In:Jack Silvagni

[T2B_]

Poor kid hates his parents for not letting him play for the future,chance to be a Giant was his dream.

I highly doubt that. Not to mention Jo would have had his head.

 

[MAXIMUM GRUNDAGE]

Look at the quality of those other 3 generation players. Hirds dad barely even got out on the park. Never even heard of the Cordners, two in your TOTC apparently though... and Hawthorn traded a Kennedy

Serge, gun, 200 odd games, in our TOTC, described by most as hard as a slab of concrete.
SOS, gun, played on the best forwards the game has ever seen and beat the lot of them. And if the opposition didnt have a FF or CHF worthy of him, he'd play forward himself and kick a bag.

Theres no questioning Jacks pedigree.

Not questioning his pedigree at all, just the claim by the OP that he's the first 3rd generation player at the same club. Don and Dennis Cordner were Ted's brother's, Edward's sons and David's uncles. Don won the 1946 Brownlow.

See 'legitimate' in dictionary.

Legitimate is the last word I would associate with any of Carlton's dealings. "able to be defended with logic or justification; valid" - but I see no logic in your claim that he is the first. You're just Hodgepodging to avoid admitting that you were wrong.

 

[Plugger35]

Meh he's just a poor man's Bailey Rice.

 

[T2B_]

Meh he's just a poor man's Bailey Rice.

Who hasn't played a game yet.

 

[Kick It 2 Me]

Thursday July 5. Out: J. Silvagni

 

[T2B_]

Thursday July 5. Out: J. Silvagni

Thursday July 5. Collingwood: shit

 

[Morganashlee]

Cute little attention whoring ploy by the blues. Jack Silvagni is about to become the new Jack Watts when we crush him. Sorry not sorry.

 

[Plugger35]

Who hasn't played a game yet.

We don't gift games for novelty value.

 

[MAXIMUM GRUNDAGE]

Cute little attention whoring ploy by the blues. Jack Silvagni is about to become the new Jack Watts when we crush him. Sorry not sorry.

You need a new Watts after the old one crushed the Pies twice this year.

 

[Austin_McCrabbs]

Cute little attention whoring ploy by the blues. Jack Silvagni is about to become the new Jack Watts when we crush him. Sorry not sorry.

You'll have to get passed Bryce Gibbs first

 

[Morganashlee]

You need a new Watts after the old one crushed the Pies twice this year.

Crushed? Please. We stunted that flogs growth for 8 years while he had reoccurring nightmares of tough guy Nick Maxwell making him his bitch.

 

[chelseacarlton]

Not questioning his pedigree at all, just the claim by the OP that he's the first 3rd generation player at the same club. Don and Dennis Cordner were Ted's brother's, Edward's sons and David's uncles. Don won the 1946 Brownlow.

Legitimate is the last word I would associate with any of Carlton's dealings. "able to be defended with logic or justification; valid" - but I see no logic in your claim that he is the first. You're just Hodgepodging to avoid admitting that you were wrong.

Maxxy,you becoming increasingly melty and wronger with each post.
The Silvagni's are the best 3 generation one club family.
Of this,after much debate and hodgepodge like data retrieval,there is no doubt.

 

[Austin_McCrabbs]

Crushed? Please. We stunted that flogs growth for 8 years while he had reoccurring nightmares of tough guy Nick Maxwell making him his bitch.

Sheesh. The way you say it makes it sound like it's something Jack Watts wouldn't like.

 

[Brutalitops]

Cute little attention whoring ploy by the blues. Jack Silvagni is about to become the new Jack Watts when we crush him. Sorry not sorry.

LoL! And just who are these Collingwood hard men? You dont have any blokes with even a skerrick of mongrel in them on your list anymore. Traded them all away, along with your next 24 first round draft picks

 

[Austin_McCrabbs]

LoL! And just who are these Collingwood hard men? You dont have any blokes with even a skerrick of mongrel in them on your list anymore. Traded them all away, along with your next 24 first round draft picks

You obviously haven't seen 'Big Bad' Brodie Grundies and Jesse 'Pink Bitz' White before

 

[Kick It 2 Me]

Collingwood 2014-16: shit
Carlton 2000-16: real shit (4 spoons)

EFA.

 

[chelseacarlton]

Meh he's just a poor man's Bailey Rice.

Meh,who?

Cute little attention whoring ploy by the blues. Jack Silvagni is about to become the new Jack Watts when we crush him. Sorry not sorry.

When finals are out of question,whore it up good and proper I always say.(actually I've never said that,but I will from now on).
Jack to kick 6 on debut.
I doubt any pie will test Cas' devotion and love for his newest protege!.
#JSJ2D

 

[Bet on Blue]

He's not the first 3rd generation player at the same club in the league either. James Hird did it 24 years ago.

But, Carlton!

 

[Brutalitops]

EFA.

Shame you cant beat us. Cant wait for your melts after the game. The Collingwood board is gonna be ****ing Chernobyl after tonight.

 

[Bomberblitzer]

Too bad he's a dud.

 

[T2B_]

We don't gift games for novelty value.

Cute but he's had genuinely good form in consecutive weeks.

 

[Brutalitops]

Too bad he's a dud.

Has Daniher figured out which sticks to kick the ball through yet? Got yourself a Cloke in the making there buddy

 

[JustaBattler]

Cute little attention whoring ploy by the blues. Jack Silvagni is about to become the new Jack Watts when we crush him. Sorry not sorry.

What are you going to do sit on him?

 

[chelseacarlton]

Too bad he's a dud.

Carlton are the only legitimate club with 16 flags.
You're also wrong on your reply.
Your entire list are duds and the rest are drug cheats.
Now,that is how you prove "too bad" and "dud".
Have a blue coloured amazeball for all your troubles,of which I'm sure there are many!.

 

[Doss]

Bit touchy.