Elliot Yeo v Will Hoskin-Elliott

[Big Fresh]

Which player would you rather have at your club?

 

[Bulldog1954]

Hoskin-Elliot's reputation far exceeds his performance.

He is a great athlete, who had a decent 2014 and did bugger all in 2015. He got single figure disposals in 5 of 11 games last season and kicked 3 goals for the year.

Yeo by an absolute mile - it's not close

 

[Mofra]

Yeo for me - WHE is icing, not cake.
Yeo has the ability to play big bodied mid or shutdown taller forwards, flexibility is very highly rated by coaches in the modern game.

 

[Stifler's mom]

WHE has the scope and talent to be an A grader.
Right now Yeo is performing better but I believe WHE could become outstanding.

 

[Dannnnnnnnnn]

WHE has shown almost nothing in the way of consistent, solid football and is rated highly because of reputation, attributes and "potential". Yeo has demonstrated ability and output as a defender, midfielder and forward and is a clear best 22 player for a grand finalist, despite being a month younger. I don't really see how you could go WHE at this stage, he just hasn't looked like putting it all together as yet. He might get there and I wouldn't be writing him off, but this poll is currently very lopsided in my opinion.

 

[eth-dog]

WHE is lucky to be on GWS' list, Elliott Yeo is a top 5 midfielder against the Grand Finalist of last year.

 

[Upgrayedd]

Yeo will be a premier midfielder in 18 months, Fantastic athlete, Poor mans fyfe with better kicking.

 

[juss]

Love Yeo, great to watch, really coming on.

 

[Sando22]

Yeo every day of the week.