James Sellar?

[HODGEYROAD]

Thier was big raps on him last year?? IM just wondering how he has been progressing? Has he been injured? Playing in the SANFL? Cheers

 

[Campbell's Chunky]

Thier was big raps on him last year?? IM just wondering how he has been progressing? Has he been injured? Playing in the SANFL? Cheers

Kicked 9 on the weekend.

 

[Cap]

9 touches on the weekend.

edited for something closer to reality

 

[flackjack]

Had OP apparently and has been quiet in the SANFL. Probably won't be ready to go for Adelaide until 2008.

He's a bottom age KPP, so 2008 was always the likely year for his debut. Can't wait though

 

[Mitch Power]

Thier was big raps on him last year?? IM just wondering how he has been progressing? Has he been injured? Playing in the SANFL? Cheers

He has been dropped this week to the Glenelg (SANFL) reserves. I can't believe that the Crows are playing Perrie ahead of this promising lad.

 

[Stiffy_18]

He has been dropped this week to the Glenelg (SANFL) reserves. I can't believe that the Crows are playing Perrie ahead of this promising lad.

If he was playing well enough to be pushing for AFL selection, he wouldn't be playing ressies this week

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

He has been dropped this week to the Glenelg (SANFL) reserves. I can't believe that the Crows are playing Perrie ahead of this promising lad.

Could be worse, we could be playing Damon White!

 

[Crow-mo]

Could be worse, we could be playing Damon White!

wash your mouth out

 

[CrowHop]

wash your mouth out

He should be deomted from mod status for even joking about that shouldnt he ?

 

[Captain Wacky]

Could be worse, we could be playing Damon White!

You might be next year.

 

[Kickin_Goals]

You might be next year.

Why? we have enough immobile players as it is they still tend to look better then him while they are carrying injury.
Why would Adelaide trade to pick up someone who struggles to make it into Port's lineup which is fielding 18-20 year olds down forward over him?

 

[Asgardian]

Dunno?

Ask Matt Rendell.

 

[Campbell's Chunky]

Dunno?

Ask Matt Rendell.

Your contributions to this board are second to none.

 

[AndrewJo]

He has been dropped this week to the Glenelg (SANFL) reserves. I can't believe that the Crows are playing Perrie ahead of this promising lad.

So if he was fit and ok for the AFL why would he be dropped to the Glenelg Reserves?..oops suddenly saw your club and realised why such an infantile comment was made....

 

[bus24]

Played well at CHB yesterday.

Had about 15 possesions, despite the ball not being down there much at all.

Lachy McGregor kicked 6 for the ressies yesterday I think. Rumour had it, he was going to be unveiled as our 2nd NSW scholarship player a while ago. Not sure if this is still the case.

 

[betterthanu]

Anyone reckon Crows might give him a gig at CHB for a couple of games this year??? I dont think hes ready to be given a game as a forward

 

[Campbell's Chunky]

Played well at CHB yesterday.

Had about 15 possesions, despite the ball not being down there much at all.

Lachy McGregor kicked 6 for the ressies yesterday I think. Rumour had it, he was going to be unveiled as our 2nd NSW scholarship player a while ago. Not sure if this is still the case.

What happened?

 

[Stiffy_18]

Anyone reckon Crows might give him a gig at CHB for a couple of games this year??? I dont think hes ready to be given a game as a forward

I was thinking about this a bit today after the game. I am just NOT a fan of Perrie in defence so if the situation arises where we need 3 tall defenders I would much rather go with Sellar in defence than Sarge.

To me Sarge is a forward or not in the team. Simple as that.

 

[Crowman32]

Even though Sellar seems not ready for AFL i would almost think about playing him at Centre half back and give him a few games. We are not going to make the finals so what have we got to lose.

 

[Cap]

Even though Sellar seems not ready for AFL i would almost think about playing him at Centre half back and give him a few games. We are not going to make the finals so what have we got to lose.

i'd agree - if he was in the glenelg league team - but he isn't so i think he can wait till next year

hinge, pfifer (sp) and co first

 

[bus24]

i'd agree - if he was in the glenelg league team - but he isn't so i think he can wait till next year

hinge, pfifer (sp) and co first

Hinge won't play another game for the AFC. He's been hopeless lately and will more than likely be de-listed.

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

I was thinking about this a bit today after the game. I am just NOT a fan of Perrie in defence so if the situation arises where we need 3 tall defenders I would much rather go with Sellar in defence than Sarge.

To me Sarge is a forward or not in the team. Simple as that.

I agree Stiffy that Perrie is a forward & we are better off dropping him than playing him in defence.

I gather Tredrea isn't playing next week, so that offsets Rutten's unlikely return. So there shouldn't be any need for a 3rd tall defender next week. We will need some smart mids though for Ebert & Motlop.

 

[Cap]

had my edit postbutton not taken 5 minutes to load

i would have had Meese up there as well, who cares how he is going atm - we need to see if its worth keeping him

 

[bus24]

I was thinking about this a bit today after the game. I am just NOT a fan of Perrie in defence so if the situation arises where we need 3 tall defenders I would much rather go with Sellar in defence than Sarge.

Would be excellent for him to play on a quality AFL forward. He would learn a lot.

Because he's only learning to play as a forward, he sometimes gets a bit lost.

Would be a great idea and I hope he gets a couple of games at CHB before the year is out.

Have I mentioned how huge he is? No way he's 195cm, hell I'm nearly 194 and he towers over me.

 

[Mitch Power]

So if he was fit and ok for the AFL why would he be dropped to the Glenelg Reserves?..

If he's fit to play for Glenelg senior side the week before, then one would think that form rather than fitness would be the reason he got dropped...otherwise why play him at all if he is unfit?