How does Chaffey continue to get games?

[Bentleigh]

Out: Chaffey
In: Jackson

Meyer for Hyde when the lad is fit and gets confidence.

 

[madtiger2005]

I've been saying this for weeks . Swap Chaff for Jacko and Hyde for Graham

 

[cairo tiger]

mt just coach the club mate you tool

 

[itsintheblood]

Chaffey is a joke and should have been shown the same door frawley went out of. How this bloke has played 150 games is beyond me. We will not go all the way this him in the side. Jackon should replace him immediately and we should also eliminate campbell from the side after today. He was terrible.

 

[Bentleigh]

Unlike most of you im a fan of Campbell.

However he was gash today.

 

[peejay]

Buggered if I know.

 

[lucas_hsv]

we should also eliminate campbell from the side after today.

Screw you, campbell is a champ.

 

[itsintheblood]

Unlike most of you im a fan of Campbell.

However he was gash today.

Mate, his friggen little marshmallow kicking is a disgrace. How the ******** can a guy with so much experience kick the ball out on the full 20 mtrs down the field under no pressure??? He pi$$ed me off totally today.

 

[itsintheblood]

Screw you, campbell is a champ.

Campbell WAS a champ. You obviously weren't there today hey??? His disposal was shocking.

 

[madtiger2005]

hopefully schultz improves and takes grahams spot. I forgot about cambos average game. Hartigan will add more speed to our team soon. Hey Cairo, go get someone to mummify yourself and lock you in a tomb.

 

[itsintheblood]

hopefully schultz improves and takes grahams spot. I forgot about cambos average game. Hartigan will add more speed to our team soon. Hey Cairo, go get someone to mummify yourself and lock you in a tomb.

LMAO....What will they find when they scan cairos brain in 3000 years???

 

[madtiger2005]

they'll realise he either lost most of his brain cells from heavy drinking or he just didn't have many to begin with

 

[lucas_hsv]

Campbell WAS a champ. You obviously weren't there today hey??? His disposal was shocking.

Yes, i was there today, his disposal was shocking, the 50 he gave away was stupid, but that doesn't automatically take away his champ status. Screw you again.

 

[peejay]

I was at the game, came home, read what has been said about Campbell on here and thought maybe I was at another game. So I watched the replay just to make sure I was not missing anything.

I am very happy with his game and his year. The fifty was very unlucky, it was there but it was an reactive thing. Have a look at it on the replay. He was thinking the right thing it just did not come off. Unlike what others have said his disposals while not long are all to a target. Better that than long roosts to nobody.

Will play the rest of the year easily.

 

[Weaver]

I was at the game, came home, read what has been said about Campbell on here and thought maybe I was at another game. So I watched the replay just to make sure I was not missing anything.

People have formed their opinions of Campbell and now days just let the good/OK stuff wash over them, and jump up and down "see, see told you" when he makes his 3-4 mistakes a game. If Jackson played exactly the same game there would be a 100 post thread about how he was going to be a superstar.

 

[Weaver]

Chaffey is a joke and should have been shown the same door frawley went out of. How this bloke has played 150 games is beyond me. We will not go all the way this him in the side. Jackon should replace him immediately and we should also eliminate campbell from the side after today. He was terrible.

Jackson is capable of what 50-60 minutes a game and even then he has to be kept out of the real traffic. Chaffey has the body and fitness to play the full match, play in the packs, and take the pounding.

Yes he is rubbish but he is doing a job and is our best option as a tagger this year.

 

[itsintheblood]

Yes, i was there today, his disposal was shocking, the 50 he gave away was stupid, but that doesn't automatically take away his champ status. Screw you again.

You're obviously very easily please you w@nker.

 

[itsintheblood]

Jackson is capable of what 50-60 minutes a game and even then he has to be kept out of the real traffic. Chaffey has the body and fitness to play the full match, play in the packs, and take the pounding.

