How The Captains Rate

[SackKaneJohnson]

Thought the Hearld Sun was overly generous with the ratings of our Captain. Comments and thoughts

 

[CoggaRules]

Thought the Hearld Sun was overly generous with the ratings of our Captain. Comments and thoughts

really? wow, i would never had guessed, i thought you were his biggest fan going by your nic.

 

[Infamy]

Was leading the comp in champion data points for a large part of the start of the year
Just seems to be a bit fragile these days and his form drops significantly when playing under 100%
Very underrated as captain

 

[kizzaob]

bahhh, he's not underated, he's just that shit and deserves everything he gets...should never have got him, and should never have put him as captain. (just my opinion)

 

[kizzaob]

The herald was definately overly generous.

 

[SackKaneJohnson]

Was leading the comp in champion data points for a large part of the start of the year
Just seems to be a bit fragile these days and his form drops significantly when playing under 100%
Very underrated as captain

You cant be serious. The only comeback supporters of the hack have is Champion Data points. They are worthless his possesions. Compare his game to Stevens last week. Stevens killed as with his possesions last game. Match winner. Something that can never be said about our captain

 

[phammo]

bahhh, he's not underated, he's just that shit and deserves everything he gets...should never have got him, and should never have put him as captain. (just my opinion)

I couldn't agree more kizzaob

 

[ize_]

What did the little paper actually say?

 

[emperor]

absolute fluff piece that what a shocker. LMAO @ the ratings system. I've had my laugh for the day.

I wish I could earn a crust doing that

 

[Crumden]

They rated him the second worst. Guys like Cameron Bruce who have been captain for two minutes were rated higher. Tredrea is the only one ranked lower and he has been terrible this year. I don't see how you could say he has been over-rated in the article.

 

[eays]

about spot on. Only thing to add is that at least Tredrea was once a great captain ... KJ never has and never will be. Thats why i personally rate him the worst captain in the AFL.

Throw that in with TW being the worst game day coach in the AFL and we turn up to play opposing sides with 2 massive comparative DISADVANTAGES.

Things will turn around, eventually. Hopefully the first thing is that KJ is replaced as captain at the end of the season.

 

[Tivers]

Bit harsh rating below the Egirls captain !

 

[NQTIGER]

Thought the Hearld Sun was overly generous with the ratings of our Captain. Comments and thoughts

Is that you OXX?????

 

[Top_4_Tiger]

I thought he deserved a higher rating for leadership, I constantly hear about how much of a fantastic influence he has on the youngster's development always providing great leadership off the field.

By Round 9-10 he was in the top 2-3 players of the comp, so the mark out of 10 for form was a bit harsh too.

I can't wait for Kane to get back to 100% fitness because as poor as he was last year (while on pain killers), early this season he proved that he can still be an absolute GUN and one of the best mids in the comp.

His leadership qualities are underrated outside the club, I think anyone who looks close enough can see that.

His value on field is up for debate.

 

[RuthlessRichmond]

I can't believe he cops the amount of shit from our supporters that he does, just goes to show how many know so little about the game.

Considering the lack of maturity, skill level, courage, composure under pressure and class in our midfield since he's been at the club he's had a lot on his plate not only as captain but as part of that midfield.

Players like Foley, Deledio, Polo, Edwards, White and Tambling wouldn't be showing the progress in their playing careers that they are if not for KJ.

FFS get off his back.

 

[phammo]

By Round 9-10 he was in the top 2-3 players of the comp, so the mark out of 10 for form was a bit harsh too.

ha ha lol

 

[TigerGlory]

The article was a joke.

Rating captains based on their leadership, when they have no idea on how the players behave behind the scenes, reving up players, in team huddles etc.

Judd was second on the list because hes Judd, simple really. No way is his form any better than that of Harley, Mitchell, Kirk or Burns. Yet he is rated higher.

It was a stupid, meaningless article to be honest.

 

[Top_4_Tiger]

ha ha lol

As previously pointed out (if you care to re-read... or simply read it for the first time), Johnson was ranked about #1 and #2 for the first half of the season.

Brownlow night you'll be surprised at how many votes he steals off Richo too

 

[SackKaneJohnson]

As previously pointed out (if you care to re-read... or simply read it for the first time), Johnson was ranked about #1 and #2 for the first half of the season.

Brownlow night you'll be surprised at how many votes he steals off Richo too

Get serious. He will only get an invite because he is a captain

 

[copthat]

Yeah. Just get rid of Kane Johnson and make Newman or Deledio captain.

Or make Richo captain for a couple of years -as a tribute- then make Lids captain??

Thoughts on that?

 

[kizzaob]

I can't believe he cops the amount of shit from our supporters that he does, just goes to show how many know so little about the game.

Considering the lack of maturity, skill level, courage, composure under pressure and class in our midfield since he's been at the club he's had a lot on his plate not only as captain but as part of that midfield.

Players like Foley, Deledio, Polo, Edwards, White and Tambling wouldn't be showing the progress in their playing careers that they are if not for KJ.

FFS get off his back.

Mate he's been utter shit for us since day one! I dont care what he does behind closed doors, when it comes to game day, he does sweet ____ all except buckle under pressure and handball over his head like a clown every two seconds...............I'm one of his biggest critics, because i see him as a nothing captain on the field, never see him pumping up the boys or anything like that...yes i've heard he is great around the club, but to be a good captain that needs to be combined with on field performance and leadership...he just doesn't cut it, and never will.
Bla bla bla he was a mad tiger supporter as a kid and bleeds yellow & black, i dont care! until he shows us he is a true tiger, i still see him as half decent adelaide midfielder.
Not to mention our so called leader of the club pissed on a cop shop, gee great example setting for the youngens right there.

 

[SackKaneJohnson]

Mate he's been utter shit for us since day one! I dont care what he does behind closed doors, when it comes to game day, he does sweet ____ all except buckle under pressure and handball over his head like a clown every two seconds...............I'm one of his biggest critics, because i see him as a nothing captain on the field, never see him pumping up the boys or anything like that...yes i've heard he is great around the club, but to be a good captain that needs to be combined with on field performance and leadership...he just doesn't cut it, and never will.
Bla bla bla he was a mad tiger supporter as a kid and bleeds yellow & black, i dont care! until he shows us he is a true tiger, i still see him as half decent adelaide midfielder.
Not to mention our so called leader of the club pissed on a cop shop, gee great example setting for the youngens right there.

Couldn't have said it better myself