Ins & Outs vs Western Bulldogs

[BomberAce7]

In - Johnson, Welsh, Magin.
Out - Jetta(Inj), Mcveigh(Tribunal ?), Stanton(Omit)

The reason i believe Brent should get dropped is cos he looks like he's travelling in 1st gear. He hasnt played well at all so far this season. McVeigh i hope doesnt get suspended for punching Fevola.

 

[neeksy]

i dont know if i would drop stanton just yet,maybe give him one more week.
he hasnt played that badly,he just hasnt played his best.
which he should be playing but i still think he should be in the team.
i didnt see the mcveigh thing,did it look bad?
hopefully hes not out then

 

[BomberAce7]

i dont know if i would drop stanton just yet,maybe give him one more week.
he hasnt played that badly,he just hasnt played his best.
which he should be playing but i still think he should be in the team.
i didnt see the mcveigh thing,did it look bad?
hopefully hes not out then

No i didnt look bad but it was intentional. Who knows what the tribunal will do.

 

[lamaros]

Are you kidding? Stanton worked very hard tonight. Give him a break.

Houli and Lonergan were poor. Their skills are still dodgy. Pev was afwul. Awful.

McVeigh should be ok.

Out: Jetta, Pev.
In: Welsh, Neagle?

 

[BomberAce7]

Are you kidding? Stanton worked very hard tonight. Give him a break.

Houli and Lonergan were poor. Their skills are still dodgy. Pev was afwul. Awful.

McVeigh should be ok.

Out: Jetta, Pev.
In: Welsh, Neagle?

I agree Bachar had a poor game. Lonergan was just ok. Pev well his 1st kick was a goal but yeah he wasnt good i agree.

 

[bossco]

Out: Pev
In: Lovett-Murray

 

[EssendonBombersFC]

OUT: Jetta(inj), Pev
IN: Welsh, Neagle/Gumbleton if ready.

 

[silk]

Out - Jetta, Pev
In - NLM, JJ

 

[Wahooti Fandango]

Are you kidding? Stanton worked very hard tonight. Give him a break.

Houli and Lonergan were poor. Their skills are still dodgy. Pev was afwul. Awful.

McVeigh should be ok.

Out: Jetta, Pev.
In: Welsh, Neagle?

I thought Lonergan was very good tonight.

Out: Jetta, Pev
In: NLM, Welsh

 

[flyin'high]

In - Johnson, Welsh, Magin.
Out - Jetta(Inj), Mcveigh(Tribunal ?), Stanton(Omit)

The reason i believe Brent should get dropped is cos he looks like he's travelling in 1st gear. He hasnt played well at all so far this season. McVeigh i hope doesnt get suspended for punching Fevola.

stants shouldnt be dropped yet ,he had a very poor first half but the second half and especially the last quarter he was brilliant ,in the last quarter he looked like the stanton of last year ,hopefully next week against the dogs we will see a decent four quarter effort that we know he is capable of

 

[raskolnikov]

Out: Pev

Terrible game.

 

[DonMania#5]

In : Lovett-Murray

Out : Jetta

 

[SirJimi05]

Are you kidding? Stanton worked very hard tonight. Give him a break.

Houli and Lonergan were poor. Their skills are still dodgy. Pev was afwul. Awful.

McVeigh should be ok.

Out: Jetta, Pev.
In: Welsh, Neagle?

Were you at the game?

Stanton was ordinary to say the least. I paid particular attention to his work off the ball and i can recall atleast 3 times where he could have pushed himself into a contest to cut off a lead or make a spoil but he chose to hang back and then stand there with his hands on his hips. One time he heard Fev coming and basically stopped his run at the ball. I thought he was pretty weak tonight. He needs to lift.

 

[lamaros]

Out: Pev, Jetta. (Maybe: Lonergan)
In: Welsh, Lovett-Murray. (Slattery? JJ? Neagle? CJ?)

We could use some bigger bodies in the forward line who can kick goals, I think we have enough small/fast guys in the team that we don't need to replace like-for-like.

