Hyde is a dud

[Tigerland]

I've seen enough of this one sided marshmallow.
Turns it over when it counts and never wins a 50/50 contest.
Wallace likes him because he can run - shame he can't do anything else.
Softest player in Richmond colors.
Never got over that head clash a few years back.
Belongs at Coburg.

And how the hell does Kingsley get a game? What's the point? A forward that can't kick straight that won't be there next year? Why oh Why Terry?

 

[RichosGuns]

I've seen enough of this one sided marshmallow.
Turns it over when it counts and never wins a 50/50 contest.
Wallace likes him because he can run - shame he can't do anything else.
Softest player in Richmond colors.
Never got over that head clash a few years back.
Belongs at Coburg.

And how the hell does Kingsley get a game? What's the point? A forward that can't kick straight that won't be there next year? Why oh Why Terry?

Unwarrented after todays game, he was okay, not the worse by far

 

[krustyman]

hyde had 17 possesion, some youngsters had less than 10.

 

[PHX]

hyde had 17 possesion, some youngsters had less than 10.

Hyde is 23.

The youngsters you refer to are 18 and 19.

Blokes become players with experience and some of it must be at AFL level.

 

[buffalopride]

he wasnt the worst.

 

[RichosGuns]

Hyde is 23.

The youngsters you refer to are 18 and 19.

Blokes become players with experience and some of it must be at AFL level.

Bad culture, don't play players for the sake of it. Edwards played well today, better then the last couple of weeks, and if he is selected for Melbourne then it would be warrented. But a few others, unfortunatly the Steamer included, were not good enough

 

[Deledio2Conca]

Fumbles it an awful lot.

 

[beaver fever]

hyde had 17 possesion, some youngsters had less than 10.

krusty crutch you have no idea

 

[krustyman]

Hyde is 23.

The youngsters you refer to are 18 and 19.

Blokes become players with experience and some of it must be at AFL level.

edwards need full game time with coburg. the side runs out of legs, because they need proper players.

 

[PHX]

edwards need full game time with coburg. the side runs out of legs, because they need proper players.

Which is why it's handy for us to have the week off next week.

 

[Simche]

Realistically I was absolutely livid with his holding the ball effort just dumb football and the turn over in the last quater but Hyde is a necessary evil there are about 5 blokes that need to go before him and realistically he did do some good things by far not our worst.

 

[Tigerland]

Unwarrented after todays game, he was okay, not the worse by far

______________________________________________

I must see it differently.
Thought Chris was the worst by a long way. 20 Players had pretty good games.
3 turnover from Hyde that resulted in goals. The worst was falling on it in the centre and not even making an effort to get rid of it - just lazy. A goal 20 seconds later.
Kingsley was ordinary as usual and Polo wasn't great - but it wasn't through lack of effort.
White tries hard but makes a lot of mistakes. Needs clean hands.

Jackson made a couple of blunders but did some good things. I'm begining to think he is a player.

 

[smasha]

Hyde still needs more games.

The amount of times Richmond had the ball in control only to give it away by a stupid shortpass or handball annoyed the hell out of me.

Still youngsters I guess.

 

[Croat tiger]

Hyde still needs more games.

The amount of times Richmond had the ball in control only to give it away by a stupid shortpass or handball annoyed the hell out of me.

Still youngsters I guess.

Chip,chip,chip,chip.

 

[RichosGuns]

______________________________________________

I must see it differently.
Thought Chris was the worst by a long way. 20 Players had pretty good games.
3 turnover from Hyde that resulted in goals. The worst was falling on it in the centre and not even making an effort to get rid of it - just lazy. A goal 20 seconds later.
Kingsley was ordinary as usual and Polo wasn't great - but it wasn't through lack of effort.
White tries hard but makes a lot of mistakes. Needs clean hands.

Jackson made a couple of blunders but did some good things. I'm begining to think he is a player.

