I mean, seriously how does Simmonds...

[coke_zero]

Simmo will come good, when graham come back patto will be gone.

and if he does what, we get one more year out of him? patto or vickery stepping up would be alot nicer.

 

[jackson_rules]

so we wanna play browne again aye? would be a shame to see nahas sent back to te rookie list for him, and vickery clearly isnt ready yet

 

[Danog]

Been terrible so far, Simmo.

 

[Barnzy]

Been terrible so far, Simmo.

He's been ****ing hopeless, cost us 3-4 goals already.

 

[tony_montana]

the bloke is clearly limping,

he shouldnt be playing
1 -bc hes shit
2 -hes injured

 

[win1soon]

absoulote dud! hes finshed

 

[Crumden]

His third quarter was good tonight but other than that not much from him. Geez he's gotten slow. He has been a bit of a bellweather for us over the last few years. His second half of last season he was pretty good and so was the team. And I think it was him influencing the team rather than being a frontrunner. But his year he's given us nothing. Don't agree with the vitriol he is copping on here, but his time is clearly up.

 

[rfctigerarmy]

Agree with Crumden. He isn't deserving of all the criticism, because he's been more than servicable for us since we got him.

But, like Crumden said, he's too slow now and lost all athleticism unfortunately.

I'm confident that the Graham and Pattison combo will be quite positive for us.

 

[Bojangles17]

he'll be dropped as soon as Gus is avaialble, fair dinkum he looks as though he's 42 getting around that ground, has really lost some agility...sandilands was well on his way to BOG , fortunately drfited out of the game

 

[rfctigerarmy]

he'll be dropped as soon as Gus is avaialble, fair dinkum he looks as though he's 42 getting around that ground, has really lost some agility...sandilands was well on his way to BOG , fortunately drfited out of the game

Poor decision by Mark Harvey to rest Sandi so early, I reckon. Sandi was killing us in the middle and around the ground until he was moved forward for a 'rest'.

 

[Bojangles17]

Poor decision by Mark Harvey to rest Sandi so early, I reckon. Sandi was killing us in the middle and around the ground until he was moved forward for a 'rest'.

thought exactly same thing , he was flogging us

 

[HBK619]

He's done, finally and for good, ****en useless excuse for a player, barely nullified Sandilands at all, thank god Harvey has no idea otherwise we were ****ed.

Very lucky to have kicked that goal and for that I am grateful, but it is **** OFF AND LET US BE from now for Simmonds.

Gus in next week and our 22(Not to mention ruck division) looks so much better.

 

[Madtiger2006]

The Graham/Patto ruck combo will make us a better team than tonight. Gotta move Simmo on

 

[the ranger]

Was pretty ordinary for most of tonight and I can't see him playing more than 5-6 more games in his career.

BUT, did you see him after the game? Looked pretty bloody happy and had an exchange with Wallace that pretty much confirms to me that the news the other week was a load of shite. Has been shat on by the media and the Tiger fans that were so ready to believe the worst of him. Has been a good servant of the club and I'll be cheering him off in his last game.

 

[Sausage roll]

absoulote dud! hes finshed

So the general consensus is that The snag was right:? Again??


This guy is a disgraceful list clogger.


Delist now please

 

[the ranger]

HA. List clogger. WTF?

Was clearly our best ruckman until a couple of months ago. Graham looks to have passed him but has still really only played a handful of good games. Patto is maybe past him now, too, but will never be as good as Simmonds was prior to this season. The disastrous 2007 season was as bad as it was largely because of Simmonds not being fit and healthy. He was very good in 2005 and 2006 and servicable in 2008.

To say that Simmonds has been clogging our list is definitive proof that you are either trolling or the stupidest poster on the Richmond board.

 

[Danog]

So the general consensus is that The snag was right:? Again??


This guy is a disgraceful list clogger.


Delist now please

Yes, you were the only person saying this.