Yes he is rubbish but he is doing a job and is our best option as a tagger this year.

Ok so he stays in the week and must play on ackermanis. Could be very nasty.

 

[Weaver]

Ok so he stays in the week and must play on ackermanis. Could be very nasty.

Should be very nasty, but too often people want a guy dropped, delisted, sacked (whatever) and don't go the next step and propose the alternative. The question isn't can Chaffey do a good job as a tagger (he can't), the question is who can do a better job?

We hardly want to sacrifice Coughlan, Tuck, Hyde or Johnson. The kids don't have the fitness, AFL smarts or strength (yet). Chaffey gets the job by default.

 

[oxx]

same reason Tivendale does.

We have a lack of seniority in certain positions.

 

[sante]

Campbell was good today. Worse than the previous weeks but was still good. Chaffey, I dont know, he won't play every game from now on and thats for sure.

 

[Blair7]

Out: Chaffey
In: Jackson

Meyer for Hyde when the lad is fit and gets confidence.

agreed

 

[evo]

Should be very nasty, but too often people want a guy dropped, delisted, sacked (whatever) and don't go the next step and propose the alternative. The question isn't can Chaffey do a good job as a tagger (he can't), the question is who can do a better job?

We hardly want to sacrifice Coughlan, Tuck, Hyde or Johnson. The kids don't have the fitness, AFL smarts or strength (yet). Chaffey gets the job by default.

Agree we don't want Cogs on him,he's playing to well, but Newman, Tuck or Hyde could do a superior job on stopping Aka than Chaffey could.With Power missing it'll hardly be a 'sacrifice'. Along with Black, Aka will be the most potentially damaging midfielder this week.Newman played on him during the practise match and did ok.

I agree with IITB,Chaffey has become a liability,hardened body or not.

Tick ,tick

 

[Bentleigh]

Jackson is capable of what 50-60 minutes a game and even then he has to be kept out of the real traffic. Chaffey has the body and fitness to play the full match, play in the packs, and take the pounding.

Yes he is rubbish but he is doing a job and is our best option as a tagger this year.

Some good points about needing a mature body to get battered about whilst not losing the effectivness of Johnson, Tuck, Hyde and friends. To use another team as an example Vanderburg is a similar type.

I also accpet kids aged under 20 struggle in the pysical stakes. However, like, to stick on the Hawthorn theme Lewis seems to have the body to mix it with the big boys. I would have thought Jackson has at least an equally 'mature' body and should be able to perform Chaffys role.

 

[froars]

People have formed their opinions of Campbell and now days just let the good/OK stuff wash over them, and jump up and down "see, see told you" when he makes his 3-4 mistakes a game. If Jackson played exactly the same game there would be a 100 post thread about how he was going to be a superstar.

You could say the same about Gasper, Chaffey, Tivendale, Kellaway. Note the common theme in all of them: they have been at the club during the bad times. Now we have kids coming thru (and ain't it great) just because they are the future of the club, the older servants of the club are dismissed and constantly criticised.

Well, you can't have a team full of kids and expect instant success like most of you ppl demand. Don't care if they're Deledio, Tambo whoever, they are still going to take time to develop and have to earn their positions before they automatically take the place of these guys.

I'm a big Cambo critic, but i can't see much he's doing wrong this year. Given his old age lol, he is really showing the way and except for being a bit slow (no, very slow), he is getting the ball and actually delivering it - which was my criticism of him before, i thought he turned it over a bit.

Kellaway i would have given him a vote if he had a better second half. Again, a player we say get rid of. Tivendale makes a few errors, he's not alone but he is singled out.

Agree with Weaver's analogy re Jackson - you all show very narrow vision and just expect the club to deliver a premiership with babies.

It ain't going to happen. The Cambos, Gaspars, Tivendales, Kellaways etc have just as much right to be in the team while they're still delivering and showing the way. With the team being 6-2, you can't possibly tell me they have had no influence on those results.