Think Tank Is Daisy Thomas the worst player in the league?

[skipjack]

Sitting here trying to think of a player that has less impact on a game. In fact, whenever I am unlucky enough to catch a Carlton game, he seems to be having a NEGATIVE impact. Can't outrun anyone. Can't hit the side of a barn with his disposal.

His sole contribution seems to be the goofy grin which is some kind of reaction to being embarrassed.

Put up your nominations for players that are worse than Daisy.

 

[maryjames]

Let’s see if he gets more then 7 possessions first. Then I’ll start the debate

 

[skipjack]

I see where you are going. But seriously, Carlton fans must wince whenever he gets near the ball. He is truly awful. It's sad cause he used to be good!

Mods feel free to send this to the main board.

 

[maryjames]

Thomas is actually doing ok in this game.

 

[chefmeister]

Let’s see if he gets more then 7 possessions first. Then I’ll start the debate

Well he has 12 to half time.
Hmmmm...

Mods just slap the backfire tag on this sucker now.

 

[Dave Stevens]

Will Langford

 

[skipjack]

Well he has 12 to half time.
Hmmmm...

Mods just slap the backfire tag on this sucker now.

But him getting the ball doesn't prove me wrong

What I'm saying is that even when he gets near the ball he has a negative impact on the side. Turnovers, handballs to nowhere, kicks off the side of the boot that go out on the full. It's constant.

 

[skipjack]

Will Langford

Played three massive games in a finals series a couple of years back. Done **** all since. Worthy of discussion.

 

[Baldur]

Sitting here trying to think of a player that has less impact on a game. In fact, whenever I am unlucky enough to catch a Carlton game, he seems to be having a NEGATIVE impact. Can't outrun anyone. Can't hit the side of a barn with his disposal.

His sole contribution seems to be the goofy grin which is some kind of reaction to being embarrassed.

Put up your nominations for players that are worse than Daisy.

You clearly have not been watching St Kilda play this year. Half our team is worse.

 

[maryjames]

But him getting the ball doesn't prove me wrong

What I'm saying is that even when he gets near the ball he has a negative impact on the side. Turnovers, handballs to nowhere, kicks off the side of the boot that go out on the full. It's constant.

Disagree. Took a huge mark got it going and Carlton kick a goal through superstar Salvani. Also got in and under and got it out and created more opportunities for Carlton. All in all he does more then a certain hawk player who dreams of 12 touches in a half

 

[Occidental]

Had an ankle reconstruction and a shoulder reconstruction. He is cooked. Lost his acceleration, lost his spring, lost 10m at least off his kicking.
Yet Carlton keep playing him.

 

[Dave Stevens]

Taylor Walker wouldn’t be far off on current form

 

[skipjack]

Had an ankle reconstruction and a shoulder reconstruction. He is cooked. Lost his acceleration, lost his spring, lost 10m at least off his kicking.
Yet Carlton keep playing him.

True. That loss of pace, acceleration and spring is cruel. Back in the Malthouse days at Collingwood he was awesome.

 

[Starburns_]

Jack Silvagni says Thomas isn't even the worst player at Carlton.

 

[Morganashlee]

 

[Dave Stevens]

And a ripping bloke is Dale.

He’s nowhere near the worst at Carlton let alone the comp.

 

[MAXIMUM GRUNDAGE]

My workmate witnessed Daisy getting punched out at the Drouin pub a few years back.

 

[Hawk Dork]

Majak looks like a better footballer

 

[Supercoach Bargain]

Jack Silvagni.

 

[sonnywalters]

Hayden Ballantyne.

 

[hawkman]

Jack Silvagni says Thomas isn't even the worst player at Carlton.

Liam Jones makes Thomas look good as well

 

[Supercoach Bargain]

It's all so long ago.....

 

[juice t]

Isn't even the shittest player at Carltank

 

[A Cut Above]

Not the worst, and not the most overpaid either

 

[HairyO]

Will Langford

Would be on 1/3 the money. And occasionally lays tackles.