Geelong vs St Kilda match ups

[Robin Hood]

B: Josh Hunt, Matthew Scarlett, Brenton Sanderson
F: Stephen Milne, Fraser Gehrig, Matthew Ferguson

HB: Darren Milburn, Tom Harley, David Wojinscki
HF: Aaron Hamill, Nick Reiwoldt, Stephen Powell

C: James Kelly, Cameron Ling, Kane Tenace
C: Nick Dal Santos, Luke Ball, Xavier Clarke

HF: Kent Kingsley, Ben Graham, Gary Ablett Jnr
HB: Brett Voss, Matt Maguire, Austinn Jones

F: Paul Chapman, Brad Ottens, Steve Johnson
B: Steven Baker, Luke Penny, Max Hudgton

RUCKS: Steven King, Joel Corey, James Bartel
RUCKS: Justin Koschitzke, Robert Harvey, Lenny Hayes

INT: Cameron Mooney, Peter Riccardi, Charlie Gardiner, Corey Enright
INT: Brendon Goddard, Leigh Fisher, Jason Gram, Jason Blake

EMG: Andrew Mackie, Henry Playfair, Paul Koulorotis
EMG: Andrew Thompson, Leigh Montagna, Barry Brooks

Geelong side as I've selected it while St Kilda side is taken from SensibleCommentator's post. Bold is Geelong, Italicised in St Kilda.

King will maul Kosi in the ruck giving first use to Geelong's midfield. Surprisingly when you look at the match ups Geelong's forwards look fairly decent against St Kilda's defenders. While Geelong's defenders should be able to contain/break even with St Kilda's forwards. Thoughts?

Geelong by 10 points.

Done on the Cats board seeing it was hijacked by trolls on the main board.

 

[SaveFeriss]

Did ya cream ya pants, as per usual, as you typed the Sleepy One's name?

 

[JUBJUB]

Did ya cream ya pants, as per usual, as you typed the Sleepy One's name?

Another troll hijack.

 

[Robin Hood]

Another troll hijack.

 

[SaveFeriss]

It's an insult to the trolls who have a sense of irony, to be calling Robin Hoo0d a troll.

He aint worthy, just desperate.

 

[Robin Hood]

Did ya cream ya pants, as per usual, as you typed the Sleepy One's name?

Yes. It was fun.

 

[Unwritten_Law]

How much time have you wasted following Robin Hood around?

 

[SaveFeriss]

about .21 seconds.

+ 24.03 seconds replying.

Im still young, I have time to waiste.

 

[JeffDunne]

What is the Geelong fascination with StKilda? I don't get it.

Port won the GF and it is them you should worry about being able to beat. Sure I'm hoping the Saints will make the GF, but I still think Port will be a team both us and Geelong will need to roll to have a crack. Minor premiers for the past three years, now can win finals and at the MCG.

Question is, can you beat Port?

 

[Fall Out Boy]

What is the Geelong fascination with StKilda? I don't get it.

I don't get it either mate, but it well and truly works both ways.

A few Sainters here who are totally obsessed by Geelong, whilst there seems to be a few threads a week about us on Saintsational.

Thankfully there hasn't been a post about St. Kilda on Cats Claw for a good month.

 

[Robin Hood]

I don't get it either mate, but it well and truly works both ways.

A few Sainters here who are totally obsessed by Geelong, whilst there seems to be a few threads a week about us on Saintsational.

Thankfully there hasn't been a post about St. Kilda on Cats Claw for a good month.

I compared then because firstly a team naming St Kilda's best 22 had recently been done by SensibleCommentator and no other teams had done this.

Secondly, they are at similar stages in development. To be honest I think Port is a definite next year but these two sides should battle over the next few years. I would have done it with Port except I dont know their side well enough.

 

[Unwritten_Law]

about .21 seconds.

+ 24.03 seconds replying.

Im still young, I have time to waiste.

Robin Hood posts a lot of crap and I don't read it all but most of the time it seems you are there to reply in double time.

 

[Robin Hood]

Robin Hood posts a lot of crap and I don't read it all but most of the time it seems you are there to reply in double time.

I dont know why Tigers fans banned me from their board. They love me. Its good to feel loved.

 

[JeffDunne]

I don't get it either mate, but it well and truly works both ways.

No doubt. I like the heat of battle as much as anyone else, and I'm sure I'll be bagging the Cats when we play them. But when we aren't playing them, I'm actually pleased they have managed to get their act together (like StKilda).

