Formal Protest re:Player Valuation.

[Presti_is_god]

Collingwood wish to protest the value placed on youngster Brad Moran.

Brad Moran - $250,000

He has played a total of 2 games yet commands more than a number of players who play around the 20 mark.

 

[crazy_big_al]

I agree

what about this then

33. Brad Symes - $402,000

last year was $44.25

 

[Russian]

Salaries are done mainly on average scores from 2006, experienced players adjusted based on the 2006 salary, inexperienced generally get adjusted down but not too far because otherwise you'll just put them on 5 year contracts and there values will probably go up well beyond what you're paying very quickly, and any players with career threatening injuries get cut too.

Symes I didn't adjust but should've, I'll make him 360

Moran I did adjust - his scores gave him 295 so I've already cut a lot off it, I'll think about it

You can protest, but consider the first paragraph before you do - don't waste my time with silly protests

and on that $44k for last year - that's because I never included match payments for draftees last year, so consequently they were incredibly cheap. This year I've added in match payments for the average number of games played by draftees so 44 last year would be I think 75 this year

 

[BW]

Marc Murphy - $70,000
Grant Birchall - $100,000

 

[andrew_embley]

Adelaide

5. Adam Campbell - $92,000 - Played like 1 or 2 games
18. Andrew McDougall - $210,000 - Only played 1 game. Just 1 game.
26. Benjamin Sharp - $92,000 - Is a West Coast Rookie - So hasn't played a senior game, let alone been elevated
29. Brad Smith - $92,000 - 2 knee recos in 2 years as we know. Hasn't played 1 game
36. Tom Williams - $92,000 - Hasn't played 1 game due to injury
37. Joshua Wooden - $225,000 - Played like 2 games i think. Not too worried about him though as i'm gonna delist him anyway.

The McDougall one is huge for a guy who played 1 game. Williams also.

 

[Russian]

Marc Murphy - $70,000
Grant Birchall - $100,000

draft picks, fixed one year salaries

5. Adam Campbell - $92,000 - Played like 1 or 2 games
26. Benjamin Sharp - $92,000 - Is a West Coast Rookie - So hasn't played a senior game, let alone been elevated
29. Brad Smith - $92,000 - 2 knee recos in 2 years as we know. Hasn't played 1 game
36. Tom Williams - $92,000 - Hasn't played 1 game due to injury

92's the minimum for a non 1st/2nd year player

18. Andrew McDougall - $210,000 - Only played 1 game. Just 1 game.
37. Joshua Wooden - $225,000 - Played like 2 games i think. Not too worried about him though as i'm gonna delist him anyway.

Fair enough - both 177

Moran 220

 

[sante]

You don't have Rowan Nayna's salary and he isn't on the list you posted but I've listed him

 

[Russian]

You don't have Rowan Nayna's salary and he isn't on the list you posted but I've listed him

Nayna was delisted by the Dogs last year

 

[sante]

Nayna was delisted by the Dogs last year

LOL

 

[andrew_embley]

draft picks, fixed one year salaries92's the minimum for a non 1st/2nd year player Fair enough - both 177

Moran 220

thanks Russian

 

[rizzo]

30. Travis Varcoe* - $100,000

Hasnt played a game yet, buts worth more then murphy whose played half a season, and equall with birchal who played 15+ Games.

 

[Russian]

30. Travis Varcoe* - $100,000

Hasnt played a game yet, buts worth more then murphy whose played half a season, and equall with birchal who played 15+ Games.

first round draft pick vs third round draft pick

next

 

[rizzo]

first round draft pick vs third round draft pick

next

Fair enuf big fella, just wanted to know the reasoning

 

[BW]

What a coincidence that he brings that up after he trades Murphy

 

[GeeCat]

A small one, but worth it considering the hassle you made me go through with Hawkins (), so here goes:

Ryley Dunn - $120K

Kid has played 4 career games, zilch in '06, yet is higher than other players who have played more games (both during their career, and in '06). If guys like Willoughby and Trotter are sitting in the 90K zone, then surely Ryley would have to be in the same cat?