Mega Thread Draft Day Supermegaultrathread - It's finally here

kane249 · Apr 20, 2015

Play by Numbers said:
Tom Mitchell.

His bad disposal is what's stopping him getting a game with the Swans, do we really need more of that?

Play by Numbers · Apr 20, 2015

kane249 said:
His bad disposal is what's stopping him getting a game with the Swans, do we really need more of that?

His disposal is not that bad. I have seen him plan and its pretty decent.

Something else is going on. They are paying him fair coin to own the reserves.

Lyyynnnchy · Apr 20, 2015

Play by Numbers said:
His disposal is not that bad. I have seen him plan and its pretty decent.

Something else is going on. They are paying him fair coin to own the reserves.

Who would you replace in their side?

Josh Kennedy, Parker and Heeney are their inside mids and are all better than Mitchell

Play by Numbers · Apr 20, 2015

Lyyynnnchy said:
Who would you replace in their side?

Josh Kennedy, Parker and Heeney are their inside mids and are all better than Mitchell

But last season when there was a position available they still didn't play him (when not injured).

Point being he is excess to their needs but still very talented and probably undervalue at the trade table.

Obeanie1 · Apr 20, 2015

Dark Sharks said:
Is Yarran back on the cards now? He'd have currency for Carlton who i think will be going the full rebuild after this season.

I'd have Yarran in a heartbeat, straight swap for Selwood and maybe even a pick upgrade... Boom done.

Selwood is a free agent so how exactly would we trade him to anyone?

Read that Carlton are super keen on Darling.

Darling for Yarran + Cripps?

Darling for Yarran + their first rounder? Pick 2>4?

With Lamb + McGovern + Kennedy + Le cras would losing Darling be a price worth paying?

Tough call that one.

Bleedblueandgold · Apr 20, 2015

Not sure if it's been posted here yet, but nice goal by Jarrod Garlett on the weekend. Differently done, but almost Cockatoo-esque. Much smaller, but who knows, he could be just as good (or better).

Dark Sharks · Apr 20, 2015

Bleedblueandgold said:
Not sure if it's been posted here yet, but nice goal by Jarrod Garlett on the weekend. Differently done, but almost Cockatoo-esque. Much smaller, but who knows, he could be just as good (or better).

That was Yarran/Selwood all over again.

Great goal by Garlett, despite Hamish's usual cringe worthy commentary.

Yamumluvsbigcox · Apr 20, 2015

Obeanie1 said:
Darling for Yarran + their first rounder? Pick 2>4?

Tough call that one.

Easy call that one ! Ill even pack his tent for him

ROYAL EAGLE · Apr 20, 2015

Early at this stage would take Ah Chee and Jordan Snadden or Mitch Antonio

Hopefully we get another first rounder for Scott Selwood.

Jezzza · Apr 20, 2015

Don't think we will get a 1st rounder for Selwood, will be lucky to get a 2nd via FA & can't see any club offering 1st rounder as a trade.

ROYAL EAGLE · Apr 20, 2015

Jezzza said:
Don't think we will get a 1st rounder for Selwood, will be lucky to get a 2nd via FA & can't see any club offering 1st rounder as a trade.

Im talking about free agency compensation.

We cant trade him he's out of contract.

Jezzza · Apr 20, 2015

I did include FA in my post. Selwood was crap last year due to being injured, has only played one ordinary game so far this year & can you see anyone offering him a massive contract? The FA compensation has been watered down, unless you happen to be Melbourne who has lost the player.

Masto · Apr 20, 2015

Jezzza said:
I did include FA in my post. Selwood was crap last year due to being injured, has only played one ordinary game so far this year & can you see anyone offering him a massive contract? The FA compensation has been watered down, unless you happen to be Melbourne who has lost the player.

Its all about the size of the contract he receives. A broken down Dale Thomas netted Collingwood a 1st round pick. If Geelong offer a contract of the same size we'll get a 1st rounder.

Jezzza · Apr 20, 2015

Since then they have stated that FA compensation wouldn't be as generous & the Daisy contract was reportedly close to $700k a year over 4 years. Do you really think Geelong will offer anything close to that?

flamingEMBERS · Apr 20, 2015

Obeanie1 said:
Selwood is a free agent so how exactly would we trade him to anyone?

Read that Carlton are super keen on Darling.

Darling for Yarran + Cripps?

Darling for Yarran + their first rounder? Pick 2>4?

With Lamb + McGovern + Kennedy + Le cras would losing Darling be a price worth paying?

Tough call that one.

I'd Trade them Kennedy back but not Darling

swingdog · Apr 20, 2015

Yamumluvsbigcox said:
Easy call that one ! Ill even pack his tent for him

Likewise, but Ican't see it happening. The Blues are going to start a rebuild and won't be giving away high draft picks.

Prem87 · Apr 20, 2015

ROYAL EAGLE said:
Early at this stage would take Ah Chee and Jordan Snadden or Mitch Antonio

Hopefully we get another first rounder for Scott Selwood.

You reckon Selwood will leave?

He hasn't been the same player since 2011/2012, if we got a first rounder for him from FA compo we should take it and run..

Masto · Apr 20, 2015

Jezzza said:
Since then they have stated that FA compensation wouldn't be as generous & the Daisy contract was reportedly close to $700k a year over 4 years. Do you really think Geelong will offer anything close to that?

I've seen no such reports. I've only seen reports that there is no change. Frawley got a first round pick. Michael Rischitelli got an end of 1st round pick. Colin Sylvia got pick 23! I think we are going to do okay.

Masto · Apr 20, 2015

Prem87 said:
You reckon Selwood will leave?

He hasn't been the same player since 2011/2012, if we got a first rounder for him from FA compo we should take it and run..

Might be win/win/win. Our medicos can't get him right. He plays with his brother and a 2nd chance to get his foot right. We get a 1st round pick.

Jed Clampet · Apr 20, 2015

I wouldn't be trading Darling, maybe we could package up 2 or 3 of our midfielders and hope someone gives us one second round pick for them.

mattyc75 · Apr 20, 2015

Masto said:
I've seen no such reports. I've only seen reports that there is no change. Frawley got a first round pick. Michael Rischitelli got an end of 1st round pick. Colin Sylvia got pick 23! I think we are going to do okay.

lets hope so,cant see him leaving but if he did a first rounder would be awesome

Small Moves · Apr 20, 2015

Trade Darling... pfffft.

As if.

Suma Magic · Apr 20, 2015

Selwood should get as much money as Frawley. Would be a long deal too. End of first rounder a possibility though.

Righteo · Apr 20, 2015

You should get decent compo if Selwood leaves. I mean, we got pick 20 for Rhys Palmer...

Dark Sharks · Apr 21, 2015

Selwood winning the club champion will work in our favour. As will the fact we're going to finish so low.

I'll take an end of first rounder/start of second for him and run to the draft laughing.

Log In or Create New Account

Mega Thread Draft Day Supermegaultrathread - It's finally here

Doom does as he pleases

Norm Smith Medallist

Brownlow Medallist

Norm Smith Medallist

Hall of Famer

Brownlow Medallist

Premium Kent

Cancelled

Norm Smith Medallist

Club Legend

Norm Smith Medallist

Club Legend

Norm Smith Medallist

Club Legend

Premium Platinum

Brownlow Medallist

Cancelled

Norm Smith Medallist

Norm Smith Medallist

Team Captain

Brownlow Medallist

Premiership Player

Brownlow Medallist

Purple Campaigner

Premium Kent

Similar threads