Nothing would make me happier than to see a top 4 full of teams that haven't won one for a long time, including Geelong.

 

[Robin Hood]

No doubt. I like the heat of battle as much as anyone else, and I'm sure I'll be bagging the Cats when we play them. But when we aren't playing them, I'm actually pleased they have managed to get their act together (like StKilda).

Nothing would make me happier than to see a top 4 full of teams that haven't won one for a long time, including Geelong.

Well said. I'd like the Dogs to get up there but it aint going to happen.

 

[Snickers]

B: Josh Hunt, Matthew Scarlett, Brenton Sanderson
F: Stephen Milne, Fraser Gehrig, Matthew Ferguson

HB: Darren Milburn, Tom Harley, David Wojinscki
HF: Aaron Hamill, Nick Reiwoldt, Stephen Powell

C: James Kelly, Cameron Ling, Kane Tenace
C: Nick Dal Santos, Luke Ball, Xavier Clarke

HF: Kent Kingsley, Ben Graham, Gary Ablett Jnr
HB: Brett Voss, Matt Maguire, Austinn Jones

F: Paul Chapman, Brad Ottens, Steve Johnson
B: Steven Baker, Luke Penny, Max Hudgton

RUCKS: Steven King, Joel Corey, James Bartel
RUCKS: Justin Koschitzke, Robert Harvey, Lenny Hayes

INT: Cameron Mooney, Peter Riccardi, Charlie Gardiner, Corey Enright
INT: Brendon Goddard, Leigh Fisher, Jason Gram, Jason Blake

EMG: Andrew Mackie, Henry Playfair, Paul Koulorotis
EMG: Andrew Thompson, Leigh Montagna, Barry Brooks

Geelong side as I've selected it while St Kilda side is taken from SensibleCommentator's post. Bold is Geelong, Italicised in St Kilda.

King will maul Kosi in the ruck giving first use to Geelong's midfield. Surprisingly when you look at the match ups Geelong's forwards look fairly decent against St Kilda's defenders. While Geelong's defenders should be able to contain/break even with St Kilda's forwards. Thoughts?

Geelong by 10 points.

Done on the Cats board seeing it was hijacked by trolls on the main board.

As if St.Kilda would pick that team. There are some positionbs on there that a so stupid.
Matthew Fergurson couldnt make out emergency list let alone on the ground. And if he did make the ground hge wouldnt be foward pocket. Stupid thread.

 

[Robin Hood]

As if St.Kilda would pick that team. There are some positionbs on there that a so stupid.
Matthew Fergurson couldnt make out emergency list let alone on the ground. And if he did make the ground hge wouldnt be foward pocket. Stupid thread.

The saints posiitons were by sensiblie commentator inanother thread

 

[Snickers]

The saints posiitons were by sensiblie commentator inanother thread

Dont read too much into it buddy.

 

[nananana catman]

Dont read too much into it buddy.

So thats actually not the St.Kilda team to play Geelong this year?!?!

Good God NO!!!

 

[Robin Hood]

Dont read too much into it buddy.

Im not, im saying it wasnt me picking the st kilda team.

 

[BB gun]

B: Josh Hunt, Matthew Scarlett, Brenton Sanderson[/B]
F: J Farmer, R Murphy, P Medhurst

HB: Darren Milburn, Tom Harley, David Wojinscki
HF: M Pavlich, J Longmuir, D Headland

C: James Kelly, Cameron Ling, Kane Tenace
C: H Black, P Haselby, B Schammer

HF: Kent Kingsley, Ben Graham, Gary Ablett Jnr
HB: G Polak, L Mcpharlin, M Carr

F: Paul Chapman, Brad Ottens, Steve Johnson
B: J Walker, R Hadrill, R Hayden

RUCKS: Steven King, Joel Corey, James Bartel
RUCKS: A Sandilands, P Bell, J Carr

INT: Cameron Mooney, Peter Riccardi, Charlie Gardiner, Corey Enright
INT: D Gilmore, S Thorton, T Cook, R Dunn

EMG: Andrew Mackie, Henry Playfair, Paul Koulorotis
EMG: S McManus, D Woods, A Grover

 

[jmain14]

Inane, obsessive and tired old tripe is totally unnecessary jmain14 as Fred gave Robin Hood a two week holiday last night. - Phat