Didak vs Kerr

[magpiewarrior]

Didak's good to watch on his day but ......closest thing to Daicos???
Were you actually above the age of 6 when he was playing? You've either bumped your head recently or you're getting him mixed up with BERTRAND Daicos who played 2 games on the bench for the East Smithfield under 15's.
Sure didak is a fantastic instinctive player but the Magician was a step above that. He knew where the ball was going to be and what he was going to do with it before it got there.
You sure you're not trying to boost this guys market price?

Wow an Eagle supporter giving credit to a former Pie, I've only been living in Perth for 50 years I know but is this a first? Oh hang on a minute he's only praising a former magpie so that he can rubbish a current one. Having heard all the invective about Judd when he left Perth I know what credit the locals give to any non-eagle and how biased they are about current Eagles. If we were silly enough to give them Didak then he would suddenly be elevated to greatest ever status in their eyes and Kerr would be called a hack that fed off Judd and Cousins.

 

[Bonobo]

Jeez Magpiewarrior, I used a couple of positive adjectives to describe Didak as well. I just find that it is too easy for all of us to compare players that are exciting now with players that are proven champions from the past. Truth be told I'm a Fitzroy supporter that now only follows WC because as a one eyed East Perth supporter followed the career of Ross Glenndining and with the demise of the mighty Lions had to fall back on something...and it just couldn't be the Brisbane Bears er Lions.

 

[magpiewarrior]

Jeez Magpiewarrior, I used a couple of positive adjectives to describe Didak as well. I just find that it is too easy for all of us to compare players that are exciting now with players that are proven champions from the past. Truth be told I'm a Fitzroy supporter that now only follows WC because as a one eyed East Perth supporter followed the career of Ross Glenndining and with the demise of the mighty Lions had to fall back on something...and it just couldn't be the Brisbane Bears er Lions.

Fair call, I'll just hop back into my over sensitive box now. Needless to say, your point about comparing past players with current is totally valid particularly when you see how different the game is now to then.

 

[Snoop Dog]

My view would be keep Didak over Kerr.
Keen to get Kerr but just dont see a way we could trade for another first round selection unless we could give up Reid which I would do but I doubt in this draft we would get a first rounder for him. Fraser would go close but I dont want to give him up.

 

[Pie eyed]

It's like comparing apples to pears....


One's hard at it and the other is soft.

One's inside the other's completely outside.

One's neat by foot the other makes the ball talk.

One's a midfielder the other's a HFF.

Both are matchwinners.

Does Collingwood need an elite inside midfielder or elite HFF?

Both. That's the point. We have one already in Didak and Kerr is not the only option for the other. A bird in the hand and all that.

You must go to a different fruiterer than me as Pears are harder than apples...lol

 

[The MaTRiX]

Also, just one thing in favour for Kerr....


IS THAT HE IS TWICE THE PLAYER DIDAK IS!!!

That was a hilarious read though G.O.B. Cheers mate.

Your post is laughable.

I am a Saints supporter and can tell you most avid football followers would rather Didak on their side. Eliminate off field indiscretions. Not that Kerr is an angel.