Feedback thread

[rizzo]

PLease leave you Feedback for what we should include for the up and coming season.

 

[rizzo]

So at the end of the year no one can bitch about rules or gameplay ect because no1 has left feedback.

CMON theonlyway to make the gamebetter is to tell us what needs fixing

 

[Gaz_87]

There should be a rule that you can't put your team in until after the AFL side's have said there teams... to save Russian from having to pick the player who scored of the highest of there list and he gets to play... this is unfair not only on the person they are playing but everyone else who puts there team in without players who won't play.

 

[GeeCat]

Originally posted by Gaz_87
There should be a rule that you can't put your team in until after the AFL side's have said there teams... to save Russian from having to pick the player who scored of the highest of there list and he gets to play... this is unfair not only on the person they are playing but everyone else who puts there team in without players who won't play.

Then what do you propose the teams who are unavailable to select their team on the Thursday or Friday for whaever reason do?

 

[Gaz_87]

Originally posted by GeeCat
Then what do you propose the teams who are unavailable to select their team on the Thursday or Friday for whaever reason do?

Yes I understand that SOME weeks people will need to put there teams in early for one reason or another... but unlike roylion and Al who have put there teams in early pretty much 12 out of the 15 rounds.

 

[Roylion]

Originally posted by Gaz_87
Yes I understand that SOME weeks people will need to put there teams in early for one reason or another... but unlike roylion and Al who have put there teams in early pretty much 12 out of the 15 rounds.

You could at least present the facts, instead of some made up rubbish.

My teams have been named at the following times.
Round 1 - Saturday (edited on the Friday before the deadline, after the teams were known)
Round 2 - Thursday
Round 3 - Wednesday (after Gaz-87's team) NOT EDITED
Round 4 - Thursday
Round 5 - Friday
Round 6 - Friday (after Gaz_87 on Thursday)
Round 7 - Thursday (after Gaz_87)
Round 8 - Wednesday (edited on the Friday before the deadline, after the teams were known)
Round 9 - Thursday
Round 10 - Friday (after Gaz_87's team on Thursday)
Round 11 - Friday (after Gaz_87's team)
Round 12 - Thursday
Round 13 - Wednesday (edited on the Friday before the deadline, after the teams were known)
Round 14 - Tuesday (edited on the Friday before the deadline, after the teams were known)
Round 15 - Tuesday. NOT EDITED

So in actual fact, only TWICE (Round 3 and Round 15) over the last 15 rounds, have I posted my final side where the AFL teams have not been known. Four times I have edited my team before the deadline on Friday night. 5 times I've posted my team after Gaz_87, who indeed named his team early on at least once occasion.

Where he pulled this "pretty much 12 out of the 15 rounds" from is somewhat of a mystery. Although I think I can guess.

Originally posted by Gaz_87
There should be a rule that you can't put your team in until after the AFL side's have said there teams... to save Russian from having to pick the player who scored of the highest of there list and he gets to play... this is unfair not only on the person they are playing but everyone else who puts there team in without players who won't play.

If Gaz_87 is so concerned about this, then this "problem" is easily addressed. Every side names 22 players before the deadline and if a player from the top 18 is injured or not playing then he can only be replaced by one of the four on the interchange bench. Anyone not named in the 22 for that week cannot contribute to the team's score, even if he is selected for his AFL side.

If the top 22 are going to contribute to the score, then each side names three emergencies and players who score can only be selected from the 22 named + the three emergencies named for that week. Anyone outside this does not score for the team, even if they do score points in the AFL for that week (no matter how high or how low their score is).