Is this a chance?

[NUCKLE]

Chilliboy & other esteemed trade rumour experts I believe this information that I just found on Demonland.com could actually be pretty accurate.

Because it seems fair and equal and actually a post where Melbourne players are not overestimated or overvalued.

1, Green, Armstrong & Pick 28 to Brisbane for Luke Power

2, Yze & Bizzell to Carlton for Whitnall & Pick 20

3, Pick 12 & Pick 20 traded jointly for the best available player (possibly Bartel)

4. Pick 44 traded to Collingwood for Shane Woewodin

Demons Gain: Luke Power, Lance Whitnall, Jimmy Bartel & Shane Woewodin

Demons Lose: Green, Yze, Bizzell, Armstrong & 1st, 2nd & 3rd round draft picks.

 

[Deestroy]

Considering you HAVE to pick up a minimum of 3 players in the draft, that leaves us with some real dud selections.

 

[melbournemartin]

i'd rather trade ward or heffernan then pick 44 to the pies for woewodin

i wouldnt do the whitnall deal.

the other 2 would be beauties but unlikely

 

[demons_bri]

yze looks set to stay, aswel as white and neitz, channel 10 news reported this tonite

 

[Unleash Hell]

Personally i don't see Luke Power coming to the Dees, but if we got 1 or even 2 of Bartel, Whitnall, Power or Watts i would be pretty happy

we lack a few quality middy's so Bartel and Power would be my top priority with Whintall or Watts as a bonus


No to Hay, Polak just because they are both WA Boys......

 

[dee_molisher]

If we recruit Whitnal, we seriously have lost the plot.

 

[Unleash Hell]

If we recruit Whitnal, we seriously have lost the plot.

Please don't take this as an attack on you...


How have we lost the plot??? I was originally agianst it but have warmed to the big fella.
Neitz is the only player we have on our list who is a strong KPP and Neita i am sad to say is past it. Miller as much as i love him is not the awnser at least not now. (he is 22 - 23 in March i think, soz i am too lazy to look), and still needs time to develop.

To have any chance at winning a flag u need a big man who can take a grab. Whintall is that. Look at the Lions and look at the Eagles. What is the difference you ask between these two side?? Lions had Brown and Lynch, the Eagles had Hunter & Hansen, catching my drift??

A forward line with Miller Whintall Bruce
Davey Neitz Robbo

looks damn good to me!

 

[D_double_E]

yze looks set to stay, aswel as white and neitz, channel 10 news reported this tonite

Sweet, these three will be play a huge part in a contending next year.

 

[CowboyFromHell]

Nuckle = Sucked in.

 

[CaptainDavey]

Since when is Greeny going to leave the club?...I always saw him as being a future captain. Having Whitnall would be great though, although he can't run he's an great kick and a very, very smart KPP

 

[deestroyerz]

that leaves us with despicible draft picks. bartel in early 20's is good. definately power at 25. i think the one we need to go for most is bartel. we need more hardness through the midfield. remember we can still go for watts who is awesome. im not sure whether i would want him or whitnall more. is he going to be a 100 plus monster. i cant be bothered at looking at what he weighs. we still have untried nick smith who looks crap. but this warnock dude played well in the sandy grand final and looks a good type. has anyone heard the rumour we will be recruiting his brother. robert warnock in draft. 201 centimetres and 77 kilos!!!!! we still have paul johnson, ridiculous. our depth will be extrodinary. what do we do with jamar?? sandy will win the flag. they are a shoe in for 06

 

[demonfire]

we wont get 4 big names like that... and that is a huge shake up to the side. one that isnt needed...

EDIT: 3 big names and woewodin

 

[Slander]

Chilliboy & other esteemed trade rumour experts I believe this information that I just found on Demonland.com could actually be pretty accurate.

Because it seems fair and equal and actually a post where Melbourne players are not overestimated or overvalued.

1, Green, Armstrong & Pick 28 to Brisbane for Luke Power

OMG that's soooo unfair we would b getting soooooo scrood.
Armstrong & pick 44 for Power = much better

2, Yze & Bizzell to Carlton for Whitnall & Pick 20

Bizzell for Whitnall its a done deal

3, Pick 12 & Pick 20 traded jointly for the best available player (possibly Bartel)

Nooooooo pick 12 for Bartel
pick 60 for Shannon Grant

4. Pick 44 traded to Collingwood for Shane Woewodin

Luke Williams for Shane Woewodin

+ pick 12 in the PSD gets Fergus Watts

Demons Gain: Luke Power, Lance Whitnall, Jimmy Bartel, Shannon Grant, Shane Woewodin & Fergus Watts

Demons Lose: Bizzell, Armstrong, Williams & 1st, 2nd & 3rd round draft picks.

 

[Squarky]

OMG that's soooo unfair we would b getting soooooo scrood.
Armstrong & pick 44 for Power = much better


Bizzell for Whitnall its a done deal



Nooooooo pick 12 for Bartel
pick 60 for Shannon Grant


Luke Williams for Shane Woewodin

+ pick 12 in the PSD gets Fergus Watts

Demons Gain: Luke Power, Lance Whitnall, Jimmy Bartel, Shannon Grant, Shane Woewodin & Fergus Watts

Demons Lose: Bizzell, Armstrong, Williams & 1st, 2nd & 3rd round draft picks.

It's this sort of attitude that gets Collingwood nothing each year at the trade table. Total rubbish - you've got to give something to get something.