List Mgmt. Draft Discussion 2016

[Kilroy]

Drawing on Knightmare, Skippos and Bishop's current Power Rankings here's their aggregated Top 30:

1 Petrevski-Seton
2 Brodie
3 Macreadie
4 Allison
5 Battle
6 Rotham
7 Berry
8 Bowes
9 Powell-Pepper
10 Scharenberg
11 Setterfield
12 Ainsworth
13 Simpkin
14 Parfitt
15 Graham
16 Scheer
17 McGrath
18 Clarke
19 Scrimshaw
20 McCluggage
21 Galluci
22 Goddard
23 Strnadica
24 Mutch
25 Kerr
26 Korewha
27 Witherden
28 Rolls
29 Sweet
30 Slimming

 

[Hayes4PM]

Drawing on Knightmare, Skippos and Bishop's current Power Rankings here's their aggregated Top 30:

1 Petrevski-Seton
2 Brodie
3 Macreadie
4 Allison
5 Battle
6 Rotham
7 Berry
8 Bowes
9 Powell-Pepper
10 Scharenberg
11 Setterfield
12 Ainsworth
13 Simpkin
14 Parfitt
15 Graham
16 Scheer
17 McGrath
18 Clarke
19 Scrimshaw
20 McCluggage
21 Galluci
22 Goddard
23 Strnadica
24 Mutch
25 Kerr
26 Korewha
27 Witherden
28 Rolls
29 Sweet
30 Slimming

Scharenberg at 10 and Simpkin at 13? I'd take those.

 

[Half Back Pocket]

McLuggage into top 10 as well imo

 

[Hayes4PM]

McLuggage into top 10 as well imo

The Human Suitcase

(The luggage related jokes will never stop)

 

[Dr Spaceman]

McLuggage into top 10 as well imo

The Human Suitcase

(The luggage related jokes will never stop)

Probably end up at an interstate team.

Should be able to handle all the travel.

 

[Defacto]

Knowing our luck we end up with another short ass in simpkin

 

[austinnn]

If we go for McCluggage, I hereby "claim" him as My Boy...

He's definitely the full package.

All jokes aside, I just think he'd be good to have in our squad.













Just in case.

 

[Kilroy]

If we beat the Bombers tomorrow the current 2016 AFL Draft would see us with pick #5 to begin with. If Harrison Macreadie goes before or at that pick we'd probably have pick 6 (if GWS take him with the pick Collingwood gave them plus a discount).

Sam Petrevski-Seton and Will Brodie could conceivably go #1 and #2.

Jacob Alison may well go to Brisbane and Jack Bowes to Gold Coast (zone picks) but that likely wouldn't change our choices even if they finish lower on the ladder.

Which would leave us to choose from:
Josh Battle (tall forward)
Josh Rotham (tall defender with some midfield potential)
Jarrod Berry
Sam Powell-Pepper
Jonty Scharenberg
Ben Ainsworth
Jy Simpkin
Brendan Parfitt
Jack Graham
Andrew McGrath
Dylan Clarke
Jack Scrimshaw (tall defender with some midfield potential)
Hugh McCluggage
Jordan Gallucci
Daniel Venables?

 

[austinnn]

I remember the first time I came across the McCluggage family. I was drinking in a pub and my mates spotted his elder brother, who they knew and who was a fairly big fella himself. They told me about him and I burst out laughing, shouting about what a silly name it was and basically using all the puns I've used on this thread. I was pretty drunk so was probably talking loudly and obnoxiously. As I said "what kind of a bloke is this McCluggage anyway?" like a smartarse, I felt a tap on my shoulder. I stopped and turned around and it was him.

He said "Carry on, mate"

 

[Defacto]

I remember the first time I came across the McCluggage family. I was drinking in a pub and my mates spotted his elder brother, who they knew and who was a fairly big fella himself. They told me about him and I burst out laughing, shouting about what a silly name it was and basically using all the puns I've used on this thread. I was pretty drunk so was probably talking loudly and obnoxiously. As I said "what kind of a bloke is this McCluggage anyway?" like a smartarse, I felt a tap on my shoulder. I stopped and turned around and it was him.

He said "Carry on, mate"

ROFL hahahahahaa

 

[wraglesweb]

Apparently St Kilda interested in Gaff, Just wondering what you guys would think would be a fair trade ?

 

[t_94]

Apparently St Kilda interested in Gaff, Just wondering what you guys would think would be a fair trade ?

A fair bit tbh. First rounder and a decent player. Surely he's happy and required at West Coast though? Gun player. Not sure Saints should give up what he'd be worth.

 

[wraglesweb]

A fair bit tbh. First rounder and a decent player. Surely he's happy and required at West Coast though? Gun player. Not sure Saints should give up what he'd be worth.

General consensus on our board is first pick and Acres.. We hope he doesn't leave..But apparently offered a big deal and hasn't signed yet

 

[t_94]

General consensus on our board is first pick and Acres.. We hope he doesn't leave..But apparently offered a big deal and hasn't signed yet

Wouldn't trade Acres and he's on a long term deal; will be a very good player. Reckon Gaff will sign anyway.

 

[Kilroy]

Apparently St Kilda interested in Gaff, Just wondering what you guys would think would be a fair trade ?

Tom Lee and a year's supply of Dare iced coffee?

 

[Defacto]

Wouldn't trade Acres and he's on a long term deal; will be a very good player. Reckon Gaff will sign anyway.

other issue with gaff is his kicking. its not elite and can be poor at times, due to how much KM's he punches out... i just feel it could be a bit like the jetta trade for wce, they get a good outside type that never reaches the same heights (i know its early days on jetta)

would be a good get though, but as you said, i think he stays at wce

 

[Hayes4PM]

I'm sure a fair deal for an out of contract player, who wants to go home can be sorted out between the Saints and the Eagles.

 

[The New Sainter]

other issue with gaff is his kicking. its not elite and can be poor at times, due to how much KM's he punches out... i just feel it could be a bit like the jetta trade for wce, they get a good outside type that never reaches the same heights (i know its early days on jetta)

would be a good get though, but as you said, i think he stays at wce

I think his footskills actually are elite. He can deliver some real lace out zingers. I think you might be exaggerating a bit here to fit the narrative?

I could be wrong.

 

[Mat Mann]

pick 46 wasn't it for a best 22 player?

 

[AFLOnline]

Drawing on Knightmare, Skippos and Bishop's current Power Rankings here's their aggregated Top 30:

1 Petrevski-Seton
2 Brodie
3 Macreadie
4 Allison
5 Battle
6 Rotham
7 Berry
8 Bowes
9 Powell-Pepper
10 Scharenberg
11 Setterfield
12 Ainsworth
13 Simpkin
14 Parfitt
15 Graham
16 Scheer
17 McGrath
18 Clarke
19 Scrimshaw
20 McCluggage
21 Galluci
22 Goddard
23 Strnadica
24 Mutch
25 Kerr
26 Korewha
27 Witherden
28 Rolls
29 Sweet
30 Slimming

Know Josh Battle pretty well. Trained with him a few times and played with his brother. Good young kid, always knew he was good, never top 5 in a draft good though. Think he could be a bit small to go that early.

 

[Hayes4PM]

pick 46 wasn't it for a best 22 player?

Yeah but this is different, Cripps was pick 24 in that draft and gaff was pick 4. So it'll be pick 21.

 

[Joffaboy]

General consensus on our board is first pick and Acres.. We hope he doesn't leave..But apparently offered a big deal and hasn't signed yet

Lol. First rounder and Acres.

 

[crasha301]

Barrels its time for your Monday scouting report.

 

[Joffaboy]

Barrels its time for your Monday scouting report.

Better still revive your post on Paddy and Derm from yesterday for your loyal fans.

 

[Barrels]

Barrels its time for your Monday scouting report.

No TAC Cup footy this week lad.

Better still revive your post on Paddy and Derm from yesterday for your loyal fans.

Was it taken down?