General MFC discussion

[markm106]

So what was the real go with MC. Anything more than just walking away from us with the club having no idea?
I have heard a few stories I wouldn't bother posting because they are likely crap.

 

[Cannon82]

So what was the real go with MC. Anything more than just walking away from us with the club having no idea?
I have heard a few stories I wouldn't bother posting because they are likely crap.

1. Retired from football
   
2. Announced comeback
3. Trained with club in bid to regain fitness
4. Announced he wanted to play for another club
5. Orchestrated trade to another club

All over a roughly 6 month timeline.

 

[Ando727]

1. Retired from football
   
2. Announced comeback
3. Trained with club in bid to regain fitness
4. Announced he wanted to play for another club
5. Orchestrated trade to another club

All over a roughly 6 month timeline.

Like I said, A-grade A-hole...

 

[Demon 16]

So what was the real go with MC. Anything more than just walking away from us with the club having no idea?
I have heard a few stories I wouldn't bother posting because they are likely crap.

I'm pretty sure he had to deal with a few issues.

My interpretation is;

He had some psych issues.

Told the club and asked for extended, open ended leave.

Club obliged and suggested that he retire in good faith, and come back if and when he recovered.

He took the deal which was favourable in terms of payments.

He recovered enough to play footy, but realised his contract upon return would be reduced.

Acted against good faith and took himself to open market for a better deal by saying he needed a 'change of environment'.

Effectively blackmailing the club to trade him/let him go so he could earn more money again.

 

[Topkent]

He makes me think tom scully is a decent bloke








....almost

 

[stretcharmstrong]

$1m/year @ 20 years old to leave a god awful, imploding basket case? Scully is a saint compared to MC.

 

[markm106]

1. Retired from football
   
2. Announced comeback
3. Trained with club in bid to regain fitness
4. Announced he wanted to play for another club
5. Orchestrated trade to another club

All over a roughly 6 month timeline.

That's pretty much what I thought. Disappointing that it happened with all the work we put in.

 

[wowlace]

He just got greedy. His manager played a big role in this saga obviously.

 

[pure demon]

Sure is boring around here...bring on the nab cup challenge thing. Btw preseasons are way to long. I would be happy if they just put the hulk on ice till round1. Gain matchday fitness as the season progresses

 

[stabler]

I would be happy if they just put the hulk on ice till round1. Gain matchday fitness as the season progresses

I think there's merit in that. If he is to go down, it may aswel be in the season proper and not some Mickey mouse bull$#!+ nab cup game. I sure hope he stays injury free but every time I watch him, be it at Casey or at training, it's like he's moving around on very thin ice and at any moment... Well it's best not to think about.

But back on point, yeah I'd be happy for him to just play the one nab cup game, maybe limited minutes, then unleash the hulk rd 1 at the G. Even an underdone Hoges is better than any forward in the comp. You heard me correctly.

 

[Topkent]

Don't put him on ice, the kids 19
If they have to treat him that carefully now his career will be over soon Anyway

Nabs played at 80% intensity anyway

 

[booshboy]

Nab cup is a ****ing joke. Might as well play Garry Lyon at full forward.

 

[ExTasDeeMan]

Don't put him on ice, the kids 19
If they have to treat him that carefully now his career will be over soon Anyway

Nabs played at 80% intensity anyway

Agree - if he's fully fit, he's fully fit. Get him on the park and establish his confidence to just kick some ass in the season proper.

 

[Demon 16]

If we rest him into round 1, he's even more likely to break down with the dramatic increase in intensity.

 

[Topkent]

If we rest him into round 1, he's even more likely to break down with the dramatic increase in intensity.

Along that line of thinking, Rest Dunn, Jones, Tyson, Jamar, Dawes, Vince, McDonald, Petracca and anyone else who will be involved in round 1

 

[PerfectFooty]

Along that line of thinking, Rest Dunn, Jones, Tyson, Jamar, Dawes, Vince, McDonald, Petracca and anyone else who will be involved in round 1

At this risk on injuries that will hinder our season i suggest that we let Casey play for us instead.

 

[Demon 16]

Along that line of thinking, Rest Dunn, Jones, Tyson, Jamar, Dawes, Vince, McDonald, Petracca and anyone else who will be involved in round 1

I was suggesting that resting him would not be a good idea.

 

[Topkent]

I was suggesting that resting him would not be a good idea.

I was agreeing with you lol

 

[Demon 16]

I was agreeing with you lol

Oh right, sorry

Yeh I can understand managing his load, but I dont think keeping him on ice until round 1 would be a good idea.

Even if he's playing well during the year, I'm sure we'll give him a few weeks off to keep him fresh anyway.

 

[Topkent]

Oh right, sorry

Yeh I can understand managing his load, but I dont think keeping him on ice until round 1 would be a good idea.

Even if he's playing well during the year, I'm sure we'll give him a few weeks off to keep him fresh anyway.

Yeah, I think if you treat him like he is ready to break down every minute then he will probably break down

Besides, it sends the wrong message if every player is available for the nab except a 19 yr old debutant who is deemed to important

 

[SpeciousArgument]

Do you know this Dees fan? camera was found in USA

 

[Topkent]

Shit that would be a holy grail style find

 

[Trav 20]

Now people want to wrap Hogan in cotton wool. Wonders never cease.

Besides, it sends the wrong message if every player is available for the nab except a 19 yr old debutant who is deemed to important

Not withstanding the fact that his birthday is on February 12 and he'll start in the NAB Challenge series beyond his teenage years.

 

[Topkent]

Now people want to wrap Hogan in cotton wool. Wonders never cease.


Not withstanding the fact that his birthday is on February 12 and he'll start in the NAB Challenge series beyond his teenage years.

I wouldnt care if he was 25, the fact that he hasnt played a game and people are worried about his durability is silly

 

[Trav 20]

I wouldnt care if he was 25, the fact that he hasnt played a game and people are worried about his durability is silly

That's great. I'm just correcting your incorrect assertion.