How long will Cornes Get....

[The Night Shift]

if anything for throwing in the flying forearm/elbow? not to mention a very very simliar knock to what put Ballantyne out for 2 weeks (not sure which Port player that was)??

 

[Bradesmaen]

Can I have some of what you are smoking?

 

[dominguez]

Hopefully Hase isn't in trouble for his tackle that injured the players back.

 

[silverscope]

Wont be reported, but the bump on (deBoer or Hase) with his head over the ball may be looked at.

 

[samseenee]

Yeah that Bump was no different to Frodo's last week...

 

[silverscope]

Hopefully Hase isn't in trouble for his tackle that injured the players back.

Shouldn't be, Was a legal hit and he didnt even land on his back.

 

[The Night Shift]

Can I have some of what you are smoking?

I don't give you shit for your posts Bradesmaen... try to show a modicum of respect...

 

[dominguez]

Yeah that Bump was no different to Frodo's last week...

I guess the difference is that the Freo player today was fine while the Bulldog's player required treatment last week.

 

[samseenee]

I guess the difference is that the Freo player today was fine while the Bulldog's player required treatment last week.

Is that cause our players are tougher than the Bull dogs thou?

 

[Bradesmaen]

Which bump is that? The one on de boer? Gray (I think) was trying to pull out and even had his hands up before he collided with him. If we are talking Cornes on Hase... then its a no brainer. That hasn't been given a suspension unless he actually swings his elbow into his face. It is just a simple free kick for a high fend off. If you think anymore then you do not watch enough football/haven't played enough.

 

[freo1]

if anything for throwing in the flying forearm/elbow? not to mention a very very simliar knock to what put Ballantyne out for 2 weeks (not sure which Port player that was)??

mate, i count myself as biased as they come, and yeah, at first the forearm to hase's head looked bad, but on replay it wasnt worth more than the free kick. if it was an elbow then yeah, case to answer, but nothing in it for mine.

i still agree that ballantyne was screwed though

 

[peppy la pew]

Which bump is that? The one on de boer? Gray (I think) was trying to pull out and even had his hands up before he collided with him. If we are talking Cornes on Hase... then its a no brainer. That hasn't been given a suspension unless he actually swings his elbow into his face. It is just a simple free kick for a high fend off. If you think anymore then you do not watch enough football/haven't played enough.[/quote]


Have you been a w***er all your life ??

 

[Kram]

Which one of the Cornes sisters was this?

 

[silverscope]

The Chad.

 

[Nodgey]

When I first saw it I thought he should get weeks for it.

It ticks all the boxes - high, intentional, medium(?) impact. And I'm convinced if it were Solomon or Jeff (or Barry Hall or Byron Pickett for that matter) it would be seriously looked at.

But on second thoughts, I wonder of the impact was severe enough to warrant a suspension. (I guess only Haze could tell us that...)

I wouldn't be surprised of he gets off. And I wouldn't at all be surprised if he gets offered a week for it either.

But, hey, it's a Cornes. I hope he gets 3.

 

[purplepassion82]

nothing imo.

 

[Power King]

if anything for throwing in the flying forearm/elbow? not to mention a very very simliar knock to what put Ballantyne out for 2 weeks (not sure which Port player that was)??

Cornes should get 0 weeks, and the freo player that got one of ours in the back late should get 0 weeks too.

Nothing worthy of a report from today's game in my opinion.

 

[Selggad]

I reckon it's an interesting situation. Cornes should get nothing, but it was head high, reckless and low impact. I don't know what the definitions of these things are (I assume it is all written down somewhere) but based on those criteria, then it is a reportable and chargeable offense.

 

[Bradesmaen]

I reckon it's an interesting situation. Cornes should get nothing, but it was head high, reckless and low impact. I don't know what the definitions of these things are (I assume it is all written down somewhere) but based on those criteria, then it is a reportable and chargeable offense.

It would be classified as accidental, therefore not a reportable offence.

 

[Rubber Pants]

Should get what it deserves

Nothing

 

[Taylor]

Are you talking about that hit on Stephen Hill behind play?

I've got to hand it to the kid, he took the forearm to the head, went down, then got up before the guy who hit him.

 

[DockersMad]

Cornes should get 0 weeks, and the freo player that got one of ours in the back late should get 0 weeks too.

Agree. It was Hasleby and it wasn't late, but nothing in either incident. Cornes was reckless but that's about all.

Nothing worthy of a report from today's game in my opinion.

Disagree. DeBoer was crunched high from front on while his head was over the ball. As Ballantyne was rubbed out last week, this should definitely be looked at. I'd claim that the MRP should be consistent but we all know they won't be.

The fact that DeBoer got straight up instead of rolling around clutching his head like a bulldog bitch will probably save the Port player, I didn't catch who it was.