Immediate Trade Impact

[Butler]

With all the trades this year and the increase in sideways trading I thought it would be interesting to see how peoples trade work out the week they do them.

Obviously a trade is more long term than that but we constantly see people in the vent/kudos thread talking about the players they brought in. So here is mine last weekend:

Out: Masten (93), Watts (38)
In: Murphy (84), Leuenburger (74)

Round 2 total: +27
Season total: +27

 

[VSTone]

out: Rampe (0) Bewick (62)
in: Viney (59) Burger (74)

R2: +71

 

[TedDougChris]

This requires maths on a Friday night. So I will get back to you when I'm capable of doing maths... Perhaps on Sunday....

 

[yogibbear]

Out: Whitfield (102), Scooter (87)
In: Mundy (70), Moloney (101)
R2: -18

FMDT.

Trades for RD3 are going to be an equally spectacular fail I think... leaving $250k in the bank for R4 trades....

 

[Krujan]

Out: Macaffer (60), Lucas (76)
In: Leuenberger (74) Wines (81)
Rd2: +19

 

[pillager]

Out: Longer (0), Mitchell (19)
In: Leunberger (74), Viney (59)
R2: +114

My high differential exposes a very poor selection in Longer.

 

[lmach]

Out: Maric (77), Longer (0)
In: Kreuzer (91), Leuenberger (74)

Round 2 Total: +87
Season Total: +87

 

[terribleflowers]

kinda hard to quantify the longer switch as we only picked longer as a placeholder for luey, and longer only didn't play because luey did, so it looks like we gained a lot more than we did since that was the plan all along and longer would have probably scored 50-60 anyway. early trades are also much more about $$$ than points too obv obv.

but anyway out: longer (0), martin (93)
in: luey (74), jjk (97)

r2 +78

 

[Barry_Badrinath]

Out: Lee (0), Longer (0)
In: Dwyer (90), Leuenberger (74)

Dwyer rode the bench and Lee would've too so that made no difference.
Blicavs scored 57 and would've played had I kept Longer and his zero.

So +17 for me

 

[Anzac16]

Out: Smith(34), Harper(29)
In: Kreuzer(91), Rowe(59)

Dwyer(90) was on the field instead of Harper/Rowe though...

So R2 = +118
Total = +118

 

[Gee Dub]

Out: Watts (38). Longer (0)
In: Monfries (96), Luey (74)

+132

 

[Jars458]

Out: Whitfield (102), Scooter (87)
In: Mundy (70), Moloney (101)
R2: -18

FMDT.

Trades for RD3 are going to be an equally spectacular fail I think... leaving $250k in the bank for R4 trades....

Terrible trades yogi, the rules haven't changed overnight.

 

[Jars458]

Traded duffied today.

 

[lmach]

Traded duffied today.

Uh oh.

 

[Jars458]

Uh oh.

Dixon needs to rock.

 

[QS]

Out Lecras (0), Longer (0)
In JJK (97), Berger (74)
+171
No brainer really.

 

[mitchzz]

Out: Longer (0), Stevens (41)
In: Leunberger (74), Wines (81)

Total R2: + 114

 

[yogibbear]

Out Lecras (0), Longer (0)
In JJK (97), Berger (74)
+171
No brainer really.

So what you had no bench in either position? Kind of overstating it a bit, don't you think?

All these Longer trades are BS calculations as I'm sure you have playing ruck benches.

 

[QS]

So what you had no bench in either position? Kind of overstating it a bit, don't you think?

All these Longer trades are BS calculations as I'm sure you have playing ruck benches.

I meant, it was false economics.. I HAD to trade them out, so my + figure is inflated, thus this comparing these figures are flawed.
Nil playing bench rucks, Tom Lee (did not play) and Karnezis (9).. so -9, +162.. still a load of shit

 

[Butler]

Yeah, it's a much better way to go the In against the bench player that would have played if you hadn't of made the trade.

For example, if you had Lecras and your first bench was Macaffer then it would be Macaffer against the player you traded in.

 

[mrpig]

out karny (6) toumpas (32) (on field)

in kennedy(97) and crouch(62) (on field)

+121
some good trading last week

 

[lmach]

Traded duffied today.

Finished on 86 after being on like 70 at half time. Wow.

 

[yogibbear]

Terrible trades yogi, the rules haven't changed overnight.

They didn't change overnight, but they sure did changed compared to the last two years of DT. Overall capital is so much more critical again, and with more trades, comes more outlets to increase capital. So, if all my rookies are perfect, then I'm damn well going to sideways trade. (Grrrr Whitfield... I posted on here asking about why he was so crap in Round 1 considering he was playing wing the entire time, but no one informed me I had nothing to worry about... [Sadly I had to work 12 hr days for 21 days now, instead of 8 to 5 so 3 out of every 6 w/e's I don't get to watch the day matches]).

 

[Fyfe4Life]

Last week:
Out: Stevens(41), Robinson(75)
In: Wines(81), Wright(49)
+14 difference

 

[WCEprod]

Last Week:
Out: Currie (0) Lecras (0)
In: Leunberger (74) Rowe (59)
+74. Left Rowe on bench