Free Agency Jack Silvagni - [Joins St Kilda as UFA]

[Doggy]

Apparently leaning towards the dogs

 

[GoEaglesGoSGIO]

Why? You have a better list than Collingwood going forward.

Darcy will be a superstar of the league.

He would also join a club which will be more welcoming of him too. Its clear from the players managers that Collingwoods elderly crew would resent Silvagni being there on big coin given he is earning money that they could be getting

Collingwood have overplayed ones hand here to the point that signing Silvagni will hurt the culture

 

[CCurnow3picks]

We're offering more as per our board ITK, but if he's best mates with Houston it will be hard to see him go anywhere else but Collingwood.

Houston could use the support!

If only for the 12 games/year JSOS graces the field free of injury.

 

[CCurnow3picks]

He has cooled on collingwood is the word today.

Collingwood has cooled on Collingwood.

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

SOS to the Dogs would be far more palatable for Blues fans. Would also ensure the Pies are absolutely cooked going forward relying on Moore and Frampton to defend their d50.

Most likely get us a better compo pick too as I think the Dogs have a bit more cap space to throw around.

 

[Pencil case]

SOS to the Dogs would be far more palatable for Blues fans. Would also ensure the Pies are absolutely cooked going forward relying on Moore and Frampton to defend their d50.

Most likely get us a better compo pick too as I think the Dogs have a bit more cap space to throw around.

I still hate the idea of offering him more than 600k, but if it happens I’ll back him in.

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

I still hate the idea of offering him more than 600k, but if it happens I’ll back him in.

Imo that is a bargain. Most will remember the pre 2025 JSOS when assessing what he's worth but if he maintains his form from this year he's worth every penny of 8-900k.

 

[Pencil case]

Imo that is a bargain. Most will remember the pre 2025 JSOS when assessing what he's worth but if he maintains his form from this year he's worth every penny of 8-900k.

Any club would be stupid to offer more than 750k. No way.

 

[Corn Cobbers]

SOS to the Dogs would be far more palatable for Blues fans. Would also ensure the Pies are absolutely cooked going forward relying on Moore and Frampton to defend their d50.

Most likely get us a better compo pick too as I think the Dogs have a bit more cap space to throw around.

He's not the only defender in the country Walshy wouldn't ensure anything

Agree he's better off going to the Dogs now, Fly botched it

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Any club would be stupid to offer more than 750k. No way.

New CBA 750k is SFA these days.

 

[Corn Cobbers]

New CBA 750k is SFA these days.

It's a fair bit to give to a guy who's had one good season and averages 14 games a year

 

[Pencil case]

New CBA 750k is SFA these days.

He barely makes it through a season. Decent defender sure, but offering 800-900k would be unhinged, St Kilda behaviour.

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

He barely makes it through a season. Decent defender sure, but offering 800-900k would be unhinged, St Kilda behaviour.

He won't get it this year due to past seasons but imo thats the level he was playing at based on actual performances this year. He was outstanding down back for us.

 

[Pencil case]

He won't get it this year due to past seasons but imo thats the level he was playing at based on actual performances this year. He was outstanding down back for us.

No doubt if he had a few (full) seasons like that he’d be worth a lot more than he is

 

[Atomboy]

Any one but Carlton it seems

Geez it must really stink down at Princes Park at the moment

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Geez it must really stink down at Princes Park at the moment

Ur literally having to offer a player the biggest contract in AFL history to try and pry him out of the joint. Either it aint too bad at Carlton or things are seriously grim at the Saints.

 

[Atomboy]

Ur literally having to offer a player the biggest contract in AFL history to try and pry him out of the joint. Either it aint too bad at Carlton or things are seriously grim at the Saints.

The most famous name at your club is looking to join your mortal enemies (or anyone who will take him) and it’s not too bad ?.

Whatever gets you through the day I guess.

 

[Corn Cobbers]

The most famous name at your club is looking to join your mortal enemies (or anyone who will take him) and it’s not too bad ?.

Whatever gets you through the day I guess.

Mass exodus followed by a full rebuild is "just a few tweaks" apparently

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Mass exodus followed by a full rebuild is "just a few tweaks" apparently

Not sure two players is considered a 'mass' exodus.

 

[TwiggleyFanClub]

JSOS doesn’t have a manager. He has a pimp.

 

[Pencil case]

Reported on Gettable that Jack has met with senior figures at the Western Bulldogs and that there’s a confidence he will be wearing red white and blue next year.

Riley also reported that although the gap has closed between Pies and Dogs for his signature, he thinks Pies have their nose slightly in front.

 

[Doggy]

Reported on Gettable that Jack has met with senior figures at the Western Bulldogs and that there’s a confidence he will be wearing red white and blue next year.

Riley also reported that although the gap has closed between Pies and Dogs for his signature, he thinks Pies have their nose slightly in front.

Shock horror

 

[seaweed]

Reported on Gettable that Jack has met with senior figures at the Western Bulldogs and that there’s a confidence he will be wearing red white and blue next year.

Riley also reported that although the gap has closed between Pies and Dogs for his signature, he thinks Pies have their nose slightly in front.

Ah, yes. He’s met with us, which means he’ll inevitably sign at Collingwood.

 

[The Nostradamus]

can see why the dogs chasing him hard after yesterday
north apparently also interested

as an UFA could be the first player to move clubs this year or draper

 

[TradeDraft]

Well could find out this week what he is going to do