Fantasy Draft Voting- Anyone can vote

[saintkildaman]

Okay, here it is; the voting for the Fantasy Draft.

Anyone can vote and they can vote for anyone. We are waiting on two teams but we can postphone it anymore, so I guess it is there loss.



Shameless-
FB: N.MAXWELL (VC) H.TAYLOR J.SURJAN
HB: G.BIRCHALL N.BROWN H.O'BRIEN
C: A.COONEY D.CASSISI J.MCVEIGH
HF: S.JOHNSON J.KENNEDY D.JACKSON
FF: A.MONFRIES T.WALKER A.GOODES (VC)
R: H.MCINTOSH C.JUDD (C) B.SEWELL
I/C: P.BOWER P.DUFFIELD R.PALMER SUB: S.SIDEBOTTOM
Emg: B.MCEVOY R.BASTINAC C.YARRAN
Res: M.JAMISON B.EBERT S.WRIGHT G.ROHAN A.WONNAEMIRRI


StKMan-
FB: G.Johncock J.Frawley S.Gilbert
HB: C.Morton N.Bock(C) J.Grimes
C: S.Hill D.Martin J.Lewis
HF: D.Beams T.Cloke C.Rioli
FF: T.Banfield J.Anthony C.Knights

R: M.Kruezer B.Vince G.Ablett (C)

I: L.Jetta A.Joesph B.McLean

S: A.McPhee

Emg: A.Morabito A.Embley M.Firrito

Reserves: L.Greenwood L.Adams D.Brogan M.Thomas H.Hocking


Andolate-

FB- J.Drummond M.MaguireL.Shoey HB- A.Otten C.Enright C.Bruce
C- M.Priddis M.Murphy B.Stanton
HF- T.Varcoe N.Riewoldt T.Rockliff FF- D.Petrie M.Morton J.Watts J

R- M.Leunenberger P.Chapman B.Gibbs
I- S.Tuck R.Clarke A.Walker
S- K.Bradley
Emg- J. Porplyzia B.Moles A.Rance
Reserves- D.Prestia P.Vespresmi B.Symes M.Banner


L_W_P
B. Guerra (Haw) - B. Lake (WB) - T. Pears (Ess)
X. Ellis (Haw) - M. Hurley (Ess) - J. Gram (StK)
A. Davey (Melb) - K. Cornes (PA) - L. Davis (Coll)
D. Thomas (Coll) - J. Roughead (Haw) - R. Murphy (WB)
D. Motlop (PA) - B. Fevola (BL) - A. Davey (Ess)
A. Sandilands (Freo) - J. Winderlich (Ess) - B. Deledio (Rich)

F. Ray (StK) - M. Johnson (Freo)
J. Gwilt (StK) - J. Adcock (BL)

S. Hampson (Carl) - C. Masten (WCE) - J. McKenzie (Melb)

B. Miller (Rich)
D. Zaharakis (Ess)
S. Atley (NM)
J. Toy (GC)
D. Heppell (Ess)


AussieThunda-
B: Lindsay Gilbee, Dustin Fletcher, Darren Milburn
HB: Shannon Hurn, Scott D Thompson, Nick Malceski
C: Leigh Montagna, Daniel Kerr, Brendon Goddard
HF: Robbie Gray, Ryan OKeefe, Shaun Higgins
F: Mark LeCras, Daniel Bradshaw, Eddie Betts

R: Darren Jolly, Nick Dal Santo, Steven Salopek

I: Rhys Stanley, Jack Ziebell, , Nathan Foley, Lachlan Henderson

Emg: Robert Warnock, Daniel Harris, Ben Cunnington, Sharrod Wellingham

Reserves: Reece Conca, Charlie Dixon, Josh Fraser, Ben Jacobs










Goodie23-
FB: Sam Fisher - Alipate Carlile - Campbell Brown
HB: Tadgh Kennelly - Dale Morris - Joel Corey
C: Daniel Cross - Daniel Rich - Ryan Griffen
HF: Lindsay Thomas - Lance Franklin - Shannon Byrnes
FF: Adam Schneider - Jack Riewoldt - Jarrad Grant