Players that were worse then Hyde today:
- Kingsley
- Thurstfield
- Polo
- Howatt

Thats of the top of my head

 

[GoTeam2-0-0-4]

I've seen enough of this one sided marshmallow.
Turns it over when it counts and never wins a 50/50 contest.
Wallace likes him because he can run - shame he can't do anything else.
Softest player in Richmond colors.
Never got over that head clash a few years back.
Belongs at Coburg.

And how the hell does Kingsley get a game? What's the point? A forward that can't kick straight that won't be there next year? Why oh Why Terry?

you are a rather stupid individual. how can you say that he is soft and then go on to say he never got over the head clash. if he was in fact soft as you say, then how did he even get into that head clash to begin with. Its one thing to criticize a guys performance, but its completely ignorant to suggest that any1 who plays badly is soft.

As for his performance today, he may have turned it over but he scored and set up a number of goals for us today- but i suppose its convenient for you to overlook that.

 

[PLSC]

he is pretty crap so great thread

the amount of times he walks along the wing bouncing the footy while richo is making leads only to **** it up is a joke

cant win his own ball in the middle which doesnt help and also has no right foot which eventually puts teammates under pressure and leads to turnovers

rubbish!

 

[tigertRANCE]

I've seen enough of this one sided marshmallow.
Turns it over when it counts and never wins a 50/50 contest.
Wallace likes him because he can run - shame he can't do anything else.
Softest player in Richmond colors.
Never got over that head clash a few years back.
Belongs at Coburg.

And how the hell does Kingsley get a game? What's the point? A forward that can't kick straight that won't be there next year? Why oh Why Terry?

LOL. You have no idea. Hyde tired in the 2nd half, which is understandable considering he has just come off an injury and the size of Subi. Was actually one of the reasons why we had such a great 1st half, and why our midfield actually looked good today. Had a hand in a handful of goals and kicked a ripper himself. One of the few who is good in tight, can evade and actually has a footy brain. Not blessed with pace or size, but better than half our list. Watch the game again Tigerdud. Should stay another year until other better young midfielders come through which is our major weakness.

GO TIGES!!!

 

[krustyman]

LOL. You have no idea. Hyde tired in the 2nd half, which is understandable considering he has just come off an injury and the size of Subi. Was actually one of the reasons why we had such a great 1st half, and why our midfield actually looked good today. Had a hand in a handful of goals and kicked a ripper himself. One of the few who is good in tight, can evade and actually has a footy brain. Not blessed with pace or size, but better than half our list. Watch the game again Tigerdud. Should stay another year until other better young midfielders come through which is our major weakness.

GO TIGES!!!

good point, hope it clears that up for the auskick brigade.

 

[Heisenberg_]

he is pretty crap so great thread

the amount of times he walks along the wing bouncing the footy while richo is making leads only to **** it up is a joke

cant win his own ball in the middle which doesnt help and also has no right foot which eventually puts teammates under pressure and leads to turnovers

rubbish!

Amen brother.

Heart in mouth stuff EVERY time he goes for a run, inevitably runs way too far, losing the momentum and the ball comes back the other way, starting to rival ****ing Tivendale

 

[Rayzorwire]

I've seen enough of this one sided marshmallow.
Turns it over when it counts and never wins a 50/50 contest.
Wallace likes him because he can run - shame he can't do anything else.
Softest player in Richmond colors.
Never got over that head clash a few years back.
Belongs at Coburg.

First game back and showed some good things - especially in the first half. Long way from the worst and will improve for the run.

And how the hell does Kingsley get a game? What's the point? A forward that can't kick straight that won't be there next year? Why oh Why Terry?

Must go.

 

[Madtiger2006]

Hyde is good, he stays. End of story

 

[Heisenberg_]

Hyde is good, he stays. End of story

Wrong.
Not good, depth player at best, too slow to play the role he tries to play so destroys momentum, can't fault he's effort, just not good enough.

 

[Madtiger2006]

Wrong.
Not good, depth player at best, too slow to play the role he tries to play so destroys momentum, can't fault he's effort, just not good enough.

He's a good forward

 

[Heisenberg_]

He's a good forward

Wouldn't and shouldn't make it in our best team