Internal Trial

[Team DJ]

Wasnt sure what to title this one, but thought it would be a bit of fun.

We are now up to our 8th Head Coach (Full Time):
Cornes - 91 - 94, Shaw - 95 - 96, Blight - 97 - 99, Ayres - 00 - 04, Craig - 05 - 11, Sanderson - 12 - 14, Walsh - 15, Pyke - 16 -

If you were to pick a best of team for our first 4 and then our second 4 coaches who would win? You can only pick a player once however. Below is my attempt.

Team 1
Coach: M. Blight
Assistants: G. Cornes, R. Shaw, G. Ayres
B. Hart R. Jameson K. Johnson
C. McDermott P. Caven N. Smart
K. Koster M. Ricciuto A. McLeod
T. McGuiness M. Robran T. Bond
D. Jarman T. Modra P. Vardy
S. Rehn M. Bickley A. Jarman

D. Pittman M. Stevens B. James M. Connell

Team 2
Coach: N. Craig
Assistants: B. Sanderson, P. Walsh, D. Pyke
N. Bassett B. Rutten G. Johncock
T. Edwards D. Talia N. VanBerlo
R. Douglas S. Thompson R. Sloane
B. Burton T. Walker B. Vince
J. Porplyzia K. Tippett S. Welsh
S. Jacobs S. Goodwin P. Dangerfield

N. Bock B. Reilly B. Smith E. Betts


The debatable ones for mine is what team should Ricciuto, McLeod, Goodwin and Edwards be in? I decided to go 2 and 2.

I think team 1 wins with the likes of the Jarmans, Modra, Roo and McLeod. However think the bottom 6 players are better in Team 2.

 

[Mego Red]

Well, this isn't what I thought this thread would be about.

 

[Donkey Magoo]

I think that you gotta put guys in where they debut. Team 1 should win comfortably.

 

[DD#23]

I think that you gotta put guys in where they debut. Team 1 should win comfortably.

well absolutely if you give them a much larger pool of players to select from with that rule...

plus you get to judge every player in Team 1 on their entire careers and not almost be forced to select guys who only started a year or two ago like Team 2 has to.

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

I think that you gotta put guys in where they debut. Team 1 should win comfortably.

Or put them where they played the majority of their games.