R: Paddy Ryder - Jimmy Bartel - Clinton Jones

I: Todd Goldstein - Liam Picken - Josh Hunt

Sub: Luke McPharlin

Emg: Brad Ottens - Tyson Goldsack - Jackson Trengove

Reserves: Hamish Hartlett - Chris Dawes - Martin Mattner - Tommy Walsh - Robert Eddy


AussieThunda2-

B: Nathan Crackwhore, Josh Gibson, Heath Scotland
HB: Brad Sheppard, Heath Grundy, Chad Cornes
C: Daniel Hannebury, Brent Harvey, Michael Rischitelli
HF: Daniel Gia, Tom Hawkins, Colin Sylvia
F: David Rodan, Barry Hall, James Podsiadly
R: David Hille, Lenny Hayes, Chance Bateman

Inter: Nic Natanui, Cale Hooker, Brent Moloney, Richard Douglas

Emer: Brandon Matera , Brent Renouf, Jack Steven, Brent Prismall

Reserves: Ryan Schoenmakers, Jared Polec, Kyle Reimers, Mitch Wallis



GoddardisGod-
FB: A. McGrath, Staker, Tambling
HB: H. Shaw, Silvagni, Waite
C: Burgoyne, Kennedy, Ibottson
Hf: Stokes, Pavlich, Mayne
Ff: Krakouer, Hansen, Jurrah
R: Cox, Black, A. Selwood
I: Brennan, R. Shaw , Pearce
S: Lovett-Murray

Emg: Jamar, Carazzo, McVeigh

Reserves: Gaff ,Fyfe, McCarthy, Hudson, Dempster

StKMan2-
FB: J.Harbrow B.Rutten(C) B.Rawlings
HB: D.Mundy P.Davis D.Wells
C: S.Thompson(C) D.Swan K.Jack
HF: A.Didak J.Shultz M.Barlow
FF: H.Ballantyne Q.Lynch B.McGlynn

R: S.Jacobs T.Boak M.Boyd

I: L.Power J.Bolton N.Jones

S- J.White

Emg: D.Glass M.Seaby C.Ward

Reserves: J.Melksham T.Chaplin K.Hunt B.Howlett T.Simpkin

 

[saintkildaman]

Need as heaps of votes ASAP.

 

[goodie23]

I've been upgraded from Goodie to Goddie, I like it

Naturally I rate my team the highest, but here's how I rank the others:

Shameless (Would probably compete with my team the best)
L_W_P (Very close second, midfield's a little shaky, but that's a very impressive backline)
AussieThunda (Good strong team, but your bookends are ancient)
StKMan (Another good backline but let down by the forwards)
StKMan2 (Some fine players but a popgun forward line)
GoddardisGod (Too many questions over your backs, can Staker, Silvagni & Tambling stand up, can Waite not get suspended)
AussieThunda2 (With the exception of Grundy, not sold on the spine.)
Andolate (Some good pick-ups but returning from injury, Maguire, Petrie, Raph, Otten. Morton's not a full forward, Enright's not a CHB.)

All opinions, feel free to disagree but doubt you'll change my mind

 

[saintkildaman]

Hahaha, your team is godlike.

 

[Kildonan]

I think StKMan2 has the best team except his forwards are crap. Lets him down completely. Imagine having such a strong defence that you have Glass as an emergency and Troy Chaplin as a reserve outside your best 25

(1) Goodie23 has the best all round team - there are many better defences than his but the players he has chosen can adapt to several roles

(2) L_W_P has the second best all round team

(3) AussieThunda is my pick for third best

 

[saintkildaman]

My second team was origionally AFLOnlines, but he wasnt active so I took over got about 3 picks

 

[stkildathunda]

I
AussieThunda (Good strong team, but your bookends are ancient)

AussieThunda2 (With the exception of Grundy, not sold on the spine.)

Yea i agree they are ancient but remember we never decided on what we were basing it all on. Was never mentioned at the start that we were basing anything on this years results.


On AT2 im not a fan of that side either, had nothing to play with when i took over as i had way too many forwards and no backs or mids.

