Isn't It Amazing When.......

[dee-molishon]

.............you kick the ball in quickly how much easier kick ins become!!!!

I swear the coaching staff has been reading this forum during the week. Well done all, we have solved that crisis for them.

If the melbourne coaching staff have any other problems they want us to solve feel free to post them here.

 

[BROCKTHEROCK]

Re: Isnt It Amazing When.......

If it wasn't for those 15 mins where they got about 8 goals, we would have had an easy win. Lucky we didn't, no priority for Richmond and Naitanui is in the bag

 

[dee-molishon]

Re: Isnt It Amazing When.......

If it wasn't for those 15 mins where they got about 8 goals, we would have had an easy win. Lucky we didn't, no priority for Richmond and Naitanui is in the bag

Take ur happy to lose attitude of my thread and jam it up your arse.

 

[master bate]

Re: Isnt It Amazing When.......

.............you kick the ball in quickly how much easier kick ins become!!!!

I swear the coaching staff has been reading this forum during the week. Well done all, we have solved that crisis for them.

If the melbourne coaching staff have any other problems they want us to solve feel free to post them here.

I agree, they should all kick in quickly, unless there is absolutely no option for them, where I can understand the swap the ball crap. Also maybe Frawley can be band from kicking in, his mistake was pretty horrible.

 

[BROCKTHEROCK]

Re: Isnt It Amazing When.......

Take ur happy to lose attitude of my thread and jam it up your arse.

I guess your one of those people who liked the win against the bulldogs last year.

What a great win.

Only cost us Naitanui AND Rich (and pick 19 last year), but oh yeah those 2 days of feeling good about the win were all worth it

People who have Melbournes future at heart are pleased with the loss.

 

[dee-molishon]

Re: Isnt It Amazing When.......

I guess your one of those people who liked the win against the bulldogs last year.

What a great win.

Only cost us Naitanui AND Rich (and pick 19 last year), but oh yeah those 2 days of feeling good about the win were all worth it

People who have Melbournes future at heart are pleased with the loss.

Yea there the same people who dont buy memberships each and every year. Fk off dkhead and support carlton. You tanking ckhead piece of shit.

Buy a membership help the club with money!! Thats where our future lies not in the flipping draft!!!

 

[BROCKTHEROCK]

Re: Isnt It Amazing When.......

Yea there the same people who dont buy memberships each and every year. Fk off dkhead and support carlton. You tanking ckhead piece of shit.

Buy a membership help the club with money!! Thats where our future lies not in the flipping draft!!!

Ive been a member without fail since 1991.
Sorry for actually wanting a good squad that will lead us to a premiership in the future. Winning token games against the tiggers, i really couldn't care less this season.

My deepest apolgies, sir.

 

[bringbackschwarter5]

Re: Isnt It Amazing When.......

If it wasn't for those 15 mins where they got about 8 goals, we would have had an easy win. Lucky we didn't, no priority for Richmond and Naitanui is in the bag

Back to the snow, Mr Fairweather

 

[BROCKTHEROCK]

Re: Isnt It Amazing When.......

Back to the snow, Mr Fairweather

Wouldn't fairwearther supporters TECHNICALLY not be around when we're losing?

Jeeze, i thought the stereotype was that our supporters were at least SMART.

 

[Headless]

We want supporters who spew with hurt after we lose, not soft supporters like you.

Look at all the duds picked up in the first 5 picks of the draft. High picks aren't everything.

 

[dee-molishon]

We want supporters who spew with hurt after we lose, not soft supporters like you.

Look at all the duds picked up in the first 5 picks of the draft. High picks aren't everything.

Spot on!!! As i recall judd was pick 3 and franklin was pick 5. There for all the best three players (gary ablett father and son) in the afl have been drafted outside the top two picks.

I dont know why you would even go to games if you want to lose, whats the point?

I know i go over the top asking for the heads of everyone down to the boot studder after a loss. BUT THERE IS NO WAY IN HELL I WANT TO LOSE GAMES!!

 

[BROCKTHEROCK]

We want supporters who spew with hurt after we lose, not soft supporters like you.

Yeah... I'm more of a glass half full kind of guy.

I try to take out the positives of most things in life, maybe you should too.

 

[cannons]

Why does this debate continue to rage?

