Ins & Outs???

[bucksisbest]

Lonie's not even playing in the VFL at the moment ,so he won't be coming in any time soon.

 

[Stakerz]

I hate playing the Dogs at the dome

 

[Stakerz]

OUT: Maxwell, Reid, Fraser
IN: Rocca, Wood, Anthony.

____EN HELL!!!!!

 

[King Woodie]

King_woodie your jkin sayin anthony on murphy right?

Murphy is their marking CHF who covers a great deal of ground. I would think that O'Brien is the best match-up for him, but feel that he is needed on JOhnson, who will play closer to goal. Would prefer Anthony on Murphy over each of Maxwell, Wakelin, Brown, etc.

 

[Optimax]

I hate playing the Dogs at the dome

i hate playing at the dome, dont care who especially in our home game

 

[King Woodie]

Clarke is fine... it's just he is NOT A BACKMAN! He is ment to run n run n run but he can't! What happened against Geelong? B.O.G and was in the middle....

He cant adapt to the quick decisions of a backline yet.

He was in the backline against Geelong... But I agree, I think he is best suited to coming off a wing or even a defensive tagger job (ie putting him on Stevens or Murphy today would have been good). I think he is less suited to small defender on the goal line - and that is a position that we can rotate players like McCarthy, Iles, Cook, etc through.

 

[goalpie]

Dome sucks. Wont go there not for anything.

In: Buckley
Out: Malthouse.

Are we ever going to get rid of this knob.

 

[Big Bucks]

out fraser just cant jump, looked totally injured today
in Wood at leats he will jump at ruck contests.

Out the bullshit we played today
In some heart what happened since the geelong game?

Opti you know ____ all about football
I told you Frser is a ____en hack, and you said he waS THE BEST RUCKMAN IN THE LAND.
Take Hackwell with you, absolute piece of sh!t

 

[checker]

In: Iles, Cox, Wood.

Out: Clarke, O'brien, Fraser.

 

[HFF]

There will not be wholesale changes this week.

Considering our VFL side got pumped too, changes look minimal.

Whilst Josh was disappointing, he will bounce back and is our #1 ruckman. His around the ground stuff will be vital against Hudson and Minson who really aren't that great around the ground.

I think Iles is probably the only one who put his hand up for selection this week from the VFL side and maybe J-Mac.

For those who have suggested Dawes are kidding themselves. MM will not simply give players games they have not warranted and going by Dawes' form, he has not been crash hot. Plus Reid was among the best.

In: Iles (been relatively solid and among the best many times this season, just unlucky not to break into the line-up. 34 disposals and 2 goals is good enough IMO for a spot in the seniors).

Out: Johnson (too predictable and disposal is still a worry with too many passes going over the top, may also be cited from reports when a Carlton player went down too).

 

[eddiesmith]

Out: Johnson, Maxwell, Bryan

In: Cook, Anthony, Wood

Would bring in Lonie instead of Cook but he has disappeared from the face of the earth

 

[The Royal Sampler]

There will not be wholesale changes this week.

Considering our VFL side got pumped too, changes look minimal.

When "development" is the be-all and end-all in the VFL side, getting pumped (in the VFL) will not prevent anyone from being given a senior opportunity. So far we've only won 2 VFL games, and yet we've played the likes of Toovey, Cox, Wellingham, Stanley, Cook, Reid, Anthony and Egan at various times.

 

[HFF]

When "development" is the be-all and end-all in the VFL side, getting pumped (in the VFL) will not prevent anyone from being given a senior opportunity. So far we've only won 2 VFL games, and yet we've played the likes of Toovey, Cox, Wellingham, Stanley, Cook, Reid, Anthony and Egan at various times.

Yes, I totally understand that TRS, however all those players you have mentioned have figured regularly among the best in the VFL when they have been considered for selection.

I just can't accept people's logic on giving a young kid a game if he doesn't deserve the opportunity i.e. Dawes.

If we were to 'blood the list' and build for next season then go for it, however, we are in contention for a finals campaign at the moment and can even push for a top 4 berth provided we get the results.

 

[The Royal Sampler]

You're saying there'll be minimal changes because the VFL side got pumped. I'm saying there's been changes all year and the VFL side has been pumped on all but 2 occasions.

Anthony has been in the best consistently. McCarthy has been in the best on several occasions, as has Iles. The VFL side getting pumped will not affect their chances of senior selection.

 

[magpies42]

out:fraser, Davis (injured)
in: wood, mccarthy

 

[loki04]

Lonie wont get in because he is not one off malthouses bum buddies.

amd becuase he is a soft footballer who is grosely overrated by pie fans, also last time he played against the dogs was 06 final.....

 

[TheClokes]

B: Clarke - Brown - Maxwell
HB: R. Shaw - O'Brien - Wellingham
C: Johnson - Burns - Pendlebury
HF: Didak - Cloke - Thomas
F: Davis - Reid - Medhurst
FL: Bryan - Swan - Lockyer
INT: H. Shaw - O'Bree - Dawes - Wood​

Out: Fraser - Wakelin

 

[BEEG]

Out = Johnson, Maxwell, Fraser

In = Iles/Mccarthy, Anthony, Wood

Johnson this year has been ____ing terrible if he isnt droped soon its a discrace

 

[shawthing09]

Out - Johnson Fraser

In - Mccarthy Wood

I agree with MDC's assesment of Ried's defensive pressure but I think seeing it was his 1st game back in the one's I'd rather he have it bought up to him first if it continutes though it is something to be dropped for, but after that preformance and his in comparision too many others I don't think he should be dropped but it should deffinatly be addressed

 

[goalpie]

Hope Wellingham gets axed this week, seriously over rated player.

 

[HFF]

Hope Wellingham gets axed this week, seriously over rated player.

You sir, are a tool.

 

[goalpie]

You sir, are a tool.

In another two years you will agree as well.

 

[jefffff34]

Iles.

 

[checker]

Hope Wellingham gets axed this week, seriously over rated player.

agreed. marks bouncing off he's chest, slow. he doesnt do enough to be an afl player.

 

[sirlothie]

How has McCarthy been travelling??

Worth a trundle?