 

[goodie23]

Yea i agree they are ancient but remember we never decided on what we were basing it all on. Was never mentioned at the start that we were basing anything on this years results.

Fair point, but I drafted for the long term anyway. All my starting 22 are under 30, the entire team would be if I didn't pick up Ottens as a bargain pick to play a King-type mentor role.

I do like your team, there are a few players in there I wanted (Le Cras, Hurn, Gray for starters). But if Bradshaw or Fletcher go down, and they're more likely to at their age, you'll really struggle to cover them. Your emergencies, reserves and half your bench are quite raw, with a little more key position depth I might've listed you #1.

AT2, there were still some backs on the table. I'd start Ben Reid at fullback well ahead of Gibson who's been punching above his weight for some time and Bate (and Podsiadly) are better CHF candidates than Hawkins. Plus it's not helped by my dislike of Bubblehead Hall.

 

[stkildathunda]

Fair point, but I drafted for the long term anyway. All my starting 22 are under 30, the entire team would be if I didn't pick up Ottens as a bargain pick to play a King-type mentor role.

I do like your team, there are a few players in there I wanted (Le Cras, Hurn, Gray for starters). But if Bradshaw or Fletcher go down, and they're more likely to at their age, you'll really struggle to cover them. Your emergencies, reserves and half your bench are quite raw, with a little more key position depth I might've listed you #1.

AT2, there were still some backs on the table. I'd start Ben Reid at fullback well ahead of Gibson who's been punching above his weight for some time and Bate (and Podsiadly) are better CHF candidates than Hawkins. Plus it's not helped by my dislike of Bubblehead Hall.

Yea position depth would have been handy, but honestly i was kinda over it after my initial starting 18 and then just picked players I knew or who i first came across that was available
I guess the selection of Bradshaw was forced as all the good key forwards were snapped up early so thought he could help out the young guns in Stanley, Henderson & Dixon. Can also throw Fraser up forward if injuries strike. Actually looking at my list i really have no backup key defenders



With AT2 i didnt bring any forwards in, they were all auto selected before i took over and I couldnt bring myself to bring in any Collingwood players.

 

[L_W_P]

StKMan - Thank you so much for taking this back over hehe Work has been chaotic this last week.

As much as I would like to vote for myself I actually don't think I've ended up with the best team.

My vote has gone to Goodie23.

The only change I would make would be to switch Morris and Fisher as I really don't rate Morris as a key defender. It may be a little bit of bias because we get to watch Roo tear him up every time we play but I think it would look just that little bit better with Fish at CHB.

Big thanks to everyone involved. It was a car crash at times but we got there in the end. Awards will be given out at the end of the year and I'll work out a better structure for the draft and playing guidelines for 2012.

Until then folks - Gooooooooooooooo the mighty SAINTERS!!!!!

 

[stkildathunda]

Seems this has been forgotten.

At this stage its a 3 way tie between

Shameless
Goodie23
Aussiethunda


I suggest maybe a new poll with only those 3 choices??

 

[Highlander35]

Thogut it was really good fun, even thought we didn't really know what to do in the end.

Maybe next off-season with a better idea of what to do. Upon review a few weeks later, yeah. My backline is pretty shit. Especially KPD's.

 

[Mindtraveller]

Aussiethunda looks like the winner, has good midfield depth and solid everywhere else. Shameless lucked out with N. Brown

 

[StFly]

Aussiethunda looks like the winner, has good midfield depth and solid everywhere else. Shameless lucked out with N. Brown

Depends how you look at it, some people might have been voting based on past efforts breeding future success, others on that dreaded P word in potential and others again merely for 2011 and thus haven't voted since the season hasn't started proper yet for anyone to "win".

A season ending injury to a single player does not then ruin a team unless you define the context of the choices made.

 

[Shameless]

Aussiethunda looks like the winner, has good midfield depth and solid everywhere else. Shameless lucked out with N. Brown

Jamison goes alright too ;-)

 

[saintkildaman]

Aussiethunda wins

 

[Mindtraveller]

I voted with aussie based on potential. Just waiting for Kerr, Higgins and Gray to get injured. If they manage to stay on the park for the season. Exciting things should happen.