylus]

I remember watching the replay of the Davey incident and thinking he hit him in the shoulder/chest only. I would say he will get off.

 

[TheBoss]

On MMM they seemed to think it was a dive & the contact was not with his head but his shoulder.

From what I saw on the tele it looks like the initial contact by Davey was made on the Swan's shoulder.

 

[melbournemartin]

It was a joke that Davey had a free against to begin with. McGlynn took a massive dive. It was nothing more than a glancing shoulder bump. Umpires were rubbish all day though so what can you expect?

I'd also hate for Mumford to get suspended. He should be fine though. Sure, it was a bit late so we got a free kick down field. That's all that was needed. It looks bad because of his size but he can't be penalised for eating 20 sausages a day or whatever the statistic was.

I don't know about Joel Macdonald's report but with Frawley hopefully coming back this week a suspension may just save Jared Rivers' spot.

 

[THE STING2]

Davey looks ok, Jetta might get a week and MacDonald should definately get a week.

 

[Bartram_Class]

Macdonald will get a week, not sure who we can replace him with, Strauss will have bad memories of the Hawks.

Can't afford to lose Davey, the run we lacked in the first half was almost entirely down to Shaw's job on him..

 

[Capt_Concussion]

You have no clue.

Wager ?

I thought for sure the contact was to the head. But everyone on he seems to think it was the shoulder. If that's the case then of cause he's not going to get weeks.

Surely you have the cognitive skills to see why Davey would get weeks if the contact was to the head.

 

[syl]

The contact was to the shoulder, he stopped like he was shot in the face with a deagle. I think it would be a joke if he is suspended.

 

[eskimo]

Rivers may also be in trouble.

Threw a few jumper punches on Reid (could be wrong) when Tapscott was taken out. Looked like 1 punch might have landed pretty hard.

 

[festa1234]

davey cleared macdonald also cleared 4 tripping

 

[Hannabal]

I thought for sure the contact was to the head. But everyone on he seems to think it was the shoulder. If that's the case then of cause he's not going to get weeks.

Surely you have the cognitive skills to see why Davey would get weeks if the contact was to the head.

I wouldn't be referencing cognitive skills if I was you.

 

[wowlace]

Would like to see Rivers get a week for a punch to the face. Has to be done when your team mate first gamer gets a dodgey. Have to step in for the lad. Not that Tapscott couldn't destroy the whole Sydney side by himself.