The way I see it, there are two viewpoints on the issue:

1. Supporters who don't mind losing in order to gain the best players for the future

2. Supporters who always want wins to ensure the club has a strong attitude, work ethic and culture

There is no optimal answer in my opinion. I don't think it matters which of those two categories you fall into, as long as you have the club's best interests at heart.

 

[dee-molishon]

Why does this debate continue to rage?

The way I see it, there are two viewpoints on the issue:

1. Supporters who don't mind losing in order to gain the best players for the future

2. Supporters who always want wins to ensure the club has a strong attitude, work ethic and culture

There is no optimal answer in my opinion. I don't think it matters which of those two categories you fall into, as long as you have the club's best interests at heart.

Like i said in a previous comment. The best three players in the afl have come from outside the top two picks in the draft. SO HOW DOES THIS HELP YOU GAIN THE BEST PLAYERS FOR THE FUTURE?

All it does is give you the best picks. It doesnt take in account anything else.

We need to learn how to win before we can get better

 

[cannons]

Like i said in a previous comment. The best three players in the afl have come from outside the top two picks in the draft. SO HOW DOES THIS HELP YOU GAIN THE BEST PLAYERS FOR THE FUTURE?

All it does is give you the best picks. It doesnt take in account anything else.

We need to learn how to win before we can get better

Obviously there is still some luck and chance involved in drafting, particularly at that age. What I would say is that 2 are from the top 5, which I consider high picks. In addition, much more science goes into selecting players these days, which improves the chance of a stronger pick.

I'm sure, despite your opinion, you can see the value in high draft picks. Look at how Carlton is developing now, there is no question this helps.

By the way, I'm still not saying losing to get these picks is the way to go, I'm just saying that supporters who feel that way are entitled to their opinion, as you are.

In addition, I agree that instilling a winning culture is pivotal to creating success over a long period of time. However, performace is cyclical, and rebuilding is necessary in certain parts of a club's history, and top draft picks can be a crictical part of that process.

 

[bringbackschwarter5]

Arn't Drew Banfield and Des Headland the only no 1 picks to win a flag

 

[stabler]

The anti-taking sentiment in this board is particulalrly rife to the point where even mentioning Naitanui gets you a torrent of abuse. People should just relax, NO we should not tank, but if we do lose a game (like we did today) whats wrong with taking a little pleasure in being that much closer to the superfreak that is Nicholas Naitanui?
No one wants to be labled a 'carlton' but lets be honest, we aint setting the world on fire this year and there is not much to look forward to this year but the ongoing development of younger players and the possibility of top draft picks. Having a crack at fellow supporters is something i would expect to see on the Richmond board but not on here.

 

[dee-molishon]

The anti-taking sentiment in this board is particulalrly rife to the point where even mentioning Naitanui gets you a torrent of abuse. People should just relax, NO we should not tank, but if we do lose a game (like we did today) whats wrong with taking a little pleasure in being that much closer to the superfreak that is Nicholas Naitanui?
No one wants to be labled a 'carlton' but lets be honest, we aint setting the world on fire this year and there is not much to look forward to this year but the ongoing development of younger players and the possibility of top draft picks. Having a crack at fellow supporters is something i would expect to see on the Richmond board but not on here.

Well best you get used to it.

 

[cannons]

Well best you get used to it.

Oh dear. Surely you can appreciate the opinions of others, as that's what a discussion forum is for. I hope this was an attempt at humour.

 

[dee-molishon]

Oh dear. Surely you can appreciate the opinions of others, as that's what a discussion forum is for. I hope this was an attempt at humour.

Im all for debate. Thats why i said best you get used to it.

Popular opinion means nothing on here, everyones entitled to their own even if no one agrees.

 

[cannons]

Im all for debate. Thats why i said best you get used to it.

Popular opinion means nothing on here, everyones entitled to theres even if no one agrees.

I agree with you here. Its having a crack at fellow supporters which I disagree with.

 

[BROCKTHEROCK]

Its having a crack at fellow supporters which I disagree with.

Overall we all just want to see Brock holding up the premiership one day

 

[cannons]

Overall we all just want to see Brock holding up the premiership one day

This is a sentiment I whole heartedly agree with.

 

[Deestroy]

The abuse on this board ends here, report it and don't respond. Repeat offenders will be dealt with.