Do We Need A New Logo?

[Chat Pile]

Yes.

Personally I'm not a huge fan of the current one. The only saving grace is that we won a few flags with it.

I'd like to see something along the lines of this:


Looks proper fierce, has character, doesn't look like a children's cartoon... I could do on.

Does everyone else like our current logo?

 

[Marcel Proust]

 

[Hamsatma]

I'd like something more retro. Essendon's recent 150-year logo is the style I reckon we should go for

 

[fargothegreat]

No way. Our current identity is associated with our recent success, just as our old one was with our mediocrity.

Wouldn't even think about changing it any time soon.

 

[Roksman]

Current logo is way too cartoony for my liking.

Merchandise would look much better with cleaner logo's.

I love this one and wish the used it on New Era hats.

Richmond tigers RFC logo - Google Search

www.google.com

 

[Marcel Proust]

Current logo is way too cartoony for my liking.

Merchandise would look much better with cleaner logo's.

I love this one and wish the used it on New Era hats.

Richmond tigers RFC logo - Google Search

www.google.com

The borussia dortmund style kits look nice

 

[Coach_Required]

Yes.

Personally I'm not a huge fan of the current one. The only saving grace is that we won a few flags with it.

I'd like to see something along the lines of this:
View attachment 1262437

Looks proper fierce, has character, doesn't look like a children's cartoon... I could do on.

Does everyone else like our current logo?

This just reminds me of years of failure

 

[Chat Pile]

This just reminds me of years of failure

the good ol' days

 

[Chat Pile]

No way. Our current identity is associated with our recent success, just as our old one was with our mediocrity.

Wouldn't even think about changing it any time soon.

That's a fair point that our current identity is tied to it, i just don't think it's an accurate representation of the club as it is now. It's not strong or fierce. Looks like a kitten.

 

[Chat Pile]

it just looks so ****ing good! I'm biased because this is the logo I grew up with, but I miss it every day.

 

[djspank]

View attachment 1262501

it just looks so ******* good! I'm biased because this is the logo I grew up with, but I miss it every day.

It does look good but it is from the era of failure.

 

[Chat Pile]

It does look good but it is from the era of failure.

that's all I knew up until a few years ago. I'm less put off by it

 

[djspank]

that's all I knew up until a few years ago. I'm less put off by it

I admit I still wear gear with that logo on it!

 

[Chat Pile]

I admit I still wear gear with that logo on it!

I bet you look good in it too.

A new logo with the fierce energy of the "loser" tiger would be good.

 

[tigerisland]

I'd like something more retro. Essendon's recent 150-year logo is the style I reckon we should go for

Who here follows the development of Essendon’s logo? What other crimes do you want to admit to here? Murder? Breaking Covid protocols?

 

[Hamsatma]

Who here follows the development of Essendon’s logo? What other crimes do you want to admit to here? Murder? Breaking Covid protocols?

Just like the minimalist old-timey design, no need to take any other tips from windy hill haha

 

[Waca Jr]

Nothing wrong with it

 

[Roksman]

View attachment 1262501

it just looks so ******* good! I'm biased because this is the logo I grew up with, but I miss it every day.

This is an apparel manufacturers / multimedia designers worst nightmare though.

There's too much happening.

Less is more.

 

[Chat Pile]

This is an apparel manufacturers / multimedia designers worst nightmare though.

There's too much happening.

Less is more.

that's a very valid point.

Just something in that realm is what I'm after. Not this cartoony looking thing we have now.

 

[fargothegreat]

View attachment 1262501

it just looks so ******* good! I'm biased because this is the logo I grew up with, but I miss it every day.

This one is too detailed to be a good logo.

I remember being a kid trying to draw this and it was a ****ing nightmare.

 

[Chat Pile]

This one is too detailed to be a good logo.

I remember being a kid trying to draw this and it was a ******* nightmare.

Yeah I remember my experience being the same.

A middle ground between the old and current would be interesting.

 

[No_Spoke]

This is an apparel manufacturers / multimedia designers worst nightmare though.

There's too much happening.

Less is more.

Spot on , current one is a flat logo which makes multimedia friendly

 

[Chat Pile]

Spot on , current one is a flat logo which makes multimedia friendly

Should a club logos be decided on whether it's multimedia friendly though? I'm not denying that's an important factor, especially for a business, but do you feel it is a good representation of our club?

Does it inspire any feelings other than "yep that's a sports logo"? It doesn't scream "eat em alive" personally. It purrs "meow"

 

[No_Spoke]

Should a club logos be decided on whether it's multimedia friendly though? I'm not denying that's an important factor, especially for a business, but do you feel it is a good representation of our club?

Does it inspire any feelings other than "yep that's a sports logo"? It doesn't scream "eat em alive" personally. It purrs "meow"

Yes, it should ,since the logo would be used by entities outside the club mostly on digital platforms. I dont mind it, it's not as aggressive looking as the old one but theres enough there

 

[Chat Pile]

Yes, it should ,since the logo would be used by entities outside the club mostly on digital platforms. I dont mind it, it's not as aggressive looking as the old one but theres enough there

but should it's use outside the club be the largest factor, in your opinion? Not having a go, i just it should represent the club first, then make efforts to ensure it's useable by others. If you think there's enough there then fair enough.