FFS Get over Judd!!!

[Wally Matera]

Bit tired of hearing all this talk about Judd. Why do Richmond supporters always want to be involved in things? Why are we always quick to want to be part of the big issues? Is it our way of trying to increase our importance?

Look back at the history of our trading... not much has come of it. Let WCE and Carlton do their business and lets just get on with worrying about what we can control. Improving what we currently have!

If Judd comes to us in the PSD, great - so be it... but why involve ourselves in this game of cat and mouse? Move on... It will only hurt us as history tells us.

 

[nut]

Bit tired of hearing all this talk about Judd. Why do Richmond supporters always want to be involved in things? Why are we always quick to want to be part of the big issues? Is it our way of trying to increase our importance?

Look back at the history of our trading... not much has come of it. Let WCE and Carlton do their business and lets just get on with worrying about what we can control. Improving what we currently have!

If Judd comes to us in the PSD, great - so be it... but why involve ourselves in this game of cat and mouse? Move on... It will only hurt us as history tells us.

You have to be kidding, a chance to screw carlton over, an oppurtunity like that doesn't h appenvery often, and it's our duty to.

We will benefit the most out of the Trade period because we have Pick 1 in the psd, so we have to be apart of it.

 

[jackson_rules]

You have to be kidding, a chance to screw carlton over, an oppurtunity like that doesn't very often, and it's out duty to.

We will benefit the most out of the Trade period because we have Pick 1 in the psd, so we have to be apart of it.

i agree why not throw our weight around abit, we are in the box seat wether we get judd or not we could very well improve our list from the deal

 

[Bulldog89]

i agree why not throw our weight around abit, we are in the box seat wether we get judd or not we could very well improve our list from the deal

we will not get judd!!ffs

 

[nut]

we will not get judd!!ffs

If Carlton aren't prepared to give up pick 1 then guess what...... we have the next best thing,

 

[jackson_rules]

we will not get judd!!ffs

i didnt say we were getting judd you f ucking w@nker learn to read my freind, all i said we are in the box seat to improve our playing list here i know were not getting judd but theres a chance and imo if we get him i wont mind but i never thought we would get him ok **** head

 

[Wally Matera]

i agree why not throw our weight around abit, we are in the box seat wether we get judd or not we could very well improve our list from the deal

How? History says that everytime we try to "improve our list" we get burnt!

Unless he comes for nothing, we shouldnt be getting involved. Pick 2 stays and the rest can go as hard as they like.

 

[jackson_rules]

How? History says that everytime we try to "improve our list" we get burnt!

Unless he comes for nothing, we shouldnt be getting involved. Pick 2 stays and the rest can go as hard as they like.

we should deal if it is an improvement not a maybe improvement, im for that if its not the case then no trading simple mate

 

[LennyLeonard]

If Carlton aren't prepared to give up pick 1 then guess what...... we have the next best thing,

He Doesn't want to play at your Club. West Coast and Carlton will do the deal. Pick 2 is better that pick 3 but if Judd doesn't want Richmond then pick 3 is better than nothing.

 

[nut]

He Doesn't want to play at your Club. West Coast and Carlton will do the deal. Pick 2 is better that pick 3 but if Judd doesn't want Richmond then pick 3 is better than nothing.

Well we would give them pick 2 twit.

 

[LennyLeonard]

Well we would give them pick 2 twit.

Twit???????????? Judd has to agree to the trade. West Coast just can't send him to Richmond .All parties must agree.

 

[Bulldog89]

i didnt say we were getting judd you f ucking w@nker learn to read my freind, all i said we are in the box seat to improve our playing list here i know were not getting judd but theres a chance and imo if we get him i wont mind but i never thought we would get him ok **** head

f*** head at the end of the day he has chosen to go to carlton..meaning he wants to play for carlton!!we dont need to get involved he doesnt wanna play for richmond otherwise he would have said I wanna play for richmond..no need to get involved c*** eyes..should jus get ova it and take a good youngster with our no.2 pick

 

[Bulldog89]

Bit tired of hearing all this talk about Judd. Why do Richmond supporters always want to be involved in things? Why are we always quick to want to be part of the big issues? Is it our way of trying to increase our importance?

Look back at the history of our trading... not much has come of it. Let WCE and Carlton do their business and lets just get on with worrying about what we can control. Improving what we currently have!

If Judd comes to us in the PSD, great - so be it... but why involve ourselves in this game of cat and mouse? Move on... It will only hurt us as history tells us.

Fully agree

 

[nut]

Twit???????????? Judd has to agree to the trade. West Coast just can't send him to Richmond .All parties must agree.

WE DONT HAVE TO TRADE FOR HIM.... we can get him by doing another deal with WC which would force him to the PSD where we have pick 1.
Morton for pick 2 and 18 or what ever. Judd doesn't have to be involved at all. ARE YOU DUMB???????????

I starting to get a little frustrated with %$@#n twits.

 

[jackson_rules]

f*** head at the end of the day he has chosen to go to carlton..meaning he wants to play for carlton!!we dont need to get involved he doesnt wanna play for richmond otherwise he would have said I wanna play for richmond..no need to get involved c*** eyes..should jus get ova it and take a good youngster with our no.2 pick

you still failed to read what i had to say about judd and us trading

 

[LennyLeonard]

WE DONT HAVE TO TRADE FOR HIM.... we can get him by doing another deal with WC which would force him to the PSD where we have pick 1.
Morton for pick 2 and 18 or what ever. Judd doesn't have to be involved at all. ARE YOU DUMB???????????

I starting to get a little frustrated with %$@#n twits.

3 ,20 and Kennedy is a better offer than 2 and 18. West coast get Morton or Cotchin at 3 as well as a key position palyer and pick 20. Do the math champ. He is coming to Carlton get over it.

 

[Bazzar]

Look back at the history of our trading... not much has come of it.

History says that everytime we try to "improve our list" we get burnt!

So you are pissed off we went all out for Brown, Simmonds and Polak?

 

[Dodgy Barry]

3 ,20 and Kennedy is a better offer than 2 and 18. West coast get Morton or Cotchin at 3 as well as a key position palyer and pick 20. Do the math champ. He is coming to Carlton get over it.

BOLLOCKS

Kennedy not fit to be the water boy in the D grade Kalgoorlie league. Get it through your thick skull. Kenneddy = trash.

Therefore 2 + 18 > 3 + 19

Back to school chump

 

[Wally Matera]

So you are pissed off we went all out for Brown, Simmonds and Polak?

None of them we have "massively" won in.

Brown - broke leg, bad luck... but at the end of the day, we havent got we've paid for. Therefore, we've been burnt.

Simmo - likely to be the best return of the 3. First year was poor (not entirley his fault, bad coaching), second year was excellent, third year injuries. But because we gave up nothing, then we're likely to win that one.

Polak - good season, but jury is out mate. Dont count your chickens...

 

[thylacine60]

Pass the popcorn. Just loving you clowns tearing each other apart in a futile argument. Go hard Tiggers!