Pev was bad tonight. Should be dropped.
Monfries didn't stay in it enough but tried.
Dyson used it well be didn't get enough of it again this week.
Houli was hardly in it but showed in flashes what he can do. Once he can put a full game together and work on his handball he'll be really useful.
Lonergan tried hard but his skills were bad and his tackling, while had intensity, was pretty poor. 50/50 on dropping him, probably keep him due to not having anyone to take his place.
Lovett was good and kicked some key goals when we needed them. I thought he should have got that other one too, looked like it was touched by the carlton player behind the line (he hit it back but it still didn't cross back into play--therefore he must have been behind the line when he hit it back in, therefore it was a goal).
Fletch had a bad game by his standards but was ok.
Mal was unlucky and still a little slow for Fev. I thought he was good otherwise.
Ryder is class, I can't get enough of him. I wish he played more around the ground.
Davey was good again. Love the guy.
Hille was out of at times but lifted at the end. Still needs to kick more goals given his puts himself in the right place to do so every week.
Jetta will be missed. Would have been nice to see some goals from him.
Laycock still needs to get that marking down. Great kick. If only he could get Hills marking ability and mobility but retain his kicking, and vice-versa.
Lloyd was average, took some good marks, could have got more goals but still got some very useful ones.
McPhee was one of our best, his leading up the ground and overall movement was exactly when we need of him. Stood up in the pressure with his marking this week.
McVeigh: Super. Hope to see more games like this from him this year and less like the Geelong game.
Nash didn't use the ball tonight as well as he can.
Rama was average.
Reimers. Not sure what to say about him, could have done better in some aspects but used the ball ok most of the time, kicked a handy goal and looked compsed.
Stanton was good in the second half, ran hard and used the ball well.
Watson was down and it showed for the second week in a row. When he's not firing we have little in the stoppages. He needs help from others.
Winders was ok.

 

[dave_27]

IN: Atkinson

 

[lamaros]

Were you at the game?

Stanton was ordinary to say the least. I paid particular attention to his work off the ball and i can recall atleast 3 times where he could have pushed himself into a contest to cut off a lead or make a spoil but he chose to hang back and then stand there with his hands on his hips. One time he heard Fev coming and basically stopped his run at the ball. I thought he was pretty weak tonight. He needs to lift.

No I missed the game tonight. Just going off what I saw on TV i'm afraid.

I saw that bit with Fev but couldn't see who the player was. That was really weak and I was very pissed off at that. If that was Stanton then I'll have to revise my estimation. Soft.

 

[marcuz]

I wouldnt be suprised if atkinson gets a run next week.

Pev will be dropped, we played one short while he was tagging Judd. I wish Hislop and Hocking would heal the ____ up. If we needed any convincing that we are 1-2 big bodies short in the middle then the last 2 weeks have confirmed it.

In: Welsh, NLM/Atkinson

Out: Pev, Jetta

 

[Windas_Magic]

Were you at the game?

Stanton was ordinary to say the least. I paid particular attention to his work off the ball and i can recall atleast 3 times where he could have pushed himself into a contest to cut off a lead or make a spoil but he chose to hang back and then stand there with his hands on his hips. One time he heard Fev coming and basically stopped his run at the ball. I thought he was pretty weak tonight. He needs to lift.

That was a time when he was filling the whole and had an opportunity to stop Fev's run but got out of the way, i must say i was dissappointed with him. I wouldn't drop him anyway.

IN: Welsh, NLM
Out: Jetta and Pev (shocker!)

 

[lamaros]

Pev on Judd: Holding off the ball to give away free kicks, never in sight when he had the ball.

 

[retroparty]

Give Stants another couple of weeks. Looks like he is playing with no confidence. Pev should probably be dropped and Welsh should come in. Jetta in injured so we could bring in JJ. Haven't seen what McVeigh did yet.

 

[bOmBeR_BoY1]

We tore these guys a new ars*hole in the NAB Cup with half a side and they had many of the experienced campaigners out there...

They are playing well, but it's our first home game at our home ground on our favourite stage, Friday Night - think we'll surprise a few... they'll be oozing confidence and arrogance out Footscray way this week - we've made them feel more than foolish in past meetings in similar scenarios... time for the boys to pull one out of the bag in front of a big Friday Night home crowd...

 

[Bomber32]

In: Lovett-Murray, Welsh
Out: Jetta, Peverill

 

[mojon95]

We'll want tall forwards to test their defence and lots of running players

IN: Neagle, Welsh, NLM

OUT: Pev, Jetta, Monfries


Is is just me or did Jobe have a terrible night.

 

[lemon chicken]

I thought Lonergan was terrific last night, played in a more suitable role for his game. Cant see Welsh coming straight in, dont think he's fit. Only player I'd like to see dropped is Pev but nobody is really screaming out pick me. Jetta was running along the boundary after he went off hopefully not to bad.

 

[SirJimi05]

I thought Lonergan was terrific last night, played in a more suitable role for his game. Cant see Welsh coming straight in, dont think he's fit. Only player I'd like to see dropped is Pev but nobody is really screaming out pick me. Jetta was running along the boundary after he went off hopefully not to bad.

Grade 1, two weeks is the early prognosis.