Honestly, what would you rather?

[hawks_time]

Our year was pretty dismal and we didn't make the finals.
Essendon performed above expectation and made the finals, only to suffer their worst defeat in a final in their history.
So would you rather have not even made the finals or get flogged by 94 points?

 

[TerryWallet]

Campbell Brown LOL

 

[Chism]

Seeing this Bumber Capitulation tonight was Awesome and i wouldnt trade it for anything. Good Stuff Bumbers serious Lulz.

 

[anti_]

west coast.

won 4/5 and finished on a high.

hawks and bombers both finished on huge lows.

out of those 2 i'd take essendon though, gain some sort of finals experience.

 

[ryzket]

Honestly they should have just forfeited before the game started, what a pathetic effort

 

[dajesmac]

west coast.

won 4/5 and finished on a high.

hawks and bombers both finished on huge lows.

out of those 2 i'd take essendon though, gain some sort of finals experience.

Hawthorn remain better than WCE.

The Hawks are reigning premiers, and with less injuries next season, should make the top 6 at the very least.

 

[dajesmac]

west coast.

won 4/5 and finished on a high.

hawks and bombers both finished on huge lows.

out of those 2 i'd take essendon though, gain some sort of finals experience.

Hawthorn remain better than WCE.

The Hawks are reigning premiers, and with less injuries next season, should make the top 6 at the very least. They have more finals experience.

 

[anti_]

obviously hawks are better than wce. but we're talking about 2009.

hawks will make the top 4 next year, but thats irrelevant.

 

[Lurkalot]

hawks and bombers both finished on huge lows.

out of those 2 i'd take essendon though, gain some sort of finals experience.

Yep, their kids will take a lot out of that 16 goal thumping.

 

[Fear0411]

LOL

Jobe waston as acting captain ahahahah led them down that snowy white hill pretty good, he did

 

[kreuze_missile]

This is like picking out of Cancer and AIDS...

 

[catspremiers2007]

Any more dumbos care to enter into this conversation.........

 

[dajesmac]

obviously hawks are better than wce. but we're talking about 2009.

hawks will make the top 4 next year, but thats irrelevant.

I figured he meant being one of those teams in general, not just being one of those teams n the way their season ended. If that's the case, you make a point.

 

[NeutralPerson]

Jack Watts

WAIT WHAT?

 

[siamang]

Essendon>>>>>>>>>>>>>Hawthorn.

 

[Fear0411]

Any more dumbos care to enter into this conversation.........

 

[catspremiers2007]

Right on queue Dumbo

 

[mantis]

Our year was pretty dismal and we didn't make the finals.
Essendon performed above expectation and made the finals, only to suffer their worst defeat in a final in their history.
So would you rather have not even made the finals or get flogged by 94 points?

Make the finals, while keeping the Bradbury premiers out.

 

[STC]

I would rather make the finals.

 

[Haduken]

I'll take that 94 point loss

I look forward to hearing the Carlton side of this question after tomorrow night

 

[invinciBlues]

Make the finals, while keeping the Bradbury premiers out.

Finals? You're having a laugh!

All I saw tonight was Adelaide doing training drills against an U13 girls netball team.

 

[blue gunslinger]

The complete humilation a hawk must feel after winning a flag and backing it up by not making the finals must be overwhelming
Shame Shame Shame

 

[Jumping Josh]

Rather make finals.

 

[99 luft balloons]

I would rather make the finals.

who would have thought a cats fan would choose that option
Premiers (08) & no finals (09) >>>>>>>>>>>> 1st & no flag & 2nd & no flag