GAJ

[TheOz]

AFAIK, this is his team;

http://supercoach.heraldsun.com.au/other_teams/?tid=7401

It's obvious that he totally fluked 2013.

 

[MightyMark]

It's obvious that he totally fluked 2013.

Lets be honest all the research in the world doesn't mean jack if you dont have a bit of luck.

 

[TheOz]

Lets be honest all the research in the world doesn't mean jack if you dont have a bit of luck.

His 2013 starting team wasn't particularly great either, he got lucky with Cloke's 190+ game however also innovatively traded him out at his high point which was very clever. The blokes who won it back when we were down at twenty trades and before the season where we had like 3 rookies on each line thanks to Gold Coast had to get their teams 100% correct before the season, rookies and all.

 

[MightyMark]

His 2013 starting team wasn't particularly great either, he got lucky with Cloke's 190+ game however also innovatively traded him out at his high point which was very clever. The blokes who won it back when we were down at twenty trades and before the season where we had like 3 rookies on each line thanks to Gold Coast had to get their teams 100% correct before the season, rookies and all.

Thats true, but they didn't have to worry about the sub.

 

[TheOz]

Thats true, but they didn't have to worry about the sub.

More trades and many more rookies (during GC/GWS first few years) made it much more easier even with the subs to start with a crappier team.

 

[Kadog]

His 2013 starting team wasn't particularly great either, he got lucky with Cloke's 190+ game however also innovatively traded him out at his high point which was very clever. The blokes who won it back when we were down at twenty trades and before the season where we had like 3 rookies on each line thanks to Gold Coast had to get their teams 100% correct before the season, rookies and all.

I think he started with Blicavs as R2 that year.

 

[Pedro]

Can't see myself trading him out. Only to trade him back in later. I wouldn't be totally unhappy if I didn't start with him though. The risk is there by keeping him in, but hopefully so is the reward.

 

[CaptainChardonnay]

If you have him, you stick with him... If you don't, like me, you don't trade him in either....

I'm comfortable with my call not to have him and can understand why you would trade him out if you did. But if it was me, I'd hold. Same as I'm holding Spud 1 (Jelwood) and spud 2 (Aswallow).

 

[KardiniaPark]

If you have him, you stick with him... If you don't, like me, you don't trade him in either....

I'm comfortable with my call not to have him and can understand why you would trade him out if you did. But if it was me, I'd hold. Same as I'm holding Spud 1 (Jelwood) and spud 2 (Aswallow).

They killed me

 

[CaptainChardonnay]

They killed me

Yep. Had the chance to take Fyfe as C as well and left it with Jelwood because he's a "Big game player"...

Cost me about 10k spots!

 

[Big Fozza]

Yep. Had the chance to take Fyfe as C as well and left it with Jelwood because he's a "Big game player"...

Cost me about 10k spots!

i could have taken Ablett's score but went with Jelwood...

 

[Lums23]

i could have taken Ablett's score but went with Jelwood...

I ended up going with Ablett's score instead of risking Selwood. Was it you that told me to take risks???

 

[Daniels]

AFAIK, this is his team;

http://supercoach.heraldsun.com.au/other_teams/?tid=7401

Ta.

Interesting. Looks ultra standard. No real shocks...? Only J. Kolodjashnji if any.

 

[Chism]

They killed me

A Swallow will destroy the Lions at Etihad after the showing they put up in S.A last week.

Stick with him.

 

[matt_bas]

Gaz, Ibbotson out
Lewis Gibson in

Unfortunately Gaz needs a few weeks for his shoulder to heal. He might keep playing all season and average 110-120. But at his price it ain't good enough. Can get Lewis in 150k cheaper to average the same and I can fix up my backline.

Could be a winning move by jumping off before the rest of the 45% does. Got a bit of the Bruyn Manoeuvre about it.

2 prems in, Hawks won't lose all year going by yesterday's game.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Be carful Gibsons scores aren't effected when Birchell comes back. I personally would wait a week. What happens if GAJ scores 150 vs the saints, which is more than possible.

 

[matt_bas]

Surely if you started with him, you keep him. Why? Because inevitably, he WILL start pumping out 150's and you WILL want him back.

When he does:

1) you'll need to burn another trade to get him back
2) you'll get burnt scoring wise by not having him and a high percentage of others will
3) you may need to forego an opportunity to do an upgrade/corrective trade or trade in a rookie on the bubble because you need to use a trade to get GAJ back.

My thoughts exactly. Why burn a trade? He may lose value but what does it matter if you aren't going to trade him out? I picked him for a reason, and 120 on a bad day, I'll take that.

 

[KardiniaPark]

A Swallow will destroy the Lions at Etihad after the showing they put up in S.A last week.

Stick with him.

I am, but I reserve my right to whinge constantly until he does something

 

[Big Fozza]

I ended up going with Ablett's score instead of risking Selwood. Was it you that told me to take risks???

haha, yes i believe it was.

 

[TheOz]

Nick ‏@nicko_1984
@championdata how is it possible Gary Ablett got 119 supercoach points from a pretty ordinary performance??
Champion Data AFL
Champion Data AFL – ‏@championdata
@nicko_1984 16 contested possessions, 75% kicking efficiency, two goals and three score assists is a pretty handy ordinary performance.

 

[Flandersss]

Nick ‏@nicko_1984
@championdata how is it possible Gary Ablett got 119 supercoach points from a pretty ordinary performance??
Champion Data AFL
Champion Data AFL – ‏@championdata
@nicko_1984 16 contested possessions, 75% kicking efficiency, two goals and three score assists is a pretty handy ordinary performance.

But he got 50 points from 2 goals didn't he!?!?

Out goes that theory.

 

[TheOz]

But he got 50 points from 2 goals didn't he!?!?

Out goes that theory.

I don't have twitter but if you do tweet the guy back.

 

[Big Fozza]

Nick ‏@nicko_1984
@championdata how is it possible Gary Ablett got 119 supercoach points from a pretty ordinary performance??
Champion Data AFL
Champion Data AFL – ‏@championdata
@nicko_1984 16 contested possessions, 75% kicking efficiency, two goals and three score assists is a pretty handy ordinary performance.

Has anyone asked about ruck scores?

 

[fantasyunit]

Has anyone asked about ruck scores?

Go in the ruck thread, there's a couple of pages about a tweet from CD 'explaining' that it's all legit.

 

[Stickers32]

Be carful Gibsons scores aren't effected when Birchell comes back. I personally would wait a week. What happens if GAJ scores 150 vs the saints, which is more than possible.

I like your thinking... How about getting Birchall in this week or is he a chance to get subbed off? I love Birchall best SC defender for the last 7-10 years


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[matt_bas]

I like your thinking... How about getting Birchall in this week or is he a chance to get subbed off? I love Birchall best SC defender for the last 7-10 years


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Hmm id wait and see. Hard to pick the defenders this year. Coming of an injury I'd wait. How about Brodie Smith?