Ins & Outs???

[shawthing09]

agreed. marks bouncing off he's chest, slow. he doesnt do enough to be an afl player.

You have been against him since before he got an afl game and often with critisms that were often untrue such as been a soft outside wingman.

He is harder then a lot of players with a lot more experince and throws himself into contests with wreckless abandon were a few more seasoned players would not. His been excellent in every game bar one that he has played and has certainly been AFL level for any player let alone one with less then 10 games to his name.

Shows a ton of promise is one of the shinning lights ( the other being pendles) in a rather lack luster group of young mids

 

[Chase the Ace]

In: Wood (Rocca if fit)
Out: Bryan

 

[doofdoof]

You have been against him since before he got an afl game and often with critisms that were often untrue such as been a soft outside wingman.

He is harder then a lot of players with a lot more experince and throws himself into contests with wreckless abandon were a few more seasoned players would not. His been excellent in every game bar one that he has played and has certainly been AFL level for any player let alone one with less then 10 games to his name.

Shows a ton of promise is one of the shinning lights ( the other being pendles) in a rather lack luster group of young mids

 

[Chase the Ace]

agreed. marks bouncing off he's chest, slow. he doesnt do enough to be an afl player.

And after just 4 games you can tell.
So how did you rate Dane Swan and Leon Davis after 4 games.

You know, I've never understood why people say Collingwood supporters are nuff nuffs

 

[checker]

And after just 4 games you can tell.
So how did you rate Dane Swan and Leon Davis after 4 games.

You know, I've never understood why people say Collingwood supporters are nuff nuffs

if you watch him in one game you can tell. im not saying he will never be good, im just saying there is better players in the 2s that are ahead of him who arent getting the chances he is,e.g stanley, iles, mcaffer anthony.

 

[shawthing09]

if you watch him in one game you can tell. im not saying he will never be good, im just saying there is better players in the 2s that are ahead of him who arent getting the chances he is,e.g stanley, iles, mcaffer anthony.

Anthony is having massive bags kicked on him at VFL level and is a defender, Maccaffer is a half foward flank not mid. Iles hasn't been outstanding at VFL this year and when at AFL level did not do as much as Sharrord has and Stanley is in the same boat as Iles. For one reason or another you just have something against Sharrord I don't know what it is but your assesments of him are always way off the mark. I am not saying he is a star but just that your assesments of him are pathetic and often make me wonder if you have seen him play.

 

[King Woodie]

Back to topic...

Out: Cloke, Johnson
In: Anthony, Wood

 

[checker]

Anthony is having massive bags kicked on him at VFL level and is a defender, Maccaffer is a half foward flank not mid. Iles hasn't been outstanding at VFL this year and when at AFL level did not do as much as Sharrord has and Stanley is in the same boat as Iles. For one reason or another you just have something against Sharrord I don't know what it is but your assesments of him are always way off the mark. I am not saying he is a star but just that your assesments of him are pathetic and often make me wonder if you have seen him play.

anthony- bags kicked on him?

iles- over 30 touches in many games this year, last week- best on with 34 touches and 2 goals.

stanley is a bit of a lost cause.

 

[shawthing09]

anthony- bags kicked on him?

iles- over 30 touches in many games this year, last week- best on with 34 touches and 2 goals.

stanley is a bit of a lost cause.

Podsi and Hackland, More importantly a defender is not going to replace a midfielder

iles- vfl does not always translate to afl ben davies thread

Back on topic with Cloke now out

Wood McCarthy in

Cloke Johnson out

rucks rotating in the foward line

 

[checker]

Podsi and Hackland, More importantly a defender is not going to replace a midfielder

iles- vfl does not always translate to afl ben davies thread

Back on topic with Cloke now out

Wood McCarthy in

Cloke Johnson out

rucks rotating in the foward line

haha.

 

[Magpie_Matty]

surely its time to give dawes a run

In : Dawes

Out : Cloke ( suspended )

 

[pieman123]

In: anthony,mccarthy,wood,dawes
Out: maxwell/wakelin, johnson, cloke, fraser/bryan

 

[goalpie]

anthony- bags kicked on him?

iles- over 30 touches in many games this year, last week- best on with 34 touches and 2 goals.

stanley is a bit of a lost cause.

They are not Malthouses little bum bitches. When will people learn.

 

[Prem87]

Whats been wrong with Rocca? When do you expect him back into the side?

 

[Ron]

Ok i have given this some thought and i hope this is how we go.

Out - Davis and Fraser, they need a rest, Davis especially. Cloke - suspended. Wakelin - Just don't think there is a matchup for him. Maxwell - Would rather have Goldsack in the team.

In - Wood, Goldsack, Dawes, McCarthy and someone else possibly Iles or even dare i say it Egan.

I know five changes is excessive, but if you are going to do it, they week before the bye is the time to do it. Davis isn't 100% and i doubt Fraser is either, they need a couple of weeks rest.

Can't really see anyone for Wakes to play on in the dogs forwardline, so send him back to the VFL or even let him have a rest.

 

[checker]

They are not Malthouses little bum bitches. When will people learn.

finally a fellow collingwood supporter with some sense, thank you.

 

[King Woodie]

Ok i have given this some thought and i hope this is how we go.

Out - Davis and Fraser, they need a rest, Davis especially. Cloke - suspended. Wakelin - Just don't think there is a matchup for him. Maxwell - Would rather have Goldsack in the team.

In - Wood, Goldsack, Dawes, McCarthy and someone else possibly Iles or even dare i say it Egan.

I know five changes is excessive, but if you are going to do it, they week before the bye is the time to do it. Davis isn't 100% and i doubt Fraser is either, they need a couple of weeks rest.

Can't really see anyone for Wakes to play on in the dogs forwardline, so send him back to the VFL or even let him have a rest.

This team would get smashed.

Two debutants (Dawes and McCarthy), and either Iles or Egan, against a rampaging Dogs outfit, without our starting ruckman, CHF, FF, and second best small forward / midfielder.

If this were to happen, it would virtually be a decision to forgo the four points against the Dogs in an attempt to have the players better off after the break.

Wakelin's match-up is either Minson or Welsh. Most likely Minson to be honest, with Brown to take the more mobile Welsh.

Can't see Anthony not getting a game this week.

 

[jonesy86]

IN:
Wood
Dawes
Goldsack

OUT:
Fraser (struggling with his knee, if he misses this game then he gets an extra week with the bye following)
Cloke (susp.)
Wakelin (Dogs play a small forward line, no match up for Wakes)