Heath Shaw At Mfc?

[chopper41]

What's everyone think of this? He is possibly up for trade at seasons end. Is only 22 and is very good footballer. If it wasn't to much, i'd be up for getting him.

 

[stabler]

would take him in a heartbeat but theres not a snowballs chance in hell they'l let him go.

Didak on the other hand might not be so lucky

 

[Headless]

Shaw - yes
Didak - no

EDIT: Shaw for the right price that is...

 

[dee-molishon]

1)Bails has already outlined he doesnt want shady characters on our list. So we wouldnt look at him anyway.
2) If he was up for trade collingwood would want a pick from somewhere between 6-12 for him which we cannot offer
3)I understand why he lied (to protect a friend) but didak is an absolute scum bag for letrting shaw do it for him. He is obviously influenced by the wrong people and we wouldnt need that. With players like carrol and brock already on our list.
4) He's overrated, cant defend is only good attacking and isnt fast enough to play permanant mid-field.

On the other hand didak will be available and if he wasnt such a scum bag lieing piece of crap he would suit us much more as we need dangerous fowards.

Pass on both, ones a scumbag and ones extemely overvalued.

 

[Bartram_Class]

They won't contemplate trading Shaw.

Didak will go if anyone will take him, certainly won't be us.

 

[CaptainDavey]

It's a nice thought but it'll never happen, they rate the lad too highly. Should wait till he screws up a bit more before we float this kind of idea. On the other hand, I wouldn't go near Didak with a 10 foot pole. Wonna>>>>>Didak

 

[stabler]

1)Bails has already outlined he doesnt want shady characters on our list. So we wouldnt look at him anyway.
2) If he was up for trade collingwood would want a pick from somewhere between 6-12 for him which we cannot offer
3)I understand why he lied (to protect a friend) but didak is an absolute scum bag for letrting shaw do it for him. He is obviously influenced by the wrong people and we wouldnt need that. With players like carrol and brock already on our list.
4) He's overrated, cant defend is only good attacking and isnt fast enough to play permanant mid-field.

On the other hand didak will be available and if he wasnt such a scum bag lieing piece of crap he would suit us much more as we need dangerous fowards.

Pass on both, ones a scumbag and ones extemely overvalued.

Addam Maric, at your service. Will be an excitement machine don't worry about that

 

[McLean_4_Captain]

1)Bails has already outlined he doesnt want shady characters on our list. So we wouldnt look at him anyway.
2) If he was up for trade collingwood would want a pick from somewhere between 6-12 for him which we cannot offer
3)I understand why he lied (to protect a friend) but didak is an absolute scum bag for letrting shaw do it for him. He is obviously influenced by the wrong people and we wouldnt need that. With players like carrol and brock already on our list.
4) He's overrated, cant defend is only good attacking and isnt fast enough to play permanant mid-field.

Pass on both, ones a scumbag and ones extemely overvalued.

While they might overate him and would ask for way too much, what you've said there isn't true. He's struggled a bit to adjust to being tagged, but so has Jones this year, doesn't make him not a good player. He's still one of the best playmakers going around

We won't give up enough even at what he should be worth, they'll want more anyway.