Edwards or King?

[Madtiger2006]

King looks like a depth player at best(A bit like Johnson should be once our young team goes bang). He doesn't have any real assets and looks like he would turn the ball over under pressure alot. I'd rather play Edwards. Not sure was he was dropped after the WC game.

 

[CoggaRules]

King looks like a depth player at best(A bit like Johnson should be once our young team goes bang). He doesn't have any real assets and looks like he would turn the ball over under pressure alot. I'd rather play Edwards. Not sure was he was dropped after the WC game.

our problems dont revovle around players that play the roles that these 2 do.
Hence talk about whether they are in or out, borders on insignifiacance.
Which, in all due respect says alot about your footy nouse.

 

[PHX]

I'd rather play Edwards for Tivendale and leave King to play the hard tough stuff.

Edwards and King play two very different roles.

 

[Madtiger2006]

our problems dont revovle around players that play the roles that these 2 do.
Hence talk about whether they are in or out, borders on insignifiacance.
Which, in all due respect says alot about your footy nouse.

Our problem is exactly what I'm talking about. Not playing the 22 who are going to take us places. We have a very promising young goal to goal line. We have some very promising midfielders to add to the senior team. But there are 4 or 5 players in our team who shouldn't be in there

 

[guruisatiger]

play them both kingy for his hard attack on the footy and edwards for his run and skill

 

[Madtiger2006]

play them both kingy for his hard attack on the footy and edwards for his run and skill

I prefer Howat and Edwards over King

 

[HBK619]

Our problem is exactly what I'm talking about. Not playing the 22 who are going to take us places. We have a very promising young goal to goal line. We have some very promising midfielders to add to the senior team. But there are 4 or 5 players in our team who shouldn't be in there

Of course there are 4 or 5 players who shouldn't be there, we have Simmo, Browny, Cogs, Tambling and Knobel out of our side injured, that would mean that there is going to be 4ish players who aren't in our best 22.

 

[Weaver]

King is 23 with a year's worth of VFL behind him. Play him now and make an informed decision about him at the end of the season.

Edwards is a teenager. Give him the time he needs to develop. No point just dumping blokes in the seniors because of some fantasy that getting bruised and humiliated every week is good for their development.

 

[Truetiger]

Get over it Toby lol. Both are different players and play in different positions. There for both should be in the line up.