Dean Brogan

[hotpie]

Yes please.

 

[Zeke]

Yeah, he'd be a nice aquisition.

Not sure that we can afford to offer anyone for him, though.

Davis?

 

[Whisky_McKay]

I'll have one thanks

 

[jefffff34]

If Port get rid of Brogan they are dead-set stupid.

Let's get Stevens.

 

[acuguy]

how about nurturing some of your own players for a change, oh that is right you would rather poach other teams players. I vaguely remember Carlton doing this for most of the mid to late 90s, look at them now.

 

[Joel]

Originally posted by acuguy
how about nurturing some of your own players for a change, oh that is right you would rather poach other teams players. I vaguely remember Carlton doing this for most of the mid to late 90s, look at them now.

You idiot. If a good player is available, you take them. Get some knowledge.

 

[acuguy]

the gains of the present can be damaging for the future

Collingwood poaching

Buckley
O'Bree
McKee
Clement
Woewodin
Holland
Freeborn
Licuria
Molloy
Rocca
Wakelin
Williams

Compared to Brisbane having five players

Lynch
Pike
both former fitzroy players

Brad Scott- came to play with his brother
Mal Michael
Caracella

How many premierships and finals have the lions played in and won compared to collingwood. you just keep poaching we will keep building. Go the pies. ha

 

[Nic]

How many rucks do we need?

 

[Rival_V]

Paper talk from the manager to get more $$$$. It's the oldest trick in the book - Say that Collingwood/Carlton/Essendon etc are after you and then watch the club get worried.

Remember that the HS said that we were interested in Matthew Richardson when he was in contract talks last year ............................................


(Though Dean Brogan would be nice!)

 

[brentoncowell]

i would not mind seeing him don the pies jumper.He is a good player,we just need to get him out of footy hell,Adelaide?south australia(no offence)

 

[statman]

I think that we should develop what we have, we have so many players who can play ruck...
In the two's we have richards, cloke and walker who all seem to be more than capable and we have rocca, Fraser and Mckee in the seniors how many more do we want..why keep importing players when we can breed our own?
Besides to get Brogan we would have to give something pretty big in return!!!!!!!

 

[Lockyer24]

No more rucks needed, Joshua is going to be better than this guy long term. (unless he comes very cheap, and we are prepared to give McKee the boot)

 

[statswiz]

i like Dean Brogan as a player and it would be good to see him in a pies guernsey. But he has been a revalation at Port Adelaide this year. Port Adelaide did play with three profiled ruckman on the weekend, they might want to get rid of one. They might want to trade Brendon Lade though.

 

[statman]

It would be extremely dumb to get rid of brogan esspically since Primus is so injury